Video

Perfect ending.

He is too simple to get her .

vile woman

Fantastic, smart, nuanced discussion. Thank you both.

the interviewer is bad. Talks too much. Let her speak.

Anti fa was more anarchist and BLM was more authoritarian kind of socialism. They were both insane, so on an ideological level so could work with each other despite the contradictions.

Some comments criticise the interviewer for seeming to shed Helen's articulate and intelligent arguments without probing deeper, either to expose faults or reinforce their accuracy. And they have a point. I prefer to think that he chooses to remain, or appear to remain dispassionate and thus neutral. But no one is ever really neutral ré trans activism so Mounk comes off as mechanical, indifferent and cool. Fortunately Helen is the opposite.

All the extremism is now focused on Israel. Right, Left, Islamist.

So interesting. It is the take over of institutions that are comfortable with themselves. You can see it at the local level - take over of local groups, local politics etc by a small group of people with extreme views using new tech to amplify their message (dumbed down so it sounds super moderate), and to organize others. These folks are often ridiculous extremists who actually are parroting the ideas of others. Often unrelated to local interests and needs. And the labels-- oy. Someone else defines you.

How can any man live as a woman? Woman is not a costume. Woman is the lived experience of being born female; a man can only ever live as a man.

Please learn to not interrupt

There's no moral tragedy in making sure children and vulnerable adults have the capacity to make clear decisions before intervening medically. There's no moral remainder.

This guy seems to think that ‘trans’ is even a thing. There are no rights that people who call themselves ‘trans’ don’t have. The demands of these people (men) trample all over the rights of women, & therefore have no weight. ‘Gender dysphoria’ is a chimera. It doesn’t exist as a condition for children who don’t already have other psychological conditions. Trans’ is non-existent for children and is fetishist transvestism and/or autogyneohilia for adult males.

She works for a corporation and was surprised? Follow the money - this naive act is also part of "the money"

gender is a social construct luckily more people are approaching ethnography from a secular standpoint rather than involving the abrahamic gender binary

Intelligent? Really? This act is CRIMINAL and should be prosecuted!

The way the self id law in Germany is framed is just the usual gaslighting. “It doesn’t affect you”. In essence, since the Transsexuellengesetz came into force in 1981 (I think), and the Gender Recognition Act in 2004, women are no longer recognised in law. Because ‘woman’ now means ‘has the letter F in a document’. OF COURSE that affects women. And when there are more and more men and it becomes ever easier for them to claim to be what we are, then the more we’re affected. We risk being sued for calling a man a man, because he has a piece of paper that declares him to be a woman. It’s misogyny on stilts. (And yes, men are also no longer recognised in law, but since they’re treated as the default anyway and need less special accommodation such as protected sports categories, the impact on them is much less critical)

51:17 people empathised with HSTS men who quietly kept to themselves and the gay scene. Straight men’s Autogynephilia is a real threat to all children, girls and women in particular. The AGP group commits far more sex crime per capita than regular adult penis havers.

We know how terribly children given Lupron for precocious puberty suffered, and they actually did get to go through real puberty at a normal age.

Proper psychology can assist people to come to terms with reality. Destroying and sterilising children’s bodies for rumination is outrageous. Men living as women impacts actual women. Boys claiming to be girls very adversely impact girl children and no one gives a damn about large gamete havers.

This was excellent. The interviewer had some new angles to explore through his questions. His thinking is different from most people who interview HJ. I appreciate his thoughtfulness and imagination/ creativity. This wasn’t a typical HJ interview. I loved hearing HJs answers to these questions especially with respect to how do we manage this in a pluralistic society. Much to think about.

Trans people already have the same rights as every other person in the population (in western societies). And the claims the activists make about this and all the statements about hatred and violence are lies. A hallmark of transactivism is to manipulate language and tell blatant lies.

I just kept thinking He cant have any children orhave anything much to do with children. Also he seems to be submerged in a very intellectual approach to this, not at all in touch with the living reality.

