Institute of Catholic Culture
Institute of Catholic Culture
  • 753
  • 2 624 857
Kulturkampf: The Dismantling of German Catholicism
This talk examined the "Kulturkampf," the German Empire's attempt to break the power of the Catholic Church in Germany during the 1870s. It discussed the legal machinery that the German state used in its campaign against the Church, the reasons why they attempted to do this, how the Church responded to the crisis, and its legacy for the Church today.
Instructor:
Darrick Taylor earned his Ph.D. in history from the University of Kansas, and teaches Humanities at Santa Fe College in Gainesville, Florida. He produces a podcast, Controversies in Church History, and recently completed his first novel. He lives in Central Florida.
Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
zhlédnutí: 740

Video

Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fifteenth Sunday of Ordinary Time
zhlédnutí 203Před 14 dny
Why has God predestined me to live in this particular time? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fourteenth Sunday of Ordinary Time
zhlédnutí 240Před 21 dnem
Why are we given "thorns in the flesh"? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
The Reformation: Historical Conditions and Unintended Consequences
zhlédnutí 4,8KPřed 21 dnem
In this lecture, discover the social and political conditions that contributed to the Protestant Reformation and the multitude of unforeseen and unintended consequences that now define the modern world. The reasons for its rapid spread throughout Europe and its lasting effects went far beyond the theological debates surrounding the reformers’ ideas. Instructor: Brad S. Gregory is Professor of E...
NEW ONLINE COURSE! Patristics 102: Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers
zhlédnutí 113Před 21 dnem
In this course, we shall explore the Fathers of the Church from the Council of Nicaea (AD 325) through the fourth and fifth centuries (with as guides St. Athanasius, St. Gregory of Nazianzus, St. Jerome, St. Augustine…) down to St. Gregory the Great in the sixth and seventh centuries and St. John of Damascus in the eighth. By engaging with these brilliant Christian minds, we will be able to exp...
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Thirteenth Sunday of Ordinary Time
zhlédnutí 280Před měsícem
Is God the author of death? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Twelfth Sunday of Ordinary Time
zhlédnutí 163Před měsícem
Who was Job? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Eleventh Sunday of Ordinary Time
zhlédnutí 198Před měsícem
What makes the Kingdom of God like a mustard seed? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Tenth Sunday of Ordinary Time
zhlédnutí 234Před měsícem
Is the Kingdom of God my kingdom? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Solemnity of the Most Holy Body and Blood of Christ
zhlédnutí 224Před měsícem
What is the Eucharist the fulfillment of? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Lauda Sion: A Theological Study of Aquinas' Eucharistic Poetry
zhlédnutí 271Před 2 měsíci
"It is here that the utmost power of a Scholasticism, not crude and truncated, like that of today, but juicy and complete, like that of the Middle Ages, was able to bend the rhythm of the Latin language to the clear exposition and demand a dogma, as abstract for the theologian as it is sweet and consoling for the heart of the faithful." -Dom Prosper Gueranger Join Dr. John Pepino and the ICC fo...
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Solemnity of the Most Holy Trinity
zhlédnutí 214Před 2 měsíci
How can I live my life in the Trinity? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Come, Lord Jesus! - Eschatology and Christian Morality
zhlédnutí 275Před 2 měsíci
The longest journey doesn’t begin with a single step. It begins with a destination. A deeper appreciation for the last things-death, judgment, heaven, and hell-deepens our grasp of Christian morality-how we should live here and now. Instructor: Fr. Paul Scalia was ordained in 1996, when he finished his master of arts degree at the Angelicum in Rome. He currently serves as the Episcopal Vicar fo...
The Spirit of the Liturgy: Divine Worship with Pope Benedict XVI
zhlédnutí 356Před 2 měsíci
"All worship is now a participation in this 'Pasch' of Christ, in his 'passing over' from divine to human, from death to life, to the unity of God and man." -Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (Pope Benedict XVI) Join Dr. Jared Staudt in a guided book study of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger's seminal work, The Spirit of the Liturgy. Cardinal Ratzinger issued a great rallying cry to humanity to rediscover our...
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Seventh Sunday of Easter
zhlédnutí 225Před 2 měsíci
Have you been consecrated? Want to dive deeper? Visit our website for hundreds of hours of free audio and video content: instituteofcatholicculture.org/
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Sixth Sunday of Easter
zhlédnutí 246Před 2 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Sixth Sunday of Easter
The Church as Eucharist: St. Paul's Theology of the Mystical Body of Christ
zhlédnutí 211Před 2 měsíci
The Church as Eucharist: St. Paul's Theology of the Mystical Body of Christ
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fifth Sunday of Easter
zhlédnutí 224Před 3 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fifth Sunday of Easter
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fourth Sunday of Easter
zhlédnutí 289Před 3 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fourth Sunday of Easter
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Third Sunday of Easter
zhlédnutí 270Před 3 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Third Sunday of Easter
Hosanna to the Son of David: Entering into Holy Week Through Sacred Music
zhlédnutí 379Před 4 měsíci
Hosanna to the Son of David: Entering into Holy Week Through Sacred Music
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fifth Sunday of Lent
zhlédnutí 303Před 4 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fifth Sunday of Lent
Milk & Honey: Eucharistic Theology in the Early Church - Part I
zhlédnutí 764Před 4 měsíci
Milk & Honey: Eucharistic Theology in the Early Church - Part I
St. Boniface and the Conversion of the Germanic Tribes
zhlédnutí 414Před 4 měsíci
St. Boniface and the Conversion of the Germanic Tribes
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fourth Sunday of Lent
zhlédnutí 333Před 4 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Fourth Sunday of Lent
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Third Sunday of Lent
zhlédnutí 304Před 4 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Third Sunday of Lent
Behold the Pierced One: An ICC Lenten Retreat with Pope Benedict XVI
zhlédnutí 284Před 4 měsíci
Behold the Pierced One: An ICC Lenten Retreat with Pope Benedict XVI
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Second Sunday of Lent
zhlédnutí 375Před 5 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Second Sunday of Lent
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the First Sunday of Lent
zhlédnutí 333Před 5 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the First Sunday of Lent
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Sixth Sunday of Ordinary Time Year B
zhlédnutí 363Před 5 měsíci
Sunday Gospel Reflection for the Sixth Sunday of Ordinary Time Year B

