Video

Intro is too long

Interesting. A better structured interview with questions prepared beforehand would have made it even better.

Pakistan and India relations between two countries can be smoother if deradicalised society of Pakistan first. Establishment of Pakistan and constitution of Pakistan should be secular constitution and Hindu's given equal rights and blassfamy law's act abolished in Pakistan. Then society education institution can equaliser for both societies can Undo Pakistan and unite India. But ground has to be made by government of Pakistan. Enough terrorist activities bleeding agendas of Pakistan. Hypocrisy of Pakistan in fact not tolerate any more by government of India. Happened is gone buried now. Either break up of Pakistan in 5parts to realise that blunder of creation of Pakistan or extinct from earth Global maps nuclear flash point is good enough for pakistan. No doubt Pakistan suffering more as lower reparrian state Indus water 🌊💦 system. All pollution shall go to Pakistan by nuclear mushroom. Air move from India to Pakistan zero point karachi sea tides in. Himalaya to Karachi air water 🌊💦 goes high natural climates direction ⬆️⬇️ monsoon season ⁉️

Mo. Ali jinha was responsible for every blood drop shed. Every orphan and raped women in India and Pakistan 1947. Partician case. He said that as lawyers he can sacrifice any muslim population of UP for carved out Pakistan infact West Punjab. Brutality steps in Pakistan infact and reciprocated in India across Radcliffe line. Sad state of affairs and loss of humanity and death' every nook and corner. .

His villagers from uggi were majority killed near Talwandi

Scholarly discussion prof.Furrukh sahib.

Excellent talk, thanks for taking this up. The songs (e.g. dasha dey) were indeed an enigma to me as they were not in pashto. I even asked few hazara and persian people if they could make any meaning out of it. My dadi used to sing it but meaning was unknown. Finally I stumbled upon the fact that they were most probably in a language called Ormuri from Waziristan.

Goosebumps...my English professor at St. Xavier's College Ahmedabad...my favourite absolutely....n to watch her speak about Sindh n Sindhis is equally special to me. I spent a decade in the Sindhi town of Gandhidham, Kutch. ❤❤❤

Love you Sir Salman

Thank you both for this. Very thought provoking..We deserve a deep rooted analysis and collective conversations of the PTSD from Partition and the impact it has on several generations thereafter the trauma. Focusing and honouring the individual struggles that deserve real ancestral healing. 🙏

A highly emotional experience, listening to Salman.What have we done to this beautiful land,to its people,to centuries of companionship? I want to honour people like Bacha Khan who opposed partition of India,suffered for independence from colonialism and spent many years in Pakistani jails for his principled stand against state propaganda aimed to keep the two countries in perpetual enmity.

Here from Shujabad city .... can assist you if require... will be happy to do so because my forefathers were also from India

I am from basti danishmandan jalanadhar punjab india

Some muslim (faver of dewbond)have vote part of India. And some hindus vote part of Pakistan

Why Professors Conceal Vital Facts on India's Partition and Allama Mashriqi: Our Documentary Review czcams.com/video/cI1NKnJkPAo/video.html

What a ,bitter and sweet memories !!!!God bless my wonderful Bhai always with a very verrrrry long , Healthy life . love you alot Bhaisaheb

Great scholar and her research & insight to the sub continent politics is extraordinary. Joy to watch and listen. Thank you Prof Ayesha Jalal. 😊for your time. She is an authority on this subject.

Good afternoon. You are saraiki speaking and you should speak saraiki. ShujaAbad is one of the best area ' there are mango archard which are best in Pakistan and world wide.

Connectivity is extremely poor

Love from Gujrat, Punjab, Pakistan ❤

She is spot on on all references that she has quoted regarding the progressive reshaping of the way of life we Sindhis adapted to after our parents relocated outside Pakistan and particularly in India. I do remember a lot of occasions and incidents that I experienced with my parents and other Sindhis that I grew up with in a predominantly Sindhi neighbourhood of Sion Mumbai since my birth as a twin Sindhi boy on 15th August 1949. Would love to share.

