A Noob Dissects
A Noob Dissects
  • 10
  • 82 700
The Bizarre World of Sonic Fighting Fan Games
But seriously though, can we get some sort of autopsy on this LeemenaDan person pretty please?
Links:
Sonic Battle LEN: archive.org/details/sonic-battle-lost-ending-neo
Sonic Smackdown: arcforged.itch.io/sonic-smackdown
Ultimate Sonic Smackdown: arcforged.itch.io/ultimate-sonic-smackdown
Sonic Duel: drive.google.com/drive/folders/1vC9Z6NY0aQAlmMcH9yWngVEqAyJiDHPj (New) || drive.google.com/file/d/1osaA65SZq5SW1J8du-c-9dvBkm_mjR1Z/view (Old)
Sonic Gather Battle: lol no
#sonic #videoessay #fightinggames
zhlédnutí: 25 399

Video

Marcy Wu: Amphibia's Greatest Blunder
zhlédnutí 2,2KPřed měsícem
#MarcyWuDeservedBetter. Come on, y'all, we can get it trending. Link to the AUs I mentioned: archiveofourown.org/series/2907240 #amphibia #videoessay #characteranalysis
The PAINFUL mediocrity of Powerpuff Girls Z
zhlédnutí 29KPřed měsícem
I love everything about this show… except for the actual show Timestamps: Development - 2:09 Story - 5:30 Characters - 14:58 Themes and Extra Thoughts - 38:55 Conclusion - 46:26 Link to concept art: TheOtaking/status/1660216502753140737 More information on the show’s pilot: lostmediawiki.com/Demashita!_Powerpuff_Girls_Z_(partially_found_Toei_pitch_pilot_of_anime_adaptation_of_Cartoo...
The AGONIZING limbo of Sonic’s Meta Era
zhlédnutí 21KPřed 4 měsíci
The decade once known as the savior of the franchise was let down by SEGA’s bad decisions. Who coulda thunk it??? #sonic #sonicthehedgehog #videoessay
The Great Sonic Characterization Debate!
zhlédnutí 1,9KPřed 5 měsíci
There are a lot of fun topics to talk about in the Sonic fandom. This isn’t one of them… so let’s talk about it! - #sonicthehedgehog #videoessay #characteranalysis - Music Credits: Song: Timur Haisyn - Brutal Fervour (No Copyright Music) Music provided by Tunetank. Free Download: bit.ly/2WuTq9d Video Link: czcams.com/video/4k2S-30eGyQ/video.htmlsi=CHyAVKYL4A9USyLq
Sonic in 3D - Adventure vs Boost
zhlédnutí 1,4KPřed 6 měsíci
Sonic has had a Rough Transition To 3D... well not actually, but that doesn't mean there weren't some rough spots! Timestamps: Adventure - 1:38 Boost - 6:42 Conclusion - 11:02 Video Credits: Console Intros - @Terminator8464 & @NeoZeroo @Geocax Nintendo 64 Games - @FCPlaythroughs & Sonic 3 & Knuckles - @pacsonicgamingPSG Boost Games - @SonixFan & @SonicJGB & @DarkspinesSonic @SonicDestiny Sonic ...
Sonic Adventure 2 vs The Test of Time
zhlédnutí 299Před 6 měsíci
Sonic Adventure 2 is commonly given the title of the best Sonic game, but is the game really all it's cracked up to be? Timestamps: Intro - 0:00 Development - 1:53 Story - 5:12 Characters - 20:29 Gameplay - 26:27 Goals - 41:17 Conclusion - 44:17 If you're interested in finding more information on SA2's development, here are some CZcams links: czcams.com/video/XoP_O58gBBY/video.htmlsi=h58v_7rfmc...

Komentáře

  • @seagullmoe
    @seagullmoe Před 14 hodinami

    I ALSO HAD A COPY OF 3.1 OMG MAN HOW FRUSTRATING

  • @geek_on_coffee
    @geek_on_coffee Před 2 dny

    I would love another video. MUGEN based Sonic fighting games like Freedom Fighters, and all the one-button supers are pretty bizarre in their own right as well, but wow, **this** was bizarre.