Komentáře

  • @lechkonradpowichrowski3965
    @lechkonradpowichrowski3965 Před 16 hodinami

    Definitely the most enlightening explanation in a nutshell of Dante's masterpiece. I've been trying painfully to go through its French translation, but I missed a lot. Realize it just now. Thanks also for notes of humour. Highly appreciated.

  • @Ben_G_Biegler
    @Ben_G_Biegler Před 8 dny

    Wow, great insights here. "You cannot serve God and Mamon"

  • @christendomempire5657

    Didn't Alexander use a tactic called a mouse trap to stop the chariots?

  • @christendomempire5657

    Will Christopher check ever come to Australia?

  • @christendomempire5657

    First

  • @christendomempire5657

    Dr John. What are the reasons that Gibbon was wrong with blaming Christians for the fall of the roman Empire?

  • @christendomempire5657

    The Romans borrowed their sword (Gladitius Hispanius) from their conquest of Spain

  • @christendomempire5657

    Didn't the Romans borrow the tactic of rotating ranks from fighting the Sabines?

  • @sjurdurkjv
    @sjurdurkjv Před 15 dny

    BS

  • @markkoscinski339
    @markkoscinski339 Před 15 dny

    Dr. Taylor, please consider a class on the Old Catholic Church and the PNCC. While tiny in comparison to the Roman Catholic Church, they have a fascinating history and evolution.

  • @jorgegomezespinosa8192

    29:36 I don't think Cervantes parodied chivalric novels merely to mock them, more so to shows the power of said fiction. Many are quick to dismiss Amadís, Orlando, Tirant lo Blanc or Palmerin of England despite the fact Cervantes himself praised them (although indeed he considered several to be derivative, such as Esplandián).

  • @carlasoto6760
    @carlasoto6760 Před 16 dny

    Nice talk the only thing There was echo and the sound was not very clear

  • @davidthomas9276
    @davidthomas9276 Před 16 dny

    Wondering if you could corroborate my admittedly shallow internet search which says there were at least 2 reformers prior to Luther; namely, Jan Hus and John Wycliffe?

  • @reeferfranklin
    @reeferfranklin Před 17 dny

    I'm a reluctant-Protestant quickly becoming Catholic, I'm very much drawn to the Personal Ordinariate & the TLM-centered Orders & parishes, but not having one local to me, and being weary of some of the current politics playing out, I've been highly intrigued by the Eastern Catholics, partially because I have a great respect for the Orthodox branches of Christendom, but also be the most reverent & most local parishes to me are Syro-Malabar, and I've long since thought Saint Thomas would be my Patron Saint, so many things lined-up, I discovered all of this the day of the Feast of Saint Thomas, I've been on the fence between Catholicism & Eastern Orthodoxy & had many confirmations that the Eastern Catholic Church, specifically of the Saint Thomas Christians variety was the proper path for myself & my daughter.

