Creating Heaven on Earth
Creating Heaven on Earth
  • 5
  • 485 055
"If Everybody Had a Heartful of Love" sung by Monica, Nicole, and Lois: Mennonite Acapella Singing
I grew up in the Holdeman Mennonites, and we weren't allowed to have instruments so we sang a capella with harmony. I love playing my piano now that I've left the group, but I still love singing with my mom and youngest sister Nicole! Enjoy! This song is by Albert E. Brumley.
Check out my sister's dance channel: czcams.com/channels/xwQ1-D3mI1QJ792ECCqqYw.html
You can find me at:
Blog: monicarosewrites.wordpress.com/
Instagram art page: monicarosepaints
Facebook art page: monicarosepaints
zhlédnutí: 4 088

Video

How Leaving a Strict Religious Group is Like Being in a Global Pandemic by Monica Rose
zhlédnutí 3KPřed 4 lety
I haven't posted anything in a while and since I'm at home, I have extra time on my hands. :) Enjoy. If you want to check out how I used creativity to get through leaving the Holdeman Mennonite group, go here: monicarosewrites.wordpress.com/2021/02/27/a-picture-is-worth-a-thousand-words/ Music credits go to: www.bensound.com/ You can find me at: Blog: monicarosewrites.wordpress.com/ Instagram a...
Why I left the Holdeman Mennonites by Monica Rose
zhlédnutí 41KPřed 5 lety
Here I tell some of the reasons I left the Holdeman Mennonite culture 8 years ago. If you would like to see how my story informs my art, check out my Instagram post about it here: pB9ZwxHUJ-0l/ If you'd like to hear some Mennonite style acapella music by my mom, sister, and I, click here: czcams.com/video/Tv2-_Ut66lg/video.html You can find me at: Blog: monicarosewrites.wordpress...
Answering questions about the Holdeman Mennonite prayer covering by Monica Rose
zhlédnutí 7KPřed 5 lety
A bit more behind the customs of the head covering. One detail I forgot to mention: the women are only required to wear the covering after they have been baptized and are a member of the church. Also I hope the audio is better this time. I don't have a microphone. If you would like to see how my story informs my art, check out my Instagram post about it here: pB9ZwxHUJ-0l/ or blo...
How Mennonite women do their hair by Monica Rose
zhlédnutí 430KPřed 5 lety
A demonstration of how Holdeman Mennonite women do their hair. A prayer covering or 'head covering' is what we called it. If you have any questions, feel free to comment below. Enjoy! I made a video answering several of your questions: czcams.com/video/clmwhvPv2mM/video.html If you'd like to listen to some Mennonite acapella style music by my mom, sister, and I, click here: czcams.com/video/Tv2...

Komentáře

  • @mzmishel7953
    @mzmishel7953 Před 4 měsíci

    I’m so happy for you. I’m glad you were able to get free. Thank you for sharing your heart and experience. ❤

  • @A.RandomLattin
    @A.RandomLattin Před 5 měsíci

    Harken then thine ear unto the voice of Tradition, for I have not entered into thy life to replace the Scriptures, nor do I wish to. But I beseech thee that thou wouldst seek the word of the Lord, to see if I be based upon biblical principles or if I be sheer Tradition. Forthwith thou must know where I be from, for thou dost need to know the difference between the two. If I be but sheer Tradition, then ye must see Scripture and Tradition dwell together in unity. And if ye find that we may not, then remove me from thee. For I do not wan to withhold thee from the wisdom of God! But I