  • @YourTypicalRemixer
    @YourTypicalRemixer Před 3 dny

    I’m gonna plug and say: give Sonic The Fighters Blitz Hyper Edition a shot! It’s a pretty well made 2D Remake of Sonic the Fighters, and I’ve had a lot of fun with it! I believe it’s also still being worked on, but what is given is a really good experience!

  • @porygonlover322
    @porygonlover322 Před 3 dny

    the midi music in sonic battle LEN is honestly just kind of a cultural difference. the fangame/doujinsoft scene in japan has a lot more continuity from the 90s (when basically any downloadable game had to use midis to keep a reasonable filesize) to now, so a lot of longstanding creators are just still using midis (especially since a lot of them compose their own music and have made it an artform in their own right) and newer creators that got into the scene from playing existing doujinsoft will just go with the flow a lot of the time (especially since a lot of those established composers release their midis for free use - i don't recognize that time distortion theme but i wouldnt be shocked if its one of them)

    • @anoobdissects
      @anoobdissects Před 3 dny

      @@porygonlover322 oh that’s actually really interesting to hear about! Thank you for the brief history :D

  • @nicktheanimeniac
    @nicktheanimeniac Před 5 dny

    I still think Smackdown is the best Sonic fighting game. Sure, the PR is bad but that can be ignored to an extent if you just wanna play the game with friends and the characters are not COMPLETELY unoriginal. Theres still plenty of moves that the fit the characters well and they're fun to play either way so at least for me - it's the best one we got

  • @ArcForged
    @ArcForged Před 5 dny

    Thanks for mentioning us even though you were not happy with what we made. Online modes are not easy to make, especially for fighting games. Even capcom struggled with delay based netcode before rollback became the standard. At the time, we were 2 people learning gamedev in the midst of a global pandemic.

  • @CommandPromptGaming

    The *way* ArcForged asked for money was kinda scummy, but it makes sense because they have their own original IP's that they're making. I think one is called Head2Head. Using a Sonic Fan Game is gross, but I don't think asking for funding isn't inherently a bad thing. I also personally dont mind the character's having copied moves from other games. Chaos's Venom move still had to be animated from scratch and programmed in. If it gave us a roster as big as they gave, i don't mind.

  • @hentpplays8845
    @hentpplays8845 Před 7 dny

    Here's hoping someone manages to get a DRM-Less version of Sonic Gather Battle and we can enjoy that game again, without the risk of getting your IP Stolen and whatnot. Because damn, it was such a good, damn game.

  • @dr_drew_
    @dr_drew_ Před 7 dny

    Pearsec 🍐

  • @Yagoshi300
    @Yagoshi300 Před 8 dny

    Wait. No "Freedom Fighters", "Freedom Fighters 2" and "Sonic Freedom Fighters 2 Plus"?

  • @borummoon
    @borummoon Před 9 dny

    Aren't we forgetting the de facto Sonic fighting game, ULTIMATE ROBOTNIK DUELS? I'm a Big Arm main myself, I tend to pivot towards grapplers. It has a bad matchup with the Egg Scorcher but luckily its players are rare.

  • @CrossoverBingo64back

    I'm going to be honest I do not agree with you with the character movesets in Sonic Smackdown and TBH It really dosen't matter if games have online or not.

  • @DanteToska
    @DanteToska Před 10 dny

    Have you tried downloading 3.1 from any sketchy links using a Virtual Machine?

  • @thegreenflareon1542
    @thegreenflareon1542 Před 10 dny

    Dong dong never die was also made in 2d fighter maker, also there was a pokemon fighting game made in it from (supposedly) old artists from the anime.

    • @thegreenflareon1542
      @thegreenflareon1542 Před 10 dny

      And ANOTHER ONE is currently being made right now! It's called Pokemon: Close combat, it's really good!

  • @thegreenflareon1542
    @thegreenflareon1542 Před 10 dny

    Uh... sonic: freedom fighters is a video game made in mugen 😐

  • @rylibes6455
    @rylibes6455 Před 11 dny

    I definitely agree that showdown is too similar to other fighting games , but it has slightly filled the void in my heart left by the lack of a MvC 4

    • @KKHell
      @KKHell Před 5 dny

      MVC 4 exists and it's MVC Infinite.

