Discussing Trek: Star Trek
Discussing Trek: Star Trek
  • 399
  • 56 321
The Logic Library: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Chapters 9 & 10)
Welcome back to the Trekkie Book Club, ah, Logic Library - where we are reindexing our library using the Vulcan Indexing System, one book at a time. We resume our discussion of 'The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko' written by Derek Tyler Attico, as we cover chapters 9 and 1. In this episode, Benjamin finds love and is finally off to Starfleet. Join us as we dive into the deets, look for connections, and give our opinions on the Emmissary's life story!
Get the Book: amzn.to/3WdVtxQ
#TheAutobiographyOfBenjaminSisko
zhlédnutí: 39

Video

So I Watched Logan's Run for the First Time (This Place Looks Familiar)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 836Pƙed 12 hodinami
Everyone has their movie bucket list. And not too long ago a sci-fi cult classic hit my radar that I realized that I had never seen before. That movie is Logan’s Run.
Intergalactic Friendship? Star Trek x Doctor Who
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 86Pƙed 19 hodinami
Alex Kurtzman and Russell T Davies will kick off the celebration with an exclusive conversation at San Diego Comic-Con; plus, a 'Friendship is Universal' gallery experience in the Gaslamp Quarter!
Remembering Jeffrey Hunter's Captain Christopher Pike #HowItStarted
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 11KPƙed 21 dnem
In this video, we take a look at Gene Roddenberry's original vision for a Starfleet Captain. This is a love letter to the first on-screen captain of the USS Enterprise, Captain Christopher Pike - with our friend and playwright Lee Shackleford.
What’s Next for Trek, Final Thoughts on Discovery and Moving on to Starfleet Academy
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 293Pƙed měsĂ­cem
In the episode, we discuss the future state of Star Trek and give some final thoughts on Star Trek: Discovery. As we prepare for Prodigy on Netflix next month, we look a bit further by discussing what we know of the Section 31 movie, Strange New Worlds season three, and the final upcoming season of Lower Decks. We also chat about how much of Discovery DNA we would like to see in Starfleet Academy.
Logical Reads: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Chapters 7 & 8)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 27Pƙed měsĂ­cem
Welcome back to the Trekkie Book Club, ah, Logical Reads - where we take the Vulcan approach, to our Star Trek Literature. We resume our discussion of 'The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko' written by Derek Tyler Attico, as we cover chapters 7 and 8. In this episode, we get into Sisko family's acceptance of Benjamin's pursuit of Starfleet, which a trip to high school presents some challenges of ...
You Pathetic Achworm!
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 131Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
If you enjoy this video please subscribe to our channel and consider supporting us on Patreon at www.patreon.com/discussingnetwork. Let’s Connect discussingtrek www.threads.net/discussingtrek discussingtrek discussingtrek Subscribe to the Podcast apple.discussingtrek.com spotify.discussingtrek.com play.discussingtrek.com/subscribe Discussing Trek is the ul...
Greatest Heist of All Time ...in Star Trek? (Star Trek: Discovery 5.9 Lagrange Point)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 323Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Join me for a discussion of the penultimate episode of Star Trek: Discovery, Lagrange Point. After the Breen Dreadnought led by Moll is able to nab the Progenitor tech before Discovery, our crew is forced to go on a heist of sorts! If you enjoy this video please subscribe to our channel and consider supporting us on Patreon at www.patreon.com/discussingnetwork. Let’s Connect discu...
Star Trek: Discovery "Labyrinths" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 36Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
In this review, we discuss the eighth episode of the fifth and final season of Star Trek: Discovery, Labyrinths. As Burnham attempts to escape a maze of the mind, the Breen enter the Badlands at the behest of Primarch Ra'une, who is now on an unrelenting quest to acquire the Progenitor tech.
Star Trek: Discovery "Erigah" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 74Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Erigah" Review
Nhan's Security Detail is Trash and a Breen Love Story (Star Trek: Discovery 5.7 Erigah)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 136Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Nhan's Security Detail is Trash and a Breen Love Story (Star Trek: Discovery 5.7 Erigah)
Star Trek: Discovery "Whistlespeak" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 49Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Whistlespeak" Review
Soothing as Grandma's Mofongo, Whistle While You Trek (Star Trek: Discovery 5.6 Whistlespeak)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 111Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Soothing as Grandma's Mofongo, Whistle While You Trek (Star Trek: Discovery 5.6 Whistlespeak)
Star Trek: Discovery "Mirrors" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 24Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Mirrors" Review
Ships, Wormholes, and Unmasked Faces (Star Trek: Discovery 5.5 Mirrors)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 254Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci
Ships, Wormholes, and Unmasked Faces (Star Trek: Discovery 5.5 Mirrors)
Section 32: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Chapters 5 & 6)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 39Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Section 32: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Chapters 5 & 6)
Star Trek: Discovery "Face the Strange" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 86Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Face the Strange" Review
Time Bugs and Facing the Strange (Star Trek: Discovery 5.4 Face The Strange)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 359Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Time Bugs and Facing the Strange (Star Trek: Discovery 5.4 Face The Strange)
Star Trek: Discovery "Jinaal" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 67Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Jinaal" Review
Doctor Culber Gets Trill (Star Trek: Discovery 5.3 Jinaal)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 139Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Doctor Culber Gets Trill (Star Trek: Discovery 5.3 Jinaal)
Star Trek: Discovery "Under the Twin Moons" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 20Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Under the Twin Moons" Review
Star Trek: Discovery "Red Directive" Review
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 116Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Star Trek: Discovery "Red Directive" Review
Literary Frontier: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Chapters 3 & 4)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 48Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Literary Frontier: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Chapters 3 & 4)
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season Four
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 54Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season Four
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season Three
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 13Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season Three
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season Two
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 19Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season Two
Trekkie Book Club: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Introduction, Chapters 1 & 2)
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 118Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci
Trekkie Book Club: The Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko (Introduction, Chapters 1 & 2)
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season One
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 25Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci
Best Moments of Star Trek Discovery Season One
Discussing The Star Trek Discovery Official Trailer
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 50Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci
Discussing The Star Trek Discovery Official Trailer
The Visitor, One of Star Trek's Most Heartbreaking Episodes
zhlĂ©dnutĂ­ 784Pƙed 5 měsĂ­ci
The Visitor, One of Star Trek's Most Heartbreaking Episodes

