Hey! I don’t know if you’ve already been told but Sagutoyas has been exposed for allegedly grooming and having a relationship with a minor (there are screenshots that have been posted on YT and I think Twitter too), so I’d recommend not using their art nor giving them credit, I mean no disrespect or hate, just thought I’d let you know
I totally agree with you but some people share their opinions about she counting as a villain (hollyleaf) and I had no time I only had those clips with me to and I had no time
@@Th3.H0n3y.K4t😂 i’ve told my dad and my mom all the warrior cats books i’ve read and every time i see a cat, i say “do you wanna know what that cat looks like? WHITESTORM” and then one day i asked my dad “Dad, do you want to know what warrior cat looks like that cat?” And he just said “Firestar” and i be like “HOW DID YOU KNOW😤😭”
Alr bout to list reasons Holly isn't a villan lol wish me luck 1 she died saving ivypool from hawkfrost 2 The 2 "evil" things she did were morally grey at most since revealing the secret was what starclan said was good ( starclan is stupid but still ) and killing ashfur was just to protect her brothers and squirrel 3 main character lol 4 she's loyal to her clan, returned when needed, follows the code (mostly ) through and through and always tries to do the right thing HERE YA GO I HAD TO BE THE ONE TO DO IT * Edit : got i really started a war zone in the comments
I totally agree with you but some people share their opinions about she counting as a villain (hollyleaf) and I had no time I only had those clips with me to and I had no time
I’m still 12, obsessed with the series! I started reading it in 4th/5th grade (I remember reading Thunder and Shadow I’m pretty sure a couple years ago, I hardly remember it but I think that was the first book I actually read). In 5th, I started Into the Wild and Fire and Ice, I got bored though and stopped reading them for a while. I’m in 7th now (yes, I reread Into the Wild/Fire and Ice, along with the other TPB books) and I’m currently reading Leopardstar’s Honor because I skipped a few add-ons in the arc one timeline, yea if u hadn’t guessed my goal is to read EVERY SINGLE BOOK in the series. (I’m actually on Moonrise in the timeline, finished Midnight a few weeks ago and then Firestar’s Quest and SkyClan’s Destiny) I absolutely love Warriors, I’m writing a fanfic right now as well!! (It’s based on my main in WCUE, Hazelfern.)
Roses are Red Violets aren't blue Ballerina's are dancers Back in my day the comment section had answers Edit: the amount of likes i got by copy and paste is making my brain malfunction
Alright, technically their both good, here’s why : (Hollyleaf) 1. Killing Ashfur was only to protect her brothers 2. She revealed the secret but like, it isn’t really evil, right? 3. Main character 🥺 4. She was very loyal to her clan and very kind-hearted. (Feathertail) 1. She died saving the Tribe of Rushing Water from Sharptooth. 2. She was very good-hearted and loyal to her clan. ❤ 3. I have not seen a single book with her being evil. This is just my opinion so yeah. ( Forgot to mention I think Hollyleaf saved Ivypool? I don’t really know- thanks for the likes btw )
I started with wings of fire and was hesitant about trying warriors. Warriors is almost as good as wings of Fire in my opinion as long as you have the time to read the books :)
I understamd this is the creators opinion on hollyleaf but to anyone confused in the the book hollyleaf isn't portrayed as a villain so your option isn't right or wrong ( and dovewing isn't the villain) also the first pic of 'hollyleaf' I think was acually dovewing
Hey! Holly and Swallow are not villains! Holly, although she killed quite a lot, but ... At the same time, she is a good cat and did not want herself! And Swallow, on the contrary, saved a friend!
If there are new readers that are wondering: Feather’tail was sweet and nice to everyone always. She was kind to cats from other clans even if they were mean. She also saved a tribe she hadn’t known for long from a mountain lion which you saw. She died a hero. Edit:forgot to mention she’s my favorite warrior cat, I even made a video on her lol
Glad people recognised Holly has done enough to be considered a villian lmao. 1. Attempted to kill her mother 2. Murdered Ashfur (for a good reason ig) 3. Got mad at Squilf for doing nothing wrong 4. Revealed Squilf and Leaf’s secret to all of the clans (it may not be that evil, but it was immature) 5. Annoying as hell (not a reason but yknow lol) And before you attack me, I’m only up to The Fourth Apprentice, so I don’t know if Holly redeemed herself yet.