    • @reeferfranklin
      @reeferfranklin Před 17 dny

      Christ is King! ✝️🟰👑 #ChristIsKing 🙏🏽🌹📿

  • @Gilbert.Suhendra
    @Gilbert.Suhendra Před 17 dny

    That was basic and easy to understand, But actually random of DNA what form comes as creature the creation of God has works incredible nature in life as eternal room also real after human died. This is the knowledge of God through feeling body in soul human must recognized on the Glory of God ! God Bless You

  • @jacktracy8356
    @jacktracy8356 Před 18 dny

    John 3:14 KJV "And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the SON OF MAN (CHRIST) be lifted up: 15 That whosoever believes in HIM should not perish, but have eternal life. 16 For GOD so loved the world, that HE gave HIS ONLY BEGOTTEN SON, that whosoever believes in HIM should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For GOD sent not HIS SON into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through HIM might be saved. 18 He that believes on HIM is not condemned: but he that believes not is condemned already, because he has not believed in the NAME of the ONLY BEGOTTEN SON OF GOD."Note: A true Christian is not condemned but has everlasting life therefore if you do not know where you will immediately go when you die then you deny what CHRIST said therefore you deny CHRIST.

  • @deanmadley4786
    @deanmadley4786 Před 18 dny

    Breaking new Christ is an equation for the universe and everything in it and the equation has been found the first symbol is, B

  • @mikelewis9444
    @mikelewis9444 Před 19 dny

    the midstream flex to climate change was both bizarre and saddening

    • @josephodoherty7864
      @josephodoherty7864 Před 8 dny

      Not at all bizarre and well within the scope of the unexpected or negligent long term effects of an extreme materialistic take on the industrial and post-industrial revolution. Some people are still in a fairytale state of denial about climate concerns.

  • @arthurw8054
    @arthurw8054 Před 20 dny

    Brilliant. Thank you.

  • @oliverclark5604
    @oliverclark5604 Před 20 dny

    Our present moment of real presence containing past and future is in the keeping in uncertainty of belief of the inseparability and qualitative equality of ensuring and insuring. This ensuring is of procreation role gifts in plural roles. This insuring is of need of union of singular identity. This keeping is only possible in consecrated marriage celibate vowed to man in Christ or male female vowed to God in keeping in uncertainty of belief their inseparability and qualitative equality as a double keeping resulting in a third as trinitarian keeping. This third keeping in withstanding a "worldwide catastrophe" of that "the great majority of [purported presumed] sacramental marriages are invalid" was by Pope Francis on 17 June 2021 on the reference point of two consecrated marriages, a male female marriage then a celibate marriage, keeping on, then from 1 November 2017 their inseparability and qualitative equality in exercising an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of ensuring and insuring. This double keeping as a reference point enabled the triple keeping by consecrated celibate marriage of Pope Francis in ensuring accountability for embezzlement of his procreation role gift charity donations by ten of his Vatican state citizens/employees, including Cardinal Angelo Becciu, and insuring accountability for an unacceptable risk of fraud by the Italian Parliament "Zan" anti-homophobia bill on his need of union of his identity in simultaneously exercising an absolute power of authorisations of the criminal indictments of these ten then convicted in his Vatican state court on 18 December 2023 and a protest note against this bill on 17 June 2021 with its defeat in the Italian Parliament on 27 October 2021. The present moment in real presence "fulfilment ... believed that there would be" by Mary at Lk 1:45 was completed in the last two words of Christ on his cross petitioning in justice "My God, my God, why ... ", and in mercy: "Father into your hands I commit ..." in his keeping their inseparability and qualitative equality. Taking hold of this keeping throughout "relative time and space" (Einstein, c.1907) and under the "Uncertainty Principle" (Heisenberg, 1927) was by these consecrated marriages, male female of Jane and Oliver Clark then celibate of Oliver Clark on the death of his wife as inseparable and qualitatively equal in a double keeping, on and from 1 November 2017 completed on 31 March 2021 on a written direction of Pope St John Paul 2's Council for the Laity Vice President, Bishop Paul Cordes, dated 29 September 1994, through the Archdiocese of Brisbane, Australia, addressing a catechist, Oliver Clark: "At this point, you must take the steps that you consider most appropriate and necessary at the local level to sustain what you consider to be your rights", as reference point for Pope Francis in his consecrated celibate marriage on 17 June 2021 completing a triple keeping as trinitarian. This triple keeping in relative time and space in uncertainty of belief is the only power able to be exercised as absolute to withstand the extreme tensions caused by these embezzlements and fraud causing the "worldwide catastrophe" of sexual abuse in "the great majority of sacramental marriages ... [as] invalid".