Komentáƙe

  • @terrylandess6072
    @terrylandess6072 Pƙed hodinou

    Hunter was obviously the best choice for film, but they weren't making a Star Trek Film.

  • @AfterTheSnap
    @AfterTheSnap Pƙed dnem

    Dang. The last season of Discovery was the LEAST emotional of them all.

  • @AfterTheSnap
    @AfterTheSnap Pƙed dnem

    It's definitely among the best seasons of Trek, hands down. Star Trek Prodigy

  • @AfterTheSnap
    @AfterTheSnap Pƙed dnem

    I want to watch that episode after hearing y'all laughing😅

  • @AfterTheSnap
    @AfterTheSnap Pƙed dnem

    I used to love card catalogs!

  • @syfysistas
    @syfysistas Pƙed dnem

    Zoey Phillips and Neffie Beumont were mentioned by Joseph Sisko in "Paradise Lost". Thank you for highlighting this novel and our brother Derek Tyler Attico. Check out his new podcast coming September 2024 non SyFy Sistas Inc.đŸ’œđŸ––đŸœ

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed dnem

      Thank you so much. And yes, I saw the announcement on your live stream about Mr. Attico’s new show! We can’t wait for the podcast to drop!

  • @bitukukuasukgremany3
    @bitukukuasukgremany3 Pƙed 2 dny

    I don't know.... there are no black people in that future. Sounds F@cked up to me.

  • @penguinguy2079
    @penguinguy2079 Pƙed 2 dny

    Check out The Scythe of Heaven...

  • @kerryomalley3943
    @kerryomalley3943 Pƙed 2 dny

    I Saw it in the theaters and it has been in my top 3 ever since. I watch my DVD all time, I never tire of it. In the novel, written by SF legends William F. Nolan and George Clayton Johnson, Last day is your 21st birthday, not the 30th

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed 2 dny

      I think I’m goings to pick up the novel. Sounds fun!

