Video

2024

❤❤❤

Yes. Miming indeed. There are plenty of videos of them singing this perfectly - LIVE.

Clearly lip synched since the song had multiple voice tracks. BUT that is so far beyond the point and spirit of the song & event. Another Bee Gees masterpiece and they lived up to their promise.

Hermosa canción saludos desde República Dominicana

❤❤❤ X Siempre .

The story of my hair over 45 years right there.

Is this perfect masterpiece still raising money for UNICEF? ❤

As i understand there are 27 tracks consisting of each guy doing 9 tracks. However lip sync they may be doing but this is thier own voices not someone else. This is the bee gees on full throttle. I see no shame in lip sync as it is thier singing anyways. Now doing it when they didn't record it at all that's a different story

Of course lip synched. This song was multi-layered mostly with Barry's vocal falsetto and would be impossible to justifiably sing live with its true beauty & charm. They eventually sang this live as part of a medley in their concerts starting in 1989 but using their normal registers only.

One of the best songs ever written❤

❤❤❤

Beautiful

Lip sync. Standard for 1979.

Watching it all over and over again till now ,2024.

It's all lip synced, it was common back then for TV.

Wow!!!

Mon dieu que cette chanson est belle ❤ et chanté divinement ❤❤❤, j adore les Bee Gees ❤❤❤

太好听了🎉2024

I love Robin's voice.

For those who stoped by to watch this song again, 2024.

4:40 me eriza la piel oír esta parte

Los hermanos Gibb the brother's Gibb SEÑORAS Y SEÑORES, PARA TODO EL MUNDO THE BEE GEES!!!,👏🏿👏🏾👏👏🏽

You can tell by watching Maurice that they were lip syncing. He didn't like lip syncing and he was all awkward and not into it.

One of the greatest!

these comments say it all... Viva the Brothers Gibb! 💎 💞💫

Such joy it is to listen and to be able to watch them ❤❤❤

I’ve never seen the new gees lip sync before but I noticed when Barry wasn’t singing his voice was still singing with Robin and mo

It is definitely lip sync,... I know for fact. I am an arranger and there are 5 harmony parts (all double tracked) and there are only 3 singing,... they have mastered the lip sync very well though especially Barry : )

They don't need to lipsync, I've seen them live at Wembley stadium,they were awesome 👍

Everyone lipsynched on television, until maybe the 80s? That’s why they thought they could pull off the Milli Vanilli scam on the public. And it worked for a while.

Jan 2024, I'm still listening ❤❤❤

Grandes,mis ídolos,siempre están en mi memoria,que tal trío THE BEE GEES FOREVER.

Not lip syncing

Lip sing of course cos they could not reach those notes anymore

This was a lipsynch as they were never able to perform that track live. It was Barry's voice multitracked numerous times. Overproduction is an understatement!

They are sining live you can see it in their breathing and neck muscles. But that doesnt mean the unicef people didnt play the track on top of their live performance

Yes this trio always sang their songs very seriously in their performance. But in this perform they were very relax as if they were not under real situation for singing. I do believe it was lip sync. But they always big legend in history..

Eles realmente cantaram em 79 ao vivo, mas obviamente neste vídeo, foi usado a gravação de estúdio. Não sei nem se existia lip sync, conceito de fazer isso naquela época.

O que escrever?? Só ouvir mesmo!! O trio perfeito 😊😊😊

Perhaps live but with backing vocal tracks for the layers? Who knows? It's awesome anyway. Pure talent.

Never doubt a Bee Gee

Definitely they're lip-synching. The unicef website for this concert says they were lip-syncing. But, they obviously can sing it live and did so many times. There are so many vocal layers that maybe they wanted the full effect for this concert so they went for playback.

That song made $10 million and all proceeds went to UNICEF $10 million back in 1980 was a batch of money

Nunca los voy a olvidar serán siempre mis favoritos.

Yes.

They are my favorite band!!! The Bee Gee's voices are pure gold!!!! They are just superbly lovely!!! 🌹🌹🌹...

Bee Gees minha gente.👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️❤️

These guys are G’s! Including Andy.

Grandes mis Bee Gees,los 4 son fantasticos forever.