  • @SF-ru3lp
    @SF-ru3lp Před 20 dny

    I shot off to Amazon and purchased "Rebel in thd Ranks" for starters. So looking gorward to reading it. I dtudied this era of history for my Leaving Certificate back in 1980-82 and found it thoroughly engrossing. Dr Brad's lecture is 'fleshing' it out for me. I have also been blessed by a number of years in 'Protestant' churches but always had 'question marks at the back of my mind. G Ire

    • @Stupidityindex
      @Stupidityindex Před 20 dny

      Is there a greater arrogance than expressing you have some sort of relationship with a deity? Question: How can you possibly take faith seriously? How can anyone in their right mind ask others to believe in the existence of a Deity who makes Mormons so Christians will know how Jews feel, having had their literature hijacked. Nothing fails like prayers in a children's hospital & indoctrinating children is criminal. The faith vocabulary causes the user to be avoided like the old woman with too many cats. Faith "comes not with peace, but sword." Faith comes with wolves dressed as sheep & preaching to the choir. Faith trades the last cow for a pocketful of magic beans & then expects everyone's appreciation. Jesus said, it is a wicked generations which seeks signs such as resurrection. Faith is as worthless as fantasyland magic, since you can't tell mountains to move. The only sign in reality is Jonah: A believer murdered by other believers because he is outnumbered. The context is Jesus seeing a gathering crowd.

    • @oliverclark5604
      @oliverclark5604 Před 20 dny

      @@Stupidityindex Yes. Faith not having its inseparability and qualitative equality kept in uncertainty of belief with thinking is worthless as attempting processes of economic "trades" without non-economic progress. Another sign in reality would be Job at Job: 41:1-6 if replacing "know" with in uncertainty believe.

  • @SF-ru3lp
    @SF-ru3lp Před 20 dny

    I see the revolution of the 1960s stemming from the fact that its only 20 years after the war. Children growing up (teens and older) in the 60s were born of men who came through WWII m- men who were traumatised and could not relate ir parent well. The reaching out in thd 60s was an expression of anger against parents who could not emote/were shut down. Then they reached for self comfort in all its extensions.... imo. G Ire

    • @davidthomas9276
      @davidthomas9276 Před 15 dny

      I would add in the assassination of President Kennedy which, in my mind, cut our country adrift from its mooring, plunged us into uncertainty and fear for the future, and was followed quickly by the large buildup of our involvement in the war in Vietnam. Fertile ground for anger and protest.

  • @SF-ru3lp
    @SF-ru3lp Před 20 dny

    Brilliant exposé Dr. Brad. Thank you. G Ire

    • @Stupidityindex
      @Stupidityindex Před 20 dny

      Is there a greater arrogance than expressing you have some sort of relationship with a deity? Question: How can you possibly take faith seriously? How can anyone in their right mind ask others to believe in the existence of a Deity who makes Mormons so Christians will know how Jews feel, having had their literature hijacked. Nothing fails like prayers in a children's hospital & indoctrinating children is criminal. The faith vocabulary causes the user to be avoided like the old woman with too many cats. Faith "comes not with peace, but sword." Faith comes with wolves dressed as sheep & preaching to the choir. Faith trades the last cow for a pocketful of magic beans & then expects everyone's appreciation. Jesus said, it is a wicked generations which seeks signs such as resurrection. Faith is as worthless as fantasyland magic, since you can't tell mountains to move. The only sign in reality is Jonah: A believer murdered by other believers because he is outnumbered. The context is Jesus seeing a gathering crowd.

  • @skabo__o
    @skabo__o Před 20 dny

    there seems to be a resurrection of faith at least by men greetings from Austria !

  • @MohamedShou
    @MohamedShou Před 21 dnem

    As a Muslim for the past couple of months I have been interested in learning about Christianity more and more especially when you don’t watch the Christian vs Muslim debates on CZcams. Most of the time you don’t learn nothing from those debates and it just becomes who’s louder or who says something “smarter”. So when you watch from actual Christian believers and what they teach and how they practice their faith then you learn way more and understand where they are coming from. May God bless you 👍🏾

    • @TesterBoy
      @TesterBoy Před 20 dny

      Read the Bible for yourself and God will guide you. Never trust anyone else’s opinion!

    • @MohamedShou
      @MohamedShou Před 20 dny

      @@TesterBoyI do read the Bible I do believe a lot of the things in the Bible are true 🤷🏾‍♂️ but not all of it

    • @oliverclark5604
      @oliverclark5604 Před 20 dny

      @@TesterBoy Particularly the "opinion" of St Paul at 1Cor7:25-34 in groomed error purporting presuming separation of consecrated celibate marriage vowed to man in Christ and consecrated male female marriage vowed to God when inseparable and qualitatively equal.