Late, but Hollyleaf does redeem herself. (Spoilers) Hawkfrost was trying to kill Ivypool for betraying the dark forest, but Hollyleaf saves her, while dying. She also helped defend an attack from a different clan because she knew the way through the tunnels.
It’s not feathertail, when they showed her in the short, there was a mountain lion and she flung herself at a rock that had a pointy end, causing it to fall. Which impaled herself, and stabbed the Moutan lion killing it, just to save other cats. And btw it’s not a show, it’s a book, series.
I'm still reading about the Three. Where I'm reading, it was only recently revealed that hollyleag may not have been crushed by rocks falling in the tunnels.
Hollyleaf is a anti-villain, she’s still my favorite character, she just did the wrong thing but her actions were understandable. She was redeeming towards the end, sure. But it doesn’t change the fact she went against the law (starclans rule) and murdered a cat.
Sadly I haven't been able to read the Warrior books because of school I do not have time to read books most of the time because I have to finish all the homework they give us
. Me role playing with out reading the books. Everyone thinks I have tho- I have the books, I just don’t have time to read them rn! Will in the summer! .
I definitely count her as a villain. (my opinion.) she killed ashfur then did the same thing he was going to do. even if she self-exiled, exile is forever, and she came back, and didn’t take the blame for it. she may have saved ivypool but that doesn’t redeem her.
This is kinda weird because neither one of them are villains Hollyleaf was just angry, and she was just trying to protect her family from Ashfur... She also protected Ivypool from Hawkfrost. As for trying to kill Leafpool, she was just pissed off that she would lie to her her entire life... And Feathertail protected Crowpaw and the Tribe of Rushing Water from Sharptooth
as someone who is newer to warrior cats basicly the whole book has murder ngl so i say none of them cause the book has over like 10 cats that murder a lot :P
I mean, she wasn’t trying to be a villian. She wasn’t even trying to kill him. After it she was haunted by her actions too. So, neither in my opinion but I do understand why that would be thought.
I haven't read it lol and yet I have no idea who's the villain 😭 Ik Scourge and Tigerstar are villains tho! My younger sis never shuts up about how much she dislikes them 😂
My friend : "uhhh uhhhhh uhhhh uhhh uhhh uhhhh uhhhhhhh-🙂 Fireheart....?" Me: "NO YOU DUM DUMP." me: " FIRE HEART IS NOT A VILLAN...." me: "read the bookies more bestie🙂✨️✨️✨️✨️"
Tbh Hollyleaf is the villain. Though she did good things, killing a cat and making everyone go against squirrelflight and leafpool wasn't exactly what a 'Hero' would do-
I know warrior cats some people say it’s not for kids because there’s a lot of violence but in Puss in boots there’s a lot of violence too like blood and all that stuff ._.
I'm also confused because feathertail died. But wasn't a feel in and then Hallelujah? She was upset that her parents wouldn't let her be her. So I really am confused too on who the villain is here.
![[Lets Art] Main WC Clan - FogClan (Part 1)](/img/n.gif)
Credits in read more and opinion!
Clip one- ScooterScones, Osinka
Clip two- Ginjaninjaowo, TheWisestDino
Clip three- Dark-Yard
Clip four- Dark-Yard
Clip five- DaveThyQueen, LenisLynx, FluffyCatSkye
Clip six- FadedKat, KimSxxiny, TheWisestDino
Clip seven- Sagutoyas
Clip eight- Sagutoyas
SPOILER:
______________________
Answer: none.
Hey! I don’t know if you’ve already been told but Sagutoyas has been exposed for allegedly grooming and having a relationship with a minor (there are screenshots that have been posted on YT and I think Twitter too), so I’d recommend not using their art nor giving them credit, I mean no disrespect or hate, just thought I’d let you know
I am confused. Holly leaf and feather tail are both not villains???