  • @byakuyatogami2905
    @byakuyatogami2905 Před 11 dny

    I remember the fandom when I was younger absolutely hated Z, but I liked it, though in a different way than the original. If you look at it as a replacement for the original show then yeah, it's not perfect. But if you look at it as a magical girl show that's Powerpuff Girls themed? It understands the assignment. I also headcanon both Professors are separate people, but related, and this takes place either alongside or soon after the original. with Ken being the same age as the original PPG.

  • @bubbles46853-ep9if
    @bubbles46853-ep9if Před 11 dny

    I mainly watch for Poochy/Peach. Such a cute little fella.

  • @RyomaLightning
    @RyomaLightning Před 11 dny

    Ask and you shall receive! It's the final build I ever worked on some 10 years ago. czcams.com/video/yodjqFre_R8/video.html

  • @RyomaLightning
    @RyomaLightning Před 11 dny

    Knowing so many people enjoyed my Unofficial SBLEN update is pretty inspiring. I'll definitely reupload the last version I worked on for all of you. I honestly hadn't realized the link died until very very recently.

  • @the-aspiring-creator4249

    Honestly I think the video is a smidge harsh on Smackdown. Not on the devs because they definitely deserve flack for their PR and I really hope this is a case of amateurs getting in over their heads and that they'll learn from it but on the game itself. Programming original movesets that would completely fit the characters is a lot to ask of a fangame team, especially considering from what I can tell, this was their first fully completed game. They likely were still learning the ropes of development and figured rather than being stuck spending hours and hours trying to figure out why a homing attack they're attempting to code is instead shooting someone off into the sky at mach 3 that porting movesets that at least fit the characters' personalities and vibe would probably be for the best. And really, this video kind of illustrates why a dedicated Sonic fighting game is so difficult to make and why we haven't seen even an official one since Sonic the Fighters. You'd need to implement a gameplay style that pays proper respect to the games with a feel that brings them to mind but can also work with traditional fighting game mechanics. Something like Dragon Ball works for fighters because really breaking it down, fighting games can be fast, frantic and flashy. You just dial it up a bit to embody Dragon Ball and implement dashing and Ki charging and you generally got it down. With Sonic? I don't know how you balance a homing attack while still having that same satisfying feel as the 3D games, how you make a boost attack work or even just implementing a flow. I mean maybe an arena fighter would be neat because then you could have slopes and springs but then there's the matter of how fast these guys can go, flight and gliding. Even Sonic Battle which got this mostly right struggled.

    • @anoobdissects
      @anoobdissects Před 10 dny

      You bring up a lot of good points! I think there's definitely a case to be made that a fan game reusing concepts and moves from pre-existing games isn't a bad thing at all. Like I said in the video, I don't think the game being an MvC clone on its own is a bad thing, and even with the movesets, had they only been a quarter or even half of the character's kit, I probably would've been willing to cut it a lot more slack. It's the idea that a good chunk of their kits are taken from other fighters that really loses me, but that still doesn't make it a bad game, just one that ends up being a bit lacking for me personally. I also agree that another big reason for the lack of fighting games that wasn't mentioned in the video was how difficult it really is (It's probably also the reason you don't see a lot of successful indie fighters nowadays, but I digress). Definitely something I want to acknowledge in a future sequel to this video. Thank you for commenting!

    • @the-aspiring-creator4249
      @the-aspiring-creator4249 Před 10 dny

      @@anoobdissects I can definitely understand, especially considering just the amount of praise Sonic Smackdown has received. Hopefully with the new version they strike a happy medium between moves pulled from other fighters and original attacks.

  • @LotsOfToubleUsuallySerious

    *Sonic Gather Battle is mentioned* A Noob Dissects: *meniacal laughter*

  • @SUPUHDAN125
    @SUPUHDAN125 Před 12 dny

    where tf is sonic smash flash

  • @LotsOfToubleUsuallySerious

    Any links for 3.1?

    • @Sairrii
      @Sairrii Před 11 dny

      czcams.com/video/yodjqFre_R8/video.htmlsi=S4ooDnE7WFKCC4Tz

  • @RDD756
    @RDD756 Před 12 dny

    u mfs need timestamps!!!!!!!!!