  • @believejesuschristislord1100

    Thank you and God bless.

  • @outofoblivionproductions4015

    Your framing of the medieval age stood out. But why does Luther always appear out of no-where? He was taught by Nominalists who wanted more focus on the Bible. The seeds of the Reformation began with these people who rejected scholasticism.

  • @erichodge567
    @erichodge567 Před 22 dny

    Guy is really good. Gonna have to check out his books.

  • @markbirmingham6011
    @markbirmingham6011 Před 22 dny

    Comment for traction. With him on environmental stewardship but i would’ve liked to see a more nuanced reflection on globalization and economic development. Millions have been lifted out of poverty by globalization and cheap goods leads to rising living standards across the board. Its complication as there are downsides too, obviously. But countries that have cheap labor often have a comparative advantage in a labor which can lead to their economic development and all the resulting benefits: improved infrastructure, increased education male and female, lower infant mortality, better nutrition and medicine etc.

    • @Stupidityindex
      @Stupidityindex Před 20 dny

      Is there a greater arrogance than expressing you have some sort of relationship with a deity? Question: How can you possibly take faith seriously? How can anyone in their right mind ask others to believe in the existence of a Deity who makes Mormons so Christians will know how Jews feel, having had their literature hijacked. Nothing fails like prayers in a children's hospital & indoctrinating children is criminal. The faith vocabulary causes the user to be avoided like the old woman with too many cats. Faith "comes not with peace, but sword." Faith comes with wolves dressed as sheep & preaching to the choir. Faith trades the last cow for a pocketful of magic beans & then expects everyone's appreciation. Jesus said, it is a wicked generations which seeks signs such as resurrection. Faith is as worthless as fantasyland magic, since you can't tell mountains to move. The only sign in reality is Jonah: A believer murdered by other believers because he is outnumbered. The context is Jesus seeing a gathering crowd.

  • @cadusteigleder9648
    @cadusteigleder9648 Před 22 dny

    Amazing conttent! Thanks so much for this upload. Whatching from Brazil. 🇧🇷🙏

    • @Stupidityindex
      @Stupidityindex Před 20 dny

      Is there a greater arrogance than expressing you have some sort of relationship with a deity? Question: How can you possibly take faith seriously? How can anyone in their right mind ask others to believe in the existence of a Deity who makes Mormons so Christians will know how Jews feel, having had their literature hijacked. Nothing fails like prayers in a children's hospital & indoctrinating children is criminal. The faith vocabulary causes the user to be avoided like the old woman with too many cats. Faith "comes not with peace, but sword." Faith comes with wolves dressed as sheep & preaching to the choir. Faith trades the last cow for a pocketful of magic beans & then expects everyone's appreciation. Jesus said, it is a wicked generations which seeks signs such as resurrection. Faith is as worthless as fantasyland magic, since you can't tell mountains to move. The only sign in reality is Jonah: A believer murdered by other believers because he is outnumbered. The context is Jesus seeing a gathering crowd.

  • @user-dr3tk8gq8r
    @user-dr3tk8gq8r Před 22 dny

    I would like a booklist on Luther and the Reformation - thank you for this talk!

  • @francissweeney7318
    @francissweeney7318 Před 22 dny

    Tbe catholic church is the great harlot of Revelation chapter 17.

    • @Kitiwake
      @Kitiwake Před 21 dnem

      Please let us have your basis for such a ridiculous statement.

    • @outofoblivionproductions4015
      @outofoblivionproductions4015 Před 21 dnem

      So, the Harlot formed your Bible? 'Sola Harlot Bible'.

    • @francissweeney7318
      @francissweeney7318 Před 21 dnem

      Chapter 17 in Revelation and the truth of The Holy Spirit.

    • @francissweeney7318
      @francissweeney7318 Před 21 dnem

      The harlot changed The Word of God. Graven images are an offense to God.

  • @piushalg5041
    @piushalg5041 Před 22 dny

    In Switzerland Zwingli wanted to force the catholic confederate to tolerate protestant preaching in their lands which they refused. Not astonishing because Zwingli would not tolerate Catholics in his territory Zwingli cut off the grain supplies to the catholic refrrutiries to starve them into submission. Sp they took to arms and defeated Zwingli's forces and killing himself in battle which he deserved.

  • @harleymann2086
    @harleymann2086 Před 23 dny

    Agreed. Governments of countries decided what religions would be permitted in the state. I suppose one can say the same thing is happening today (ex politically correct ideology).