I totally agree with you but some people share their opinions about she counting as a villain (hollyleaf) and I had no time I only had those clips with me to and I had no time
@@PARISCHARMX0X that is fully understandable like how brambleclaw is sometimes considered a villain for killing his brother
@@StormShadow365 mhm but Since it turned out that way its gonna be a twist where its supposed to be no villian in the video/
It’s ashfur
@@Rose-warriors they literally have their names at the bottom of the screen
NO WAY HOLLYLEAF IS A VILAIN....SHE IS MY FAV CHARACTER💀🤌❤️
My mom literally said "neither!"
Neither ARE villains. Holly leaf was just so confused and angry
Same! I LOVE her and she isn’t a villain. Like ok she killed one cat but still!!
@@Th3.H0n3y.K4t😂 i’ve told my dad and my mom all the warrior cats books i’ve read and every time i see a cat, i say “do you wanna know what that cat looks like? WHITESTORM” and then one day i asked my dad “Dad, do you want to know what warrior cat looks like that cat?” And he just said “Firestar” and i be like “HOW DID YOU KNOW😤😭”
@@BrownKitten-tn7sp nice
Pov: You dunno Warrior Cats and this popped up on your fyp
And yes i liked my own comment
FR
I liked your comment 🧡
It's a book series based on cats forming clans and living in a forest split into territories, I'm in love with the series 😍
fr
Same
Alr bout to list reasons Holly isn't a villan lol wish me luck
1 she died saving ivypool from hawkfrost
2 The 2 "evil" things she did were morally grey at most since revealing the secret was what starclan said was good ( starclan is stupid but still ) and killing ashfur was just to protect her brothers and squirrel
3 main character lol
4 she's loyal to her clan, returned when needed, follows the code (mostly ) through and through and always tries to do the right thing
HERE YA GO I HAD TO BE THE ONE TO DO IT
* Edit : got i really started a war zone in the comments
I totally agree with you but some people share their opinions about she counting as a villain (hollyleaf) and I had no time I only had those clips with me to and I had no time
Thanks for spoiling 🙄
I honestly think that out of ashfur and hollyleaf, ashfur is the bad guy
@@marcelinasochacka5047so why you read it?
She can still be a villain even as a main character, lol.
People who read the books when they were kids practically growing up with em(me included)
👇
I'm not in my teenhood yet and my mom bought me a warrior cats book, so excited for it to arrive!
I’m still 12, obsessed with the series! I started reading it in 4th/5th grade (I remember reading Thunder and Shadow I’m pretty sure a couple years ago, I hardly remember it but I think that was the first book I actually read). In 5th, I started Into the Wild and Fire and Ice, I got bored though and stopped reading them for a while. I’m in 7th now (yes, I reread Into the Wild/Fire and Ice, along with the other TPB books) and I’m currently reading Leopardstar’s Honor because I skipped a few add-ons in the arc one timeline, yea if u hadn’t guessed my goal is to read EVERY SINGLE BOOK in the series. (I’m actually on Moonrise in the timeline, finished Midnight a few weeks ago and then Firestar’s Quest and SkyClan’s Destiny) I absolutely love Warriors, I’m writing a fanfic right now as well!! (It’s based on my main in WCUE, Hazelfern.)
@@blopblop_idiotwhat book is it? (What’s the name, i recommend it’s into the wild)
Me having the the first 5 series and the prequel-
Feathertail's death was so sad I cried sm during that book- along with Dappletail 😭😭😭
Bro💀
@@WLHLDV-?
Same
@@PURPLE_GUY50he's the villain
@@LavenderGachaEditz ok
If Hollyleaf was the villain, she would kick dark Forrest behind.
I told people more then once that some people call her a villian, I dont mean this rude
@@PARISCHARMX0X That’s ok, she’s probably more villain-like then any other warrior cat.
@@Kali_WCtiger star? ash fur? scourge? thisteclaw? hawkfrost? hollyleaf just wanted vengance
@@Aaliyah_Random2 I meant she is more villain-like then any other hero.
@@Kali_WCOHH
Roses are Red
Violets aren't blue
Ballerina's are dancers
Back in my day the comment section had answers
Edit: the amount of likes i got by copy and paste is making my brain malfunction
good poem🤩
@@-LAVANDERCAT- thenks
It’s Hollyleaf, but most ppl don’t see her as a villain
@@simplynyxen ummm ....we were talking about the poem not the video. im not trying be rude but are you blind😐
@@-LAVANDERCAT-they weren’t talking too you. They were telling stars the answer.
