Can't you see... How lives were destroyed Of the good kinds, And who's to be held accountable? I'm trying my best here, Can't you see? While they live their lives And having fun, While the suffering continues At the hand of their sadistic mind... Can't you see? You say my lyrics are simple, Guilty as charge, You say to be kind to me, Well look, I cannot, Guilty as charge. When their not kind to me, Can't you see?
I have a mental breakdown due to disagreements with my Dad, differences, lack of understanding and not accepting the way I am and do and feel things..and still having to be grateful (intrinsically)...bc he's my Dad! This song is my absolute favourite of Madonna and when I googled its covers I saw that the artist I adore the most did one of that song. I can't, I fall down in tears. Thanks so much 🖤
Lyrics: You're saying my songs are sad Guilty as charged That I'm too easily let Guilty as charged You say I smoke too much Guilty as charged You say I snap like a weak man Guilty as charged woo woo I'm trying my best here Can't you see? I'm trying my best here Can't you see? I'm trying my best here Can't you see? Can't you see? You say I stay out too late Guilty as charged Sleep my days away Guilty as charged You say I smoke too much Guilty as charged You say I snap like a weak man Guilty as charged woo woo
While Madonna's original focuses on the actual pain caused by her father, Sia's version focuses on the moment of finally forgiving her father for all the pained he had caused her, on the moment of relief after 15 years of silence between them, which is reflected in this instrumental.
Ok I haven't heard the original but let's agree original is better.But those who are commenting about Vocal is the dumbest creature on Earth.Sia's vocal is like mile better than Madonna with wider range & varieties
No! Sorry Sia, you ARE an artist BUT this is a song only the original MADONNA. Can do. Madonna’s pain and emotion bleeds through this song! But as a radio dj, I can tell you...emotion is gone, it’s all pop and sex....and really Madonna had a lot to do with that too
Feels like you're singing while drying your hair with a phone, no pathos, the energy of singing is keeping the emotions inside to turn them in something different, in the anxiousness to show your pain you throw them out in a single moment, burning up all your heart has to tell. The voice of Madonna has a superb crescendo which comes out from her low profile interpretation, only her can achieve such an intuitive level.
Guys, I don’t know if that’s because people from old times sang like it was struggling not to cry. But I really like this version. Madonna literally sounds like she’s about to cry, mainly in lower notes. This version sounds much more contemporary (of course). You can catch in the back instruments lots of details that are hidden during the song. It’s not as deep as Madonna’s version and you won’t feel the same sad vibe here because as I said is hidden as a Children Funny Song.
What kind of fuckery is this? Madonna's version (the original) was emotionally gripping, and you really felt it in her voice. This version feels soulless and shallow, with no emotion at all whatsoever.
Madonna's songs lists over 50 different collections of covers in many music styles: bossa nova, hard core punk, industrial, lullabies. And that’s not even counting the many different one-off versions that have popped up on albums and singles around the music world for the length of Madonna’s long reign on the public consciousness.
I love this. It's done in true Sia style, and of course it's going to be totally different to Madonna. So what. It's also obviously modernised; as expected for a song that was released 26 years ago. Let's face it, Madonna's version was not a big hit; it was her first ever single not to go top 10 in the USA. If this version by Sia is released as a single I hope it does well. I'm a HUGE Madonna fan but we have to be realistic about it.
+Chris Watts A non-hit versus a higher-charting version of a song does not a better version make. While this isn't bad, it lacks the emotional depth that the original possesses regardless of the commercial accessibility of this one.
A song is not good for something like it's chart performance. Is good for the musical quality in itself. If not, we could say "La Macarena" is the best song in history
It is a tad too bubbly for my taste. Doesn't hit you right in the soul and make you feel like you need to punch something to feel like a man again like Madonnas version. Also I recall reading a comment that said someone else thought Madonna did her version after this one? Which comment is it I gotta see this.
No competition. Love Sia. She's not trying to copy Madonna. Those who love Madonna won't like this version but that's okay. We love Sia just as much and like this version. Love Sia
I love Madonna. But I absolutely love this version too! To me, Madonna's original is more haunting if that makes sense. But Sia's version is beautiful too. Both are incredible.
