Video

The Romany were always blamed as they were poor and outsiders.

Horrible woman. Couldn’t she just as easily have disowned her child and refused to pay any more for her care?

Human bites are setious, would be a felony charge today (because of AIDS)

I think it was very dangerous to be a "pretty girl" in the 1800's especially. I'm waiting for him to say just once: "She was a homely girl, which men never gave a second glance ". Lol 😂

I love how he says “induce a miscarriage” instead of in an attempt to “kill the baby” sounds much nicer to say it the first way.

What a demon passing as human purepure evil.This is very tragic.RIP to the innocent SOULS

Is the narrator AI? Occasionally pick up Staffordshire accent

Thank you BC This was interesting and unjust for those innocent people who sadly died

Stop drinking Tea from this despicable woman

fun fact: there is a series that is exactly telling the stories of it

You and the crime reel are my favourite channels. Do you know each other well? I've heard you mention each other.

Loved it

This is weird coincidence my name is Martin (the accused) and my last name is Wiggins (the coroner) never seen that in a CZcams video before

💼

What a sad case! Life was tough for women in the 19th century.. Work in the textile mills was notoriously difficult.. long hours in a dusty, noisy and hot environment.. and pregnancy was *always* the woman's fault! Although abortion was an illegal act, Dr Smith was guilty of manslaughter, not murder imo.. Poor Miss Caswell.. of course she contributed to her own demise with those earrings.. 🤦🏻‍♀️ Thanks for another fascinating story, BC💼

i'm not into old fashioned women, but i could definitely get into her.

Sad and interesting story.

Life was rough, especially for women. Things hadn't changed too much by the 1970s when I hurriedly got married.

“Still missing.” *sonic boom*

If Iftikhar had the courage to stand up against his family, he would've stayed with his Danish wife and would stay integrated and liberal with the western culture. Too bad he let the conservatism slide inside his mind.

I was so glad this had a happy ending! Justice prevailed!

The people who said he said he would harm the family or whatever why didn't they say anything before they held him?

When in doubt you should just look for the guy with the child molester mustache.

Society is so different in different parts of the world. At one time in different parts of the world, if a woman had a girl first child, the baby would be killed. Whether thrown in a river or thrown down a well to drown. SO SICK! A man wanted and had to have a Male first child. It was status for a man to have a male Heir. Now, I have to wonder what a man did when he couldn’t produce a male child. Were the baby girls killed until there was a boy born??? Sometimes, MANY times, men do not produce boys. What a HORRIBLE practice!!! .

Mate. Your subject matter and your beautifully written narration is 2nd to none

She really was a very pretty girl, poor lass 😢 rip Elizabeth xx

Thank you for this crime story Brief Case xx

❤❤❤❤❤

❤❤❤❤❤😮

What gruesome evil people! The little girl who was buried alive just is so horrifying! Brief Case, you bring us the most incredible episodes! I believe that Hell has a special place for the Evil soul's.

It's criminal how women were looked down on when unmarried and pregnant and divorced. Abusive partners and still got their wives/partners pregnant, in my personal experiences men haven't changed that much but thank god society has... this poor young lady, I hope she's resting in forever peace xx

Wow! Echoes of today. This had it all. Lack of women’s rights,a dr who lacked the knowledge that dr’s have today (today,many people want to remove that knowledge from Dr’s. People won’t acknowledge that women will still have abortions, even if it’s in a dark alley.) A murder case that went all the way up to the Supreme Court. It begs the same questions we are facing today. Is it illegal to perform an abortion? Is it a right that woman should have autonomy over their own bodies? Shouldn’t men be held equally responsible for a pregnancy? This story reminds us that the more things change, at the core, they remain the same 😢

Its like a cautionary tale that no one listened to....in our post-Dodd society this becomes a story that could very well happen - no, IS happening - in many US states today. Women's medical care had come a long way but we let it slip back to Here here's day. Shame is on us.

Abortion is wrong and this poor woman would have kept her child if she wasn’t lied to about seeing a doctor to help her

What a contrast between those unfortunate girls, desperate for some escape from society's condemnation to what we have today.. girls who consider getting pregnant in order to live off the benefit system while watching day-time TV. The pendulum has swung way too far in the opposite direction.

Really appreciate that you cover the less well known cases. I stopped following other “true crimers” as they all seem to cover the same cases and it gets boring after awhile. Can always expect a new and unusual case from you - many thanks!

😎👍

Wow! What a very sad story. None of it ended well for anyone. It seems that when it comes to infidelity, it never works out well. Another edge of your seat case. I love you BC for your hard work and dedication to giving us a much happier Monday!

The problem with putting a lovely young woman to sell cigars to men from all walks of life could have something to do with her murder. Poor young lady and others like her of the times. No real security or protection. RIP sweet young ladies.

While I agree that the doctor was not guilty of murder, but manslaughter, he should not have been set free. Rather, his sentence should have been adjusted accordingly. After all, he did cause a death while breaking the law. Bill should have somehow faced charges as well, as I believe he coerced Berengera to terminate the pregnancy. She wanted to get married but he wasn't willing to do the honorable thing. All that aside, the victim-shaming is dreadful. Did they seriously think she deserved to die or invited death because she wore a pair of earrings? Seems like the good doctor had a well-deserved visit from karma.

Diverse population then, i don't think so, apart from that your vids are enjoable.

Always fun when an episode of Brief Case crosses over with an episode of Buzzfeed Unsolved

Typical double standards. 😠

Thank you. I really appreciate it. I needed this today.

The lesson here is that if you are an unmarried woman in the 19th century, do not risk becoming pregnant.

Keep up the good work Brief Case, your crushing it.❤

I wonder how Mr and Mrs Ching got to Australia.

Karma!!!!

Aww poor duchess, all she wanted was here husbands love...typical she gives him 10 kids and he loses interest in her..shallow man... rest in peace Francois , you were too good for him...another brilliant crime story Brief Case, thank you xx

Love it, back then justice meant justice unlike today she would be out in a few yrs.