  • @530jazzercise
    @530jazzercise Před 23 dny

    german nobles wanted to 1) steal church property and 2) legalise usury..they needed a false flag to break w rome..enter germany’s most debauched priest..the bible is not in the bible..end of proddyism

  • @abalint8097
    @abalint8097 Před 23 dny

    👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @wungabunga
    @wungabunga Před 23 dny

    48:00 Certainly Rome allowed religious freedom as long as it knew its place, although not sure it was written into the constitution- so to speak. Edit: ah, see you mentioned the Dutch,also. U.S. first to guarantee it.

    • @Stupidityindex
      @Stupidityindex Před 20 dny

      Is there a greater arrogance than expressing you have some sort of relationship with a deity? Question: How can you possibly take faith seriously? How can anyone in their right mind ask others to believe in the existence of a Deity who makes Mormons so Christians will know how Jews feel, having had their literature hijacked. Nothing fails like prayers in a children's hospital & indoctrinating children is criminal. The faith vocabulary causes the user to be avoided like the old woman with too many cats. Faith "comes not with peace, but sword." Faith comes with wolves dressed as sheep & preaching to the choir. Faith trades the last cow for a pocketful of magic beans & then expects everyone's appreciation. Jesus said, it is a wicked generations which seeks signs such as resurrection. Faith is as worthless as fantasyland magic, since you can't tell mountains to move. The only sign in reality is Jonah: A believer murdered by other believers because he is outnumbered. The context is Jesus seeing a gathering crowd.

    • @wungabunga
      @wungabunga Před 20 dny

      ​@@Stupidityindex Sir, this is a Wendy's.

  • @stephentagg2142
    @stephentagg2142 Před 23 dny

    Had the protestant reformation not happened, or had been suppressed, do you believe that the church would have reformed itself to eliminate its own corruption and dogma?

    • @wungabunga
      @wungabunga Před 23 dny

      Eliminate its dogma?

    • @harleymann2086
      @harleymann2086 Před 23 dny

      I do believe the Church behaviour at the time would have changed eventually; primarily because countries would have different governments and create a different culture over time. That said, I do believe the Reformation was used by God to separate Catholic Christians from the rebels in the Church.

    • @Kitiwake
      @Kitiwake Před 21 dnem

      Do you know want dogma is?

    • @TesterBoy
      @TesterBoy Před 20 dny

      You mean its doctrines that don’t coincide with the authority of the Bible.

    • @TesterBoy
      @TesterBoy Před 20 dny

      There were several attempts at reforming the romanist church before Luther. Also were several attempts to distribute the scriptures in the common language. The Roman Church failed to reform itself. And now there is a pope who claims to follow Christ but is actually a socialist.

  • @marknovetske4738
    @marknovetske4738 Před 24 dny

    I read the unintended Reformation,it was a very insightful and informative work.

  • @AlgyPug
    @AlgyPug Před 24 dny

    Excellent lecture - a ton of information delivered in a very digestible form. The point about successful propagation of religion being dependent on political power is one that is often under emphasized. For example, at the beginning of the Thirty Years War, one of the bloodiest conflicts in pre Twentieth Century European history, Pope Paul V (1605 - 1621) provided substantial financial support to the Catholic armies. Unfortunately, Urban VIII (1623 - 1644) who was pontiff for most of the period of the conflict, was a prodigious nepotist, and emptied the Papal treasury with building projects in the Vatican and enriching his family. Had Urban provided that same level of support to the Catholic forces as had Paul perhaps most of Germany would be Catholic today.

    • @oliverclark5604
      @oliverclark5604 Před 20 dny

      to AlgyPug, Yes. "dependent" instead of inseparable and qualitatively equal procreation gift role processes in consecrated marriages, celibate and male female in the keeping in uncertainty of belief the inseparability and qualitative equality of these marriages. This keeping exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of ensuring procreation gift role processes and insuring identity in need of progress in union as a double keeping resulting in a triple keeping in uncertainty of belief as trinitarian. This triple keeping is the multiplier of economic gift processes and non-economic need of progress as the "I AM WHO I AM" at Exodus 3:14. This keeping worldwide in "relative time and space" (Einstein, c.1907) under the "Uncertainty Principle" (Heisenberg, 1927) awaited diagnosis of a "worldwide catastrophe [of] the great majority of sacramental marriages are invalid" (Pope Francis in his valid consecrated celibate marriage, 10 June 2021, 10 June 2016) for appreciation of the remedy by Pope Francis' consecrated celibate marriage on 17 June 2021. This remedy was by Pope Francis' consecrated celibate marriage keeping in uncertainty of his belief on 17 June 2021 the inseparability and qualitative equality both of its gift role processes and its need of progress in union of its identity and of these roles' inseparability and qualitative equality with roles of his Vatican state in the Cardinal Angelo Becciu and nine other citizens/employees embezzlements case and the Italian Parliament in the "Zan" anti-homophobia bill unacceptable risk of fraud case as this third keeping in uncertainty of belief as a triple trinitarian keeping of the identities of the Three Persons of the Trinity in withstanding extreme tensions caused by nepotism such as of Pope Urban V111.