Someone commented that Sia wrote this for Madonna and Imma be shady and not direct respond to them.. BUT Sia was like 14 when Madonna came out with the song 'Oh Father' and.. No Sia did not have a career back then. Ofc Sia may have brought more life to the song, but Madonna debut'd it.
Sia started writing songswhen she was 13. She wrote a song about aids at that age. So yes she didnt write this one but she could have. Dont underestimate her..
Can't you see... How lives were destroyed Of the good kinds, And who's to be held accountable? I'm trying my best here, Can't you see? While they live their lives And having fun, While the suffering continues At the hand of their sadistic mind... Can't you see? You say my lyrics are simple, Guilty as charge, You say to be kind to me, Well look, I cannot, Guilty as charge. When their not kind to me, Can't you see?
Shit
Wow. This sucks.
I have a mental breakdown due to disagreements with my Dad, differences, lack of understanding and not accepting the way I am and do and feel things..and still having to be grateful (intrinsically)...bc he's my Dad! This song is my absolute favourite of Madonna and when I googled its covers I saw that the artist I adore the most did one of that song. I can't, I fall down in tears. Thanks so much 🖤
Amo
🔥🤯 💜 WOW..! 🤯🔥 YOU ARE BEAUTIFUL. DAAM! AWESOME FIND..! 🤩🥵🌶
Lyrics: You're saying my songs are sad Guilty as charged That I'm too easily let Guilty as charged You say I smoke too much Guilty as charged You say I snap like a weak man Guilty as charged woo woo I'm trying my best here Can't you see? I'm trying my best here Can't you see? I'm trying my best here Can't you see? Can't you see? You say I stay out too late Guilty as charged Sleep my days away Guilty as charged You say I smoke too much Guilty as charged You say I snap like a weak man Guilty as charged woo woo
La versión de Madonna es desgarradora me gusta más Madonna ya que me ha provocado llanto y nostalgia gracias MADONNA
Sure, guys the original may be better but that's no reason to bully Sia for "copying" Madonna. She made a COVER!
While Madonna's original focuses on the actual pain caused by her father, Sia's version focuses on the moment of finally forgiving her father for all the pained he had caused her, on the moment of relief after 15 years of silence between them, which is reflected in this instrumental.
Ok I haven't heard the original but let's agree original is better.But those who are commenting about Vocal is the dumbest creature on Earth.Sia's vocal is like mile better than Madonna with wider range & varieties
We all agree that Madonna's version is better.
No! Sorry Sia, you ARE an artist BUT this is a song only the original MADONNA. Can do. Madonna’s pain and emotion bleeds through this song! But as a radio dj, I can tell you...emotion is gone, it’s all pop and sex....and really Madonna had a lot to do with that too
this is so beautiful,I’m literally in tears.A good cover is a cover that brings something different from the original
Shouldn’t of been touched disappointed
ughhhhhhhhhhhhhh no no, her voice sucks. ONLY MADONNA CAN SING THIS WITH PURE EMOTION
Sia with a sore throat has better voice than Madonna. Deal with it.
@@vukkicos5688 u eastern euros know shit
Feels like you're singing while drying your hair with a phone, no pathos, the energy of singing is keeping the emotions inside to turn them in something different, in the anxiousness to show your pain you throw them out in a single moment, burning up all your heart has to tell. The voice of Madonna has a superb crescendo which comes out from her low profile interpretation, only her can achieve such an intuitive level.
I love so Sia she is a really diamond her voice is the best ..her talent incredible but ok the madonna version is Better ..Sia and Madonna 2 Queens !
Esto es la versiom manaos del tema de madonna
Poor Sia, nobody understood the children song reference.
Guys, I don’t know if that’s because people from old times sang like it was struggling not to cry. But I really like this version. Madonna literally sounds like she’s about to cry, mainly in lower notes. This version sounds much more contemporary (of course). You can catch in the back instruments lots of details that are hidden during the song. It’s not as deep as Madonna’s version and you won’t feel the same sad vibe here because as I said is hidden as a Children Funny Song.