Alright, technically their both good, here’s why :
(Hollyleaf) 1. Killing Ashfur was only to protect her brothers
2. She revealed the secret but like, it isn’t really evil, right?
3. Main character 🥺
4. She was very loyal to her clan and very kind-hearted.
(Feathertail) 1. She died saving the Tribe of Rushing Water from Sharptooth.
2. She was very good-hearted and loyal to her clan. ❤
3. I have not seen a single book with her being evil.
This is just my opinion so yeah.
( Forgot to mention I think Hollyleaf saved Ivypool? I don’t really know-
thanks for the likes btw )
I agree
People argue that she tried to kill leafpool, but she was angry, stressed, and not thinking straight.
Holly leaf didn’t have any sisters. Just lion blaze and hay feather
she wasnt thinking straight
she was thinking gay :D@@simplynyxen
@@_urlocaltherian_JYNXAY_ I'd say hollyleaf deserves to be lesbian I ship her with cinderheart
being a main character does automatically make you good
i dunno i dont know warriorcats 😭
but i might start watching it 🤨🤨
uhm u cant watch it but u can read 180+ books
I'm a Wings Of Fire fan and I have never read Warrior Cats, but it seems like a great book.
I started with wings of fire and was hesitant about trying warriors. Warriors is almost as good as wings of Fire in my opinion as long as you have the time to read the books :)
@@GinaTheRainwing r u my twin? Same thing happened to me.
Challenge: chose between being a SandWing and a MudWing
@@TYSM_FOR_17_SUBS
mudwings have nothing good going for them.
@@dtheall86 true
Fan of both here could not pick
hmm, heather tail maybe?
(i don’t read warrior cats but it looks so fun and sad at the same time!!)
what IS warrior cats
a book series, it’s rlly good
Yeah it’s about death,romance,battles,conflicts,clans,murder, rules,borders,travel,traditions, etc
You should type it into CZcams it will tell you for sure
Idk, never read warrior cats.. idk if it's even available in lebanon
None of them are villains,it’s a trick question.
@@QueerRattt_ ohhhh thx for letting me know
Hollyleaf is not really a villain but can be considered one since she killed ashfur
I understamd this is the creators opinion on hollyleaf but to anyone confused in the the book hollyleaf isn't portrayed as a villain so your option isn't right or wrong ( and dovewing isn't the villain) also the first pic of 'hollyleaf' I think was acually dovewing
Hey! Holly and Swallow are not villains! Holly, although she killed quite a lot, but ... At the same time, she is a good cat and did not want herself! And Swallow, on the contrary, saved a friend!
She didn’t kill a lot what do you mean? She only killed ashfur because he was dangerous
If there are new readers that are wondering: Feather’tail was sweet and nice to everyone always. She was kind to cats from other clans even if they were mean. She also saved a tribe she hadn’t known for long from a mountain lion which you saw. She died a hero.
Edit:forgot to mention she’s my favorite warrior cat, I even made a video on her lol
Plot twist... Its actually Tigerstar
True feather tail saved the tribe
And was holly leaf really a villain?
Ima send this to my non-warrior friends !! ❤ Amazing edit
That’s a weird way to say friends 🤔
@@The_Odd_Beetle OMG I MEANT NON WARRIOR BRO HOW DID I JUST REALISE LOLLLL
@@contemporary_cat wait you said the same thing twice? I’m confused
@@The_Odd_Beetle I edited it, it use to be non-ex lol
@@contemporary_cat I still have no idea what that means😭
Glad people recognised Holly has done enough to be considered a villian lmao.
1. Attempted to kill her mother
2. Murdered Ashfur (for a good reason ig)
3. Got mad at Squilf for doing nothing wrong
4. Revealed Squilf and Leaf’s secret to all of the clans (it may not be that evil, but it was immature)
5. Annoying as hell (not a reason but yknow lol)
And before you attack me, I’m only up to The Fourth Apprentice, so I don’t know if Holly redeemed herself yet.
Late, but Hollyleaf does redeem herself.
(Spoilers)
Hawkfrost was trying to kill Ivypool for betraying the dark forest, but Hollyleaf saves her, while dying.