    • @AlgyPug
      @AlgyPug Před 20 dny

      @@oliverclark5604 Yes - while your ontolipathy is somewhat challenging I find your conclusions a little tendentious. While the essence of trinitarianism is certainly not in any sense diphragenous any form of union , either ontological or speculative, must be assessed on its own appropriate basis. While due deference to the Holy Spirit should remove any unpleasant uncertainty, i htink we should be wary of subscribing to any over-explicative sense of authorisation.

    • @josephodoherty7864
      @josephodoherty7864 Před 8 dny

      The replies here are grammatically unclear & confusing as are multiple logical leaps & presumptions not to mention a lot of specialised terminology out of context. I suspect that even the exceptionally small number of people who think they are following this tete-a-tete may have very different ideas about the other person's actually saying.🙄

  • @marknovetske4738
    @marknovetske4738 Před 24 dny

    I don't think you are actually being fair about the lack of education by the laity and the clergy. The university system was only coming into existence at the time of the reformation. And there were bishops who were pushing for theological training for priests. And the church and the Pope had many hundreds of years before band charging of the laiety for services by priests. But the Pope had no way to know and enforce abuses in far flung dioceses ,scattered across Europe.

  • @taylorbarrett384
    @taylorbarrett384 Před 24 dny

    There was a genuine move of God awakening people to the futility of their works, the gratuity of salvation in Christ, the comfort and assurance available in Christ, and the many errors, corruptions, and abuses that were pervasive throughout the Church. Protestants took that one way, and it's not entirely their fault. The Church could have taken a motherly approach, both correcting Protestant errors while affirming everything it could that was good and true in the Protestant view. Instead, it took an approach that was virtually as hostile as possible, and made its self seem quite opposed to the truths Protestants cherished, and this disappointed the evangelical Catholics who stayed loyal but were hoping for the Church to affirm those things. Anyways, I point these things out to correct my fellow Catholics in the comments

    • @marknovetske4738
      @marknovetske4738 Před 24 dny

      You are sadly misinformed. The church did treat the obstinate reformers with mildness and were met with derision and sophist arguments. The church never did then or now teach a gospel of salvation by works! The church needed reform,but in administration and clerical abuses but Not in doctrine. Before Luther, Calvin, zwingle and the rest of the self proclaimed ultimate authorities...you don't find Christians believing their doctrines of the solas anywhere going all the way back to the apostles. Theirs was a new heretofore unheard of religion based on twisting Scripture to fit their doctrines. Either 12:44 12:44 that or God simply let the church he founded believe a false gospel for fifteen hundred years! Read the early church fathers and you'll see the Catholic Church then and now! You can't find a protestant anywhere before Luther!

    • @wungabunga
      @wungabunga Před 23 dny

      @@marknovetske4738you could find plenty of heretics, though.

    • @taylorbarrett384
      @taylorbarrett384 Před 23 dny

      @@marknovetske4738 Actually, "faith alone" is how most Catholics understood Paul. Including Pope Saint Clement, Saint Augustine, Saint Ambrose, Saint John Chrysostom, Saint Bernard of Clairvaux, Saint Thomas Aquinas, etc. And the Church in no way took a moderate approach to the Reformers. Even at the beginning of the Reformation, when Luther was only protesting abusive indulgences, the Church was completely unwilling to even discuss the matter with him, but simply demanded that he recant or be excommunicated. You can only say "the Church never taught we need to earn salvation" etc, because you are a contemporary Catholic, taught the faith by contemporary apologists, who have convinced you that the current dogmas are the way the Church always taught things. But the Church did not even have a dogma concerning salvation at the time of the Reformation. There was a diversity of approaches, and the message the common lay person heard, was that Heaven was only for those who became holy enough for it by atoning for their sins, etc.