Great interview

Amazing conversation. My dad was a kid in Jalandhar during the events of 1947, but he passed away in 1985, and his brothers have likewise passed on. I never got a chance to ask him anything, so I will never know what he witnessed, unfortunately.

Thank you for this conversation, as always. 🙏

Mam Im really proud of your work on shared history and partition... Fanatics on both sides have ruined the lives of millions.....we just need peace , humanity...Im from Sindh Pakistan

Very very good, me kl hi sunia c,

Great conversation. If I was younger, I would go back to grad school and study with her ...

Outstanding.

Jai jhulelal from sindh 👍

from where i can get the link of the book. I would really appreciate. Please share the links or information. Unfortunately, there wasn't much talk about Pathans but more on partition.

Amazing conversation. Thanks again for everything.

Jai jhulelal from sindh 👍

I would request Guneeta to just end the partition obsession and let the modern nation states of India and Pakistan to live in peace please. Only Punjab and Bengal were partitioned, and even there only the NRI Punjabis seem to be obsessed about it till date. You will see never see a Kannada or Tamil, or a Manipuri speaker talk about partition. Even the large majority of Hindi speakers in North India don't care a fig about it.

the generation which experienced partition is rapidly vanishing۔ they have emotional attachment with their birthplaces and wish to visit them before they pass away۔ Both countries should facilitate them to fulfil their this wish۔ this could be proved a big step to normalise the relations and bring peace and prosperity in this part of the world۔

Background music too loud and annoying and drowning out what honorable elder is saying.

Masha Allah you are 100 percent pashtun

I am from shujabad, where is your home out side the shujabad ciry

I'm from Shujabad ❤

This is so interesting. My grandmother was from Danishmandan and my siblings and I and our cousins all wore those embroidered kurtas with matching hats as children and now the next generation are wearing them too. My mom and aunts were all taught the pathani kasheeda embroidery as young girls.

This stitching is called pathani karhai. I have my picture in that karhai. My mother and my wife still do it sometimes. On our weddings, my mother told me, there was a traditional red gown worn by the groom. My eldest mamu last wore it at his wedding.

Please also read Dr Ishtiaq Ahmad's book on Jinnah , His Sucesses , Failures and Role in Indian history . He proves with documentary evidence that it was neither Jinnah nor Nehru Patel Gandhi but the British imperial government who divided Indian subcontinent to retain a foothold for making Pakistan a garrison state to stop the spread of Russian communism upto the Arabian sea. Churchill literally used Jinnah and guided him secretly Similarly Nehru was used by Mountbaton . The Redcliff maps of divided India had been prepared in 1945 immediately after WW2 was over. British always resorted to Divide and Rule but when the time came for them to leave the political control they decided to Divide and Quit for economic control would remain with them any ways through their MNCs and Capital

Bhai Baldeep is wonderful person, I am really impressed by his beautiful rendition

Borders have existed in South Asia throughout history, between kingdoms. Borders have not stopped tens of millions of Indians, Pakistanis, and Bangladeshis from living in other countries. It is only this false partition narrative which has created partition of the minds, the actual partition never really happened in the manner in which it is presented. A shameless lie.

By continuing to hark about partition, which in reality only happened for Punjab, and Bengal, not India or South Asia, we continue to cry about a false loss, which breeds a hateful, sorrow filled mindset. It doesn't leave much room for balanced view of the present and the future, because the constant narrative is about a partition narrative, which is a naked lie.

Partition narrative is ignorant of factual history. And it's a dangerous narrative that continues to feed a hateful environment. India never existed as a country nor a nation before 1947, it was always merely a region, nothing more. It it had dozens of large kingdoms, that's not unitary. Partition is a lie against the historical truth.

It's so good to hear you ma'am ❤️❤️🙏🙏

He is adorable. I feel like I am listening to my grandfather talk. I really wanna hug him...place my head on his lap and listen to him talk endlessly

I mean she should at least read the speeches of jinnah and muslim league leaders before making false claims based on her assumptions.

My village borders Sindh but we remain in India ❤

Islam and only Islam is to be blaimed for partition. Infact Islam divides humanity.