She also helped defend an attack from a different clan because she knew the way through the tunnels.
No hate, but I don’t personally consider Holly leaf a villain like I understand why but still
Fr
I agree with y’all 100% but in some videos some people call Hollyleaf a villian? But thats ok I had no time to make this so I just chose clips
THIS ISNT EASY holly leaf isnt a villain 🥲
Thats the point 🤭
@@PARISCHARMX0Xso feathertail da villain?
@@KaganLemi none are
I haven’t watched it yet but I’m in LOVEEEEEEEEEE with cats so yea
It's a book series, those are fan animations
O thx for tellin me
i have NEVER read or watched warrior cats so i’m guessing.. holly leaf maybe?
Neither of them are they just made a mistake
@@FernsongFan oh, thanks for telling me.
Never let them know Ur next move:i haven't read it-
Same😅
Hollyleaf i think
Edit: i read the comments and relized i was wrong 😅
𝚠𝚘𝚠! I really wanna read warriar cats! is the villian feathertail? But they both look innocent.
Neither are villains, but Hollyleaf did kill somebody to protect other people
they are both innocent
I know they aren’t evil but I have a feeling they mean Holly Leaf
Rip my who have no friends 😢😂
I haven’t read it so I’m guessing feather tail is the villain idk how I just feel like it so much ^^
plot twist - Neither of them are villains
People who cried when reading/ watching feather tails
Death
☠️
👇
FeatherTail? Idkk I have never watched Warrior cats
It’s not feathertail, when they showed her in the short, there was a mountain lion and she flung herself at a rock that had a pointy end, causing it to fall. Which impaled herself, and stabbed the Moutan lion killing it, just to save other cats. And btw it’s not a show, it’s a book, series.
Omg i love warriors and sso were literally like- broskies 😭😭
Is this a show/movie/book??? Which one
I haven't read warrior cats, but my friend is obsessed- heres my guess...
IDK 😭
They are both good. I’ve read most of the books and seen a lot of the videos and they were both good
AskFur is in the HollyLeaf clip so ✨AshFur✨
I'm still reading about the Three. Where I'm reading, it was only recently revealed that hollyleag may not have been crushed by rocks falling in the tunnels.
You should do this but who had the saddest death
These two are 2 of my favorites from warrior cats❤❤❤ and love the edit I have 3 cats bwh..😅
I have not read warrior cats yrt but i think frather tail is the villain
Hollyleaf is a anti-villain, she’s still my favorite character, she just did the wrong thing but her actions were understandable.
She was redeeming towards the end, sure. But it doesn’t change the fact she went against the law (starclans rule) and murdered a cat.
I guess Hollyleaf? But, nether of them seem like a villain to me.
plot twist - Neither of them are villains
Feather tail is the villain
@@LavenderGachaEditz no she isn't 💀
@@WW2_Timeline_Animator141 but i just know that hollyleaf aint
@@LavenderGachaEditz feather tail died to kill sharp tooth a mountain lion who was trying to kill her bf
I dont watch Warrior Cats! But when I saw this video..I'm gonna need someone to explain why they both dosent seem like a villian? Who is the villian??
Sadly I haven't been able to read the Warrior books because of school I do not have time to read books most of the time because I have to finish all the homework they give us
I haven’t read warrior cats in forever, so I’ve forgotten, but hollyleaf looks like such a baddie so I think it’s feather tail 😋
Ahh I don't know anything about warrior cats but this is such an amazing edit!
I didn't read them but I wish I did tbh because it seems like a great saga
I don’t know what it is but I’m going feather tail
I was like this
Wait hollyleaf is not a villian and the other one was trying to save its self from danger
I really want to get a
The books! One question does it swear in the books?
Holly leaf? Idk
Edit: i promise i didn’t read the comments i was just saying
I read about half of one of the books, it was in my school. I think they got rid of it for some reason. Over all it was good
I’m that friend I’ve never seen this I thought it was a game 😭😭
Main characters can be turned into villains, but in this case hollyleaf is more of an anti-hero imo. Not exactly evil but not good either
I’m guessing feather tail?