That's why today people likes to show emotions, too much... dear friend Art hasn't edges, it's out of time, but this cover is only out of Art
Erre Gi How dare you say this!?? This is so emotional and conceptual, I don’t think you understand contemporary art.
this version is better,original she could’ve made it a sad ballad too but covers mean making smth different
Obsessed Furler this version is shit. no emotion, awful instrumental. Madonna was literally crying in her version
I think this is my fav of his songs
Lindo ❤️
What kind of fuckery is this? Madonna's version (the original) was emotionally gripping, and you really felt it in her voice. This version feels soulless and shallow, with no emotion at all whatsoever.
do u have the chords to this?
Yes please or just the instrumental
What a garbage comments section. Both versions are nice for different reasons. Period. Ok?
JackStrait this is so emotionless 😐
Madonna's songs lists over 50 different collections of covers in many music styles: bossa nova, hard core punk, industrial, lullabies. And that’s not even counting the many different one-off versions that have popped up on albums and singles around the music world for the length of Madonna’s long reign on the public consciousness.
Sia has a great voice. But lacks emotion. Madonna wins in this one.
both are awesome artists i love both
beautifull voice Jamie woon <3 im feeling you
the whole world is better hearing your beautiful voice , calms our hearts and brings joyful tears we all love you kiddo
One of the most beautiful Madonna's song with one of the most beautiful voices.
make me cry
On all Haters: NEVER COMPARE ARTISTS. it´s like you compare souls. f you
I love this. It's done in true Sia style, and of course it's going to be totally different to Madonna. So what. It's also obviously modernised; as expected for a song that was released 26 years ago. Let's face it, Madonna's version was not a big hit; it was her first ever single not to go top 10 in the USA. If this version by Sia is released as a single I hope it does well. I'm a HUGE Madonna fan but we have to be realistic about it.
+Chris Watts A non-hit versus a higher-charting version of a song does not a better version make. While this isn't bad, it lacks the emotional depth that the original possesses regardless of the commercial accessibility of this one.
A song is not good for something like it's chart performance. Is good for the musical quality in itself. If not, we could say "La Macarena" is the best song in history
Love this x
i love sia, don´t get me wrong but when i read the title first i was expecting something way better than this.
I'm not a sia's hater but Madonna's song (the original) is incredibly better.
I love SIA but this is just over complicated and looses the meaning of the song
Sia made justice to the song :) Great
It is a tad too bubbly for my taste. Doesn't hit you right in the soul and make you feel like you need to punch something to feel like a man again like Madonnas version. Also I recall reading a comment that said someone else thought Madonna did her version after this one? Which comment is it I gotta see this.
Took a song with a mountain of feeling....and put it to happy sounding elevator music. Utter failure.
madonnas is far better
willjames881 Tempo of Madonna's is slower and more touching, but Sia's voice is far better.
quebarasu madonnas track has more heart Sia's version is missing something but its a cover at the end of the day i dislike cover of many songs
+willjames881 There was a magnificent processing.
+willjames881 yup much better. im surprised. i like sias creativity but she probably shouldve left this one alone lol
+willjames881 yea but some are great like "forever young" and "its my life"
No competition. Love Sia. She's not trying to copy Madonna. Those who love Madonna won't like this version but that's okay. We love Sia just as much and like this version. Love Sia
I love Madonna. But I absolutely love this version too! To me, Madonna's original is more haunting if that makes sense. But Sia's version is beautiful too. Both are incredible.
Each can be appreciated and loved. Both very talented ladies.
oneslifesadream i love madonna and i like this version
oneslifesadream this version is just soulless… awful
Someone commented that Sia wrote this for Madonna and Imma be shady and not direct respond to them.. BUT Sia was like 14 when Madonna came out with the song 'Oh Father' and.. No Sia did not have a career back then. Ofc Sia may have brought more life to the song, but Madonna debut'd it.
Sia started writing songswhen she was 13. She wrote a song about aids at that age. So yes she didnt write this one but she could have. Dont underestimate her..
@@liliafurler7888 don't overestimate her
@@erregi4946 im not. She's the best songwritter of this generation and it's a fact not an opinion.
Jeff Lombardi life? there’s no life in her voice in this song. just singing the voice, not a fucking emotion
the song would have been effective, if Sia had the same experience as Madonna did.
Love this cover
Fantastic vid, maybe you will also like my playlist
I do LOVE Sia but this cover is a blaspheme :/