  • @radeadcool
    @radeadcool Pƙed 3 dny

    Basil Exposition!

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 3 dny

    Jeff Hunter was great in the 1955 movie White Feather that was a true story.

  • @Bubbles99718
    @Bubbles99718 Pƙed 3 dny

    Love this flick. Wouldn't say it has flaws, more like quirks that give it charm. Supposedly it's a bit different than the book, never read it, want to. It's highly rated.

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed 3 dny

      I may check out the book. A great premise for sure.

  • @Dreamprism
    @Dreamprism Pƙed 4 dny

    5:45 I didn't consciously notice that "came the long way round" quote by Dal, but yeah with the season resembling Doctor Who in some ways that does kind of seem like a reference to the end of Heaven Sent (great episode).

  • @komradewirelesscaller6716

    Brings back happy Trek scifi feelings!

  • @captainobvious9233
    @captainobvious9233 Pƙed 4 dny

    He was great in the role, but I am glad they didn't keep him as Captain for the second pilot. He would have passed away in the middle or just after the 3rd season and we'd never have the Star Trek movies as they are today.

  • @windgraceproject
    @windgraceproject Pƙed 5 dny

    I've never seen this either, but I have seen the Stargate episode which I now realize used this idea! Haha

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed 5 dny

      Oh, i gotta find that episode.

    • @windgraceproject
      @windgraceproject Pƙed 5 dny

      @@DiscussingTrek There are actually several that come to mind, maybe the closest would be "Revisions" even though it's not exactly the same.

  • @AfterTheSnap
    @AfterTheSnap Pƙed 5 dny

    I haven't seen it, but now I want to!

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed 5 dny

      I honestly think it may be way too much of a slog for modern audiences. A remake mode be fun though.

    • @AfterTheSnap
      @AfterTheSnap Pƙed 5 dny

      @@DiscussingTrek the way you described it makes it sound interesting. I hope someone does remake it.

  • @Dreamprism
    @Dreamprism Pƙed 5 dny

    I've never spent time in Dallas / Fort Worth beyond the airport. The water gardens look cool though. I do remember seeing the castle in Pasadena where part of an episode of Season 1 of the TV show "Alias" was filmed. The castle had been converted into apartments, and my dad lived there for a few years. Of course in Alias they pretended it was a place in another country entirely.

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed 5 dny

      What? A castle? That is pretty freaking cool. I need to make a sci-fi filming location bucket list.

    • @Dreamprism
      @Dreamprism Pƙed 4 dny

      @@DiscussingTrek It's a "castle" but built in Pasadena California long after the time that most genuine castles were built.

  • @Dreamprism
    @Dreamprism Pƙed 5 dny

    I honestly never saw it myself. Hadn't even thought about it in a long time.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    You guys are funny. It was a fun visit.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    Yup. Decker’s son was in the first Star Trek movie that had that bald lady who was a Deltan and they were going after V-ger which was one of the Voyager probes.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    Well it was hot in there and who knows how high the radiation was and too late for second thoughts oh what did I do now!

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    That’s one of the great rules of story telling. Show not tell. Great observation.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    You’re right. Kirk was going to soften the blow of Decker’s death by putting in a log entry about Decker giving his life to destroy the machine. And in a way Decker paved the way. They just needed more explosive power. It’s more heroic sounding.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    Decker was thinking that perhaps the shuttle craft’s engines when the shuttle was destroyed would deactivate it. He had the right idea but not enough power that the a starship engines set to explode with a timed detonation fortunately had enough megatons. And he said he was prepared for death ever since his crew died.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    “I told you I’m in command and I’m giving the orders! We’re going to turn and attack!” “Not with my ship you don’t!”