I dont know who the villain is but i an getting into warrior cats, so far im on book 1 chapter 5 (the old books not the remastered ones)
I don't really consider Hollyleaf a villain, but I do see how some do
I’d say Hollyleaf. Feathertail is fine, though they both are technically not villains. IDK, I’m only in The Darkest Hour. Correct me if I’m wrong.
Am I the only one who's only heard of the books
There is only books.
. Me role playing with out reading the books.
Everyone thinks I have tho-
I have the books, I just don’t have time to read them rn! Will in the summer! .
Hollyleaf is no villian, she is loyal and even though she might look evil she tries to protect her family. ❤ Hollyleaf fans ! 👇
None of them are villains, i mean everyone who has read warrior cats knows that right ?
i think feathertail (i havent watched)
Feather tail?
plot twist - Neither of them are villains
Feather tail I’m pretty sure even tho I didn’t even read or watched Warrior Cats 🐱
I definitely count her as a villain. (my opinion.) she killed ashfur then did the same thing he was going to do. even if she self-exiled, exile is forever, and she came back, and didn’t take the blame for it. she may have saved ivypool but that doesn’t redeem her.
This is kinda weird because neither one of them are villains
Hollyleaf was just angry, and she was just trying to protect her family from Ashfur... She also protected Ivypool from Hawkfrost. As for trying to kill Leafpool, she was just pissed off that she would lie to her her entire life...
And Feathertail protected Crowpaw and the Tribe of Rushing Water from Sharptooth
(i havent read warrior cats) maybe feathertail?
as someone who is newer to warrior cats basicly the whole book has murder ngl so i say none of them cause the book has over like 10 cats that murder a lot :P
Feather tail? I have not read/seen anything about Warrior cats I just play it on Roblox to rp with people
nope, none are but the creator prob wanted to say Hollyleaf is a villain
Ohhh ok
I have read warrior cats and still don’t know 😭😭😭
I in warrior cats leave family😢
Feathertail? I haven’t watched or read any of it 😭
Feathertail was killed like the second i met her, and hollyleaf litteraly is like main character in power of three
Where can you watch this ? It looks cool
I just finished reading book 6 (the prophecies begin) and I need to read the rest before I understand these 😭
I mean, she wasn’t trying to be a villian. She wasn’t even trying to kill him. After it she was haunted by her actions too. So, neither in my opinion but I do understand why that would be thought.
Blue star and fire star and cooked star and holly leaf are my fav characters
I have not watched this show before but I’m guessing feather tail
Both seem pretty innocent but am curious
I’m that friend who hasn’t read it (btw since I prefer things children and “clean” is warrior cats ok for at LEAST 12- ?)
Feather tail? Idk maybe but they died so…..
As someone who hasn’t read warrior cats , I think it’s hollyleaf
I haven't read it lol and yet I have no idea who's the villain 😭 Ik Scourge and Tigerstar are villains tho! My younger sis never shuts up about how much she dislikes them 😂
I haven’t read it before but I think it might be entertaining
But they both are not villains? Oohhh i got it! Its a trick!!
My friend : "uhhh uhhhhh uhhhh uhhh uhhh uhhhh uhhhhhhh-🙂
Fireheart....?"
Me: "NO YOU DUM DUMP."
me: " FIRE HEART IS NOT A VILLAN...."
me: "read the bookies more bestie🙂✨️✨️✨️✨️"
Where can i watch warrior cats
Tbh Hollyleaf is the villain. Though she did good things, killing a cat and making everyone go against squirrelflight and leafpool wasn't exactly what a 'Hero' would do-
I know warrior cats some people say it’s not for kids because there’s a lot of violence but in Puss in boots there’s a lot of violence too like blood and all that stuff ._.
Feather tail? (I haven’t read it yet)
Nope
To all the people who read warrior cats, tell me where I can find it! Is it good?
My time zone is Chicago!!!! (Fr it’s beautiful there if it’s snowy)
I'm also confused because feathertail died. But wasn't a feel in and then Hallelujah? She was upset that her parents wouldn't let her be her. So I really am confused too on who the villain is here.
I honestly i see hollyleaf as a villain btw but still love her and her siblings
I've heard a little bit about warroir cat's but i just brought the first book into the wild and hoping to get the whole series one day
I watch every single warrior cats