    • @josephodoherty7864
      @josephodoherty7864 Před 8 dny

      Sorry, but no, NOT at all. From the first sentence that was full of false stereotypes about the teachings of the Church pre-Luther & the dubious or let's say confusing phrase futility of works which caused a lot of error & was rightly clarified & corrected by the Council of Trent as is agreed by the modern Lutheran and Catholic Churches. Salvation only through God's grace is & always was Catholic doctrine and the direct correlation between politics, and commerce, and schism with the Church rather than any divine inspiration was absolutely clear. The reply to you about the initial mild response of the Church to Luther is very true; the 2nd reply denying this woefully misguided and uninformed. Luther did NOT initially only protest abuse of indulgences (which the Church ALREADY taught was wrong but sadly still practiced by many individuals) most of the points he raised were immediately accepted & corrected but Luther then openly started to argue religious beliefs of his own (though not his belief in polygamous marriage) including that some of the universally recognised Canon of the Bible for over 1200yrs should be removed as these disagreed with his outlook (so much for sola scriptura, but that itself is not ascriptural teaching) but despite stating much of this in front of the Pope and Cardinals he was still not excommunicated or punished for some time while gathering financial and political support.

    • @taylorbarrett384
      @taylorbarrett384 Před 8 dny

      @@josephodoherty7864 the Church didn't even have an official teaching on salvation before Trent. Id suggest doing some reading on the lives of cardinals Gasparo Contarini and Reginald Pole.

  • @johnschuh8616
    @johnschuh8616 Před 24 dny

    Waiting to see equations about the way that the spread of commerce led to rivalry for markets, to scientific developments, to seaborne empires. as well as land based empires, To he Industrialization and to ideologies like Marxism in re opposition to the capitalis and its practices.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 Před 24 dny

      Marx was motivated by Satanism. Watch the recent discussion Jordan Peterson had with Dr. Paul Kengor. He had no care for the poor in any deep way.

  • @derkennedy1228
    @derkennedy1228 Před 24 dny

    The reformation is largely a northern European project, that like the NAZI project and the green project elevates purity above all else, As JPII noted the problem started when the university intellectuals were given a totally undeserved status.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 Před 24 dny

      It seems to me to be a historical rejection by the Germanic tribes going all the way to the Romans. A battle that has repeatedly played out over the years.

    • @harleymann2086
      @harleymann2086 Před 23 dny

      I must say, there seems to be a “spirit” over Germany that is interesting to observe. As a people, they have been very good developing engineering, among other things; yet, there is an incredible rebellious streak in its history.

    • @derkennedy1228
      @derkennedy1228 Před 23 dny

      @@harleymann2086 When the flooding occurred in Germany a few years ago I was struck by the competent response of the service professionals and the total incompetence of the political establishment who ignored clear warnings and the blamed global warming.

    • @harleymann2086
      @harleymann2086 Před 23 dny

      @@derkennedy1228 Interesting is it not? The contrary behaviour of this people. Their ability to “make it happen” and their ability to easily buy into political ideology. I bet this goes way back into medieval times. Thanks for your comment.

    • @Kitiwake
      @Kitiwake Před 21 dnem

      Easily buy into new, untested political ideology.

  • @fultoneth9869
    @fultoneth9869 Před 24 dny

    Dividing & fragmentation belong to satanic reformation.

  • @ellisspear
    @ellisspear Před 25 dny

    Wow....great lecture. I have read his books.

  • @LeroyHines-z2c
    @LeroyHines-z2c Před 25 dny

    Look up Russian black icon Jesus

    • @Seraphim.of.theEucharist
      @Seraphim.of.theEucharist Před 25 dny

      We wuz Jesus 😂

    • @LeroyHines-z2c
      @LeroyHines-z2c Před 25 dny

      @@Seraphim.of.theEucharist but. The. Truth. Keep. Resurface n. Jesus. Said when. Time. For. Him. To. Come. Back. He. Will. Reveal. Himself. More

  • @alphabeta8284
    @alphabeta8284 Před 25 dny

    Is this guy a prot? He obviously hates the Catholic Church. Shame on you

  • @iwansaputra1890
    @iwansaputra1890 Před 26 dny

    real root of reformation is islam

    • @frisco61
      @frisco61 Před 25 dny

      Interesting, how?

    • @Kitiwake
      @Kitiwake Před 25 dny

      Just another heresy.

    • @cameronferguson9555
      @cameronferguson9555 Před 25 dny

      @@frisco61 my response would be that (I) Protestants relationship to the Bible seems closer to the Quran’s claim to be the verbatim word of God and (II) iconoclasm in Christian historyseems to be a direct response to iconoclasm in Islam.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 Před 24 dny

      ​@@frisco61Lloyd De Jong had a good presentation about Protestant princes receiving financial aid from Suleyman of the Ottoman Empire to establish Lutheranism in Germany and Netherlands. He cites all his sources.

    • @fantasia55
      @fantasia55 Před 24 dny

      link, please? ​@@alisterrebelo9013

  • @carlinmccormick1105
    @carlinmccormick1105 Před 26 dny

    Aloha!