  • @marquesgorham4226
    @marquesgorham4226 Před 12 dny

    How the hell do you get scared of a whole ass language?😂

    • @anoobdissects
      @anoobdissects Před 10 dny

      Well, in my defence, this was when I was a pretty young child and I've very much grown out of it now haha.

  • @SonicSkillsMUGEN
    @SonicSkillsMUGEN Před 13 dny

    Seeing as most of the comments are mentioning MUGEN games, I suggest you check out my MUGEN project Sonic Fighting Heroes: King of The Ring. The characters sprites are based off those from the Sonic Freedom Fighters MUGEN games, but completely repurposed into new characters. It'll be dropping by SAGE for the 2nd time this year, so be on the look out for it!

  • @tcrumsy
    @tcrumsy Před 14 dny

    how has nobody tried to bypass the malware in SGB?

  • @reggielacey2235
    @reggielacey2235 Před 14 dny

    its called sonic battle mugen

  • @TheLegendaryDonutKing

    Sonic gather battle looks like a cool game. Too bad the creator got salty over sprites they don’t even own.

  • @AchilleNkomo-cd1zs
    @AchilleNkomo-cd1zs Před 15 dny

    I like that voice. SUBSCRIBE !!!

  • @silveramyknux241
    @silveramyknux241 Před 15 dny

    25:08 I don’t think allowing donations is bad. And from what I can remember with the Sonic Omens fiasco, Sega doesn’t mind fan projects getting support through patreon or whatever. As long as there aren’t anything locked away from you until you do donate.

  • @megamillion5852
    @megamillion5852 Před 16 dny

    Sad there's no coverage on Super Sonic Knockout. I remembered it from seeing the thumbnail, but good video regardless! It's also very lovely of you to preserve Lost Ending Neo. I truly think it had the potential to be outstanding.

  • @originalkingdomhearts

    Wasn't the last one the thing that got the creator sent to jail?

  • @TheRuggedEchinda
    @TheRuggedEchinda Před 16 dny

    Does anyone remember a Sonic Fighting Fangame that was sprite based and worked kinda like a fast beat em up? It had really good sprite work too, you could even play as super Sonic as his own character and I think it primarily used Adventure Era music. Can’t remember its name.

    • @anoobdissects
      @anoobdissects Před 16 dny

      Would it be Sonic Battle Chaos Greed? That's the one that comes to mind for me.

  • @cristianrodrigues4152

    you should checkout the sega vs capcom fangame, it has sonic as a playable character and it looks promising

  • @keystone5750
    @keystone5750 Před 17 dny

    To answer your question from 0:31, it's because making fighting games is HARD. There's so much you need to do to make it playable, and even more to make it actually feel good to play. When I initially saw Sonic Smackdown was an asset flip, I totally understood why they did that (even if my conclusion was 'well I can just play UMVC3'). Sonic Duel being a brawl modpack is fair. There's so much that goes into a single character. It's especially messed up because everyone who knows about gamedev will say to do art last but good animations are so integral to a fighting game feeling good to play.

    • @dr_drew_
      @dr_drew_ Před 7 dny

      Ong like they talk about these games as if they’re made by professionals and that it should be up to some standard of quality, also they keep mentioning a fanbase having a defacto fighting game with a huge fan base and tournament scene but I’ve never seen that happen to any fanbase

  • @davidholanda1
    @davidholanda1 Před 17 dny

    at least, you didn't talk about that adult Sonic fangame that's technically a fighting game but way way WAY worse than you expect... ughhhh

    • @ajaxmaxbitch
      @ajaxmaxbitch Před 11 dny

      You're talking about Project X love Potion aren't you

  • @Blockyboxguy
    @Blockyboxguy Před 18 dny

    Always thought sonic smackdown was a little too unpolished to take seriously as a “real” game. Big the cat reusing the fucking animal crossing villager’s idle animation from smash is WILD lol

    • @goGothitaLOL
      @goGothitaLOL Před 16 dny

      Brawly reusing Mii Brawler’s idle animation from goddamn Smash Bros alone gave it away from me And the worst part is, that’s just the tip of the iceberg (Vector has Bowser’s F-Smash and Eggman has DK’s Up-B, just to name a few)