There are more and more unisex restrooms now when a bathroom is private. The only problem is that men are messier and women have forfeited cleaner environments. Yuck.

The medical scandal of our generation. Those poor children.

Such a pleasure -- and a relief -- to hear this calm and compassionate voice of reason, against the frenzied and aggressive narcissism of transactivist-driven demands for "trans rights" -- and to hell with anyone else's rights. Thank you Helen Joyce, and please keep talking and writing.

I am embarrassed that--as an American--the US is the most powerful agent of this highly damaging movement.

Excellent point about organizations morphing to other issues after success in one issue. The survival of the organization and funding sources become the primary motivation, even if the members don't fully grasp that.

Helen Joyce is a clear thinker and can pick through faulty arguments impressively well. She covers so much ground here. Her only fault, imv, is her feminism. She completely ignores the contributions of conservative women to this terrible situation. She does have progressive leanings. Noone is perfect.

It's strange... I'd never seen a picture of Yascha Mounk before this video, but he looks pretty much the way I always imagined he looked like, hahaha.

The position she has arrived at is very good.

no no no

Marginalised people = cannon fodder for the Left.

There is no difference. Both the Left and Woke are about POWER, it’s abuse and authoritarianism. Both will be crushed in the next 25 years. You had your chance, you abused.

Yeah, that ending was a bit abrupt.

Another superb Helen Joyce interview.

Stop saying "gender" when you mean sex. They want to pass as the other sex. They don't change sex and gender is an ideology. The whole notion is ridiculous.

Of course the left is not woke, liberals are. Liberals gave us human rights, women's rights, and LGBT rights. The left gave us Stalin and Mao.

Gay

Biggest medical scandal since lobotomies. Helen is one of the voices of reason.

Sigh

Helen Joyce ! I just adore her, I could listen to her all day.

Helen Joyce can single-handedly save the world. Her moral compass is exceptional.

I just love listening to her. She's so refreshing😍♥️

So nochmal auf Deutsch zum Selbstbestimmungsgesetz: Was du nicht verstehst: das Hausrecht ist KEIN vernünftiger Kompromiss! Männer haben in Spanien bereits versucht in ein Frauenhaus zu gelangen indem sie sich zu Frauen erklärt und Zutritt verlangt haben! Man verlangt von Frauenhäusern diese Männer selbständig abzuweisen, sich gegenüber deren Drohungen zu wehren und evtl. Zuschüsse zu verlieren wenn sie keine Männer die angeblich Frauen sind rein lassen. Außerdem wird das neben des alten Namens mit bis zu 10.000 Euro bestraft. Wie soll man der Polizei oder wem auch immer akkurat beschreiben wer sich Zutritt verschaffen will wenn man weder Geschlecht noch Namen nennen darf?! Weder Polizei noch BKA werden über die Änderung informiert! Wie soll die Polizei Personen die untertauchen wollen finden?! Dieses Nonsens Gesetz hat dermaßen katastrophale Konsequenzen für uns ALLE!!! Es muss WEG. Hast du dich überhaupt tiefer damit beschäftigt?! So „close“ kann der Blick dann nicht gewesen sein!

Yascha‘s book „The identity trap“ was great, so it astonishes me that he really doesn’t seem to understand that there really is no such thing as a legitimate trans person and the movement is also not legitimate because they consist of fetishists and other persons with an agenda that has nothing to do with equal rights. The first group was basically made trans by society and the second group is a political totalitarian movement that wants power and push men’s rights to take out their fetish in public.

What a terrible interlocutor this man is! He responded to only one or two of HJ's comments, and then to interrupt her. Talking to him must've been like shouting down a well. He needs to work on his social skills if he's wanting to make a go of this work.

Helen Joyce is the voice of common sense and science - and ofcourse truth. No one can change their biology. It’s not a philosophical exercise - that reduces the issues to something really weak and unrealistic. The health consequences of all of these medical procedures are absolutely shocking and the treatments have 100% failure rate.

Love her

HJ 4 PM