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    McCoy scanning isn’t putting a physical and mental in records so you can read them and Spock knew regulations and he just gave in. But hen Kirk ordered him to “blast regulations” and using his being the captain of his own ship Spock relieved Decker who challenged him again not respecting his authority until he realized Spock would have him under arrest. But on his way to Sickbay to get everything on record that’s when Decker beat up his security officer chaperone. Poor Red shirt.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    I guess Decker figured since he lost command of his ship why not hijack Spock’s command and Spock just backed down which got McCoy pretty ticked. But McCoy hadn’t done an exam and proved with medical records that Decker was unfit. Kirk found out and he commanded Spock to take over. He wasn’t gonna lose his ship like Decker lost his.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    It sorta looked like an elongated TP roll. But when they showed the inside of it with the glowing center that was cool. The radiation in there must be outrageous and hot and Decker was like contorting so it must’ve hurt like heck. And knowing you’re gonna die must not be so pleasant and it looked like he was in a bit of a panic like what did I get myself into now.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    Each starship has a different emblem. Same Star Fleet but different ships, so the Constellation would be different and being a Commodore he also has a different uniform emblem. In Court Martial when everyone was in dress uniform for Kirk’s trial, Commodore Stone his dress uniform had different medals than Kirk had. Just like a dress uniform shirt depending on say First Officer or Doctor would be different insignias.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    Decker was a Commodore over a Captain but one less than an Admiral. Hold it together better? You got a machine ripping apart a planet, phasers are depleted, engines trashed, attacked by the anti proton beam and the transporter trashed so you can’t beam anyone back up who are calling for help, not something you hold yourself together for. He had survivor’s guilt. I know the episode by heart since I listen to it every night to fall asleep along with Balance of Terror. And Kirk made sure Decker didn’t destroy his ship in his obsession to kill the Doomsday Machine.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    The shock of his entire crew on the third planet that was destroyed by the machine and he couldn’t beam them up because his transporter went out. Guess the plan was to inhabit the third planet as the ship was disabled but then the Doomsday Machine ate up the third planet crew and all. The loss was devastating. And who knows how long he had to wait to be found. And it was by accident as the Enterprise was following the trail of destroyed systems. Seeing what happened really did a number on Decker.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    “Matt, where’s your crew?” “On the third planet.” “There is no third planet!” “Don’t you think I know that? There was but not any more! They called me they begged me, 400 hundred of them! I couldn’t I, I, couldn’t!” And Decker broke down sobbing. His transporter was knocked out. Survivors guilt really did him in.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    A couple of times the Doomday Machine did shoot at the Enterprise and for a while the ship was held in a tractor beam until Kirk was able to fire recharged phasers from the Constellation to distract it. It had some sort of perimeter where if you get into it the Doomsday machine would fire this anti proton beam. Out of that perimeter the machine would ignore you. It knocked out the transporter a couple times and Scotty had to do his magic to get it up and running so that Kirk could press the button and beam out before boom. What got me was that the Constellation did the same thing but their phasers were exhausted and Decker kept making the same mistake with the Enterprise. Kirk didn’t want his ship disabled so he commanded Spock to take command away from Decker who tried to use regulations in order to take command back. But Decker also had survivor’s guilt because his transporter was knocked out and his crew beamed down to the third planet which was destroyed. He said he’d been prepared for death ever since he believed he killed his crew. No one had any idea that the thing would go after the planet his crew was on. The gas planet and the real hot one the machine ignored. So he figured if he had to die to destroy thing so be it. So that’s why he stole the shuttle craft. But with a crew of 400, one shuttle craft, other planets in the system being destroyed, power out, and nowhere to go being dead in space, there wasn’t much to do in terms of escape. His guilt and his obsession to kill the thing really took a toll. But his shuttling into the thing was a start in getting the thing from the inside and since the Constellation was on its last legs and the engines could go anytime, it was a pretty nifty weapon and glad it worked. I guess one could take the moral as be careful of the weapons you build since the creators never thought the Doomsday Machine would turn on them as they built it. Weapons have no loyalty. And this one could think for itself one could say.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    When Decker flew into it with the shuttle craft its engines weren’t powerful enough. But a starship’s engines set on overload had just the right amount of megatons of explosive to destroy all the internals of the Doomsday Machine and it was totally deactivated. As Kirk said, Decker had the right idea but not enough power to do it.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    The Doomday Machine wasn’t biological. It was built as a weapon but the creators never expected it to turn on them. It’s like building nuclear weapons. What we forget is that others have them too. Built so strong like Kirk mentioned that they could destroy both sides in a war uncounted years ago. Built as a bluff never meant to be used. Guess the Doomsday Machine had other plans. But it was all machine. They had to destroy it so it wouldn’t go to the occupied Rigel Colony.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    I was watching something else and they said that Nichols had a singing gig. So she was replaced for that one episode. I thought when I first saw it that Uhura just had a day off and was taking a nap in her quarters.