  • @lorenzo689
    @lorenzo689 Před 18 dny

    MMZ ost bg music?? new sub, also insert "you missed fighters blitz" comment here haha (But fr its great!) edit: OH! also there's a veery new project called sonic chaos battle (IIRC), looks promising! but it's in a very early stage. as of now it's got 3 characters

  • @kindasomeviews
    @kindasomeviews Před 18 dny

    Yeah something's wrong with Streak. I tried to suggest improvements to the game and he was like "@everyone NO SUGGESTIONS!!!!!!!!!!!", now we cant get updates of the game from other sites that're further than the Balan version??? If only the game had someone else to develop it. This guy is way too dickheaded. He doesnt even put out public updates anymore. Also it's just a thing on Itch that the site asks for a dono to download, but you can press "just take me to the download" at the top of the options

    • @Tsuki_Hisui
      @Tsuki_Hisui Před 17 dny

      The donations prompt got disabled a while back

  • @Sairrii
    @Sairrii Před 18 dny

    would you imagine my surprise when i see my brother in this video as the person who LITERALLY MADE 3.1 might ask him if he still has a copy of the game idk lmao

  • @Morbius-Tension
    @Morbius-Tension Před 18 dny

    I swear this series should have gotten an anime arena fighter spin off just like ultimate ninja storm

    • @KKHell
      @KKHell Před 5 dny

      please no.

    • @Morbius-Tension
      @Morbius-Tension Před 5 dny

      @@KKHell why I think it’ll be 🔥

    • @KKHell
      @KKHell Před 5 dny

      @@Morbius-Tension Arena fighters are complete shit and should have stopped being a subgenre after the late PS2 era, but got so bad Jump Force exists. Just putting it bluntly.

    • @Morbius-Tension
      @Morbius-Tension Před 5 dny

      @@KKHell understandable ik some people believe anime games are going out of style for that read but I believe the Naruto storm games are easily the best of that genre and ik for a fact Sonic fans would eat up a spin off similar to it doesn’t have to become a staple of the series but honestly this franchise hasn’t had any good spin offs lately so this is just me throwing out an idea

  • @postal2forthe3ds
    @postal2forthe3ds Před 18 dny

    oh i remember sonic gather battle so well. being an autistic kid online in the 2010s i had some odd interests, and 2 of them happened to be sonic and computer viruses. my virus fixation had already passed at that point, but i was extremely fixated on sonic, so you just know that sonic gather battle was something i absolutely ate up. i actually didn't know about it's full backstory till i watched this video, so thank you for including it here. i'd also like to mention some other tidbits of interesting info about it you didn't include, not too much, and very quickly: first off, the general search terms of "cheat" and "hack" weren't the only terms that would trigger the malware. there was one more, much broader term, being "mod". this meant that if you so much as had the game open while looking up a mod for a video game, or even something as general as a body mod, it would trigger the malware. also, another thing you didn't mention that i find really interesting is the fact the game was known to be vm aware. you couldn't run the game on a virtual machine, as the game would know, and instantly close itself. i believe someordinarygamers found a workaround to this in his video on sonic gather battle, but i had to have watched that video like 5 years ago at this point, so i wouldn't be able to remember if it was him or another youtuber who made a video about it. the solution i believe was to run it through something called a gaming vm, which i have never heard of up to and after that point, and so don't know anything about. so yeah, the whole thing is really interesting. unfortunately coverage of it isn't as vast as it is for viruses like wannacry, memz, or even gaming viruses such as rensenware, or creepy viruses such as msmajor. its super disappointing, because i bet there'd be more coverage on it and more people opening it up to see how it ticks if it just worked on vms.

  • @Sonic171K
    @Sonic171K Před 19 dny

    Sonic Battle sucks. Sonic The Fighters is alright.

  • @zobirismage2813
    @zobirismage2813 Před 19 dny

    This was a great video, I'd love a part 2 (especially for some juicy Sonic Ultima coverage 👀)

  • @TheShadowspear2
    @TheShadowspear2 Před 19 dny

    Sonic Gather Battle was almost perfect, only thing holding it back was the creator and malware 😂

  • @nuahahahaxd
    @nuahahahaxd Před 19 dny

    have anyone play sonic the fighters blitz ?

  • @IPODsify
    @IPODsify Před 19 dny

    "pair-sec"