    • @iamclarence
      @iamclarence Pƙed 6 dny

      Yeah. Someone wrote in saying that other than the big three of Nimoy, Shatner, and Kelly everyone else would frequently be in and out due to their contracts and not being top cast. Makes a lot of sense but something that never really dawned on me until it was pointed out. So glad the reoccurring crew got to shine more in the movies.

    • @lisanidog8178
      @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

      @@iamclarence I agree.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    Yes there was somewhat of a backstory. With star charts they traced the machine from the destroyed solar systems to outside from another galaxy. It’s makers made it too good so they don’t exist any more. A deterrent run wild. But how long it had been wandering around eating planets that was never mentioned. But it won’t eat a gas planet or one with a poisonous atmosphere. How long the Constellation was just hanging there before being found was also a mystery.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    What do you mean into the story of it. The whole story was how to destroy the thing since the Doomsday Machine’s outer covering was impervious to weapons.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    The only cheesy fighting I noticed was when the security guard was escorting Decker to sickbay and the security guard got beaten up and then Decker went to get the shuttle craft to fly into the Doomsday Machine. I got the episode on line so what was cut out was Kirk yelling and shaking Decker after he was given a shot to perk him up. I knew that part because I had once VCR’d it. But my new TV can’t be hooked up to a VCR anymore and at the time when I recorded many episodes on a Star Trek special, all the episodes were uncut.

  • @lisanidog8178
    @lisanidog8178 Pƙed 6 dny

    I have it on my IPad and listen to it every night to relax and finally fall asleep. The Doomsday Machine is my second favorite episode next to The Changeling.

  • @brianbaker2455
    @brianbaker2455 Pƙed 7 dny

    Star Trek would have been a vastly different show of The Cage had been accepted as the pilot, I don't think that the show would have been as popular or long-lasting as the show was. I also believe that Hunter as Pike would have been less likely to have been as successful as Shatner as Kirk. The Cage set up an exploration of the responsibility of command and the consequences of action that was never really explored until ST: The Wrath of Khan. It would have been a different show, but who knows if it would have been as successful?

  • @cjones3710
    @cjones3710 Pƙed 7 dny

    The only real Captain Pike. The re cast woke joke stinks

  • @captainspire9094
    @captainspire9094 Pƙed 8 dny

    Ignoring this key aspect of Pike, the poor too dang fast pacing and the constant need to revisit old stories and screw them up is why SNW was a dumbed down pointless series.

    • @jv-lk7bc
      @jv-lk7bc Pƙed 12 hodinami

      they do have an unfortunate revisionist streak. They really should have left "Balance of Terror" alone. that was not a high point.

  • @windgraceproject
    @windgraceproject Pƙed 8 dny

    Robert picardo as another missing regeneration?

    • @DiscussingTrek
      @DiscussingTrek Pƙed 8 dny

      đŸ€ŁđŸ€ŁđŸ˜‚đŸ˜‚ make it so

  • @johnnybravado7141
    @johnnybravado7141 Pƙed 9 dny

    The Star Trek that could've been had Jeffery Hunter been kept on the show. Though William Shatner and Captain Kirk did make the show legend, I'm glad to see that they are finally filling the history gap between the two captains. It's just a shame that we have to first pass through the junkyard that is discovery before we can watch it.

  • @stevendeans4211
    @stevendeans4211 Pƙed 9 dny

    Jeffery Hunter made a great captain Pike in spite of a bit of a Christ complex.

  • @catsupchutney
    @catsupchutney Pƙed 9 dny

    Bear in mind most of the writers remembered the second world war and were probably veterans.

  • @davidlancaster8152
    @davidlancaster8152 Pƙed 9 dny

    Kinda reminds of pixar animation. Thanks for keeping me informed. You be smooth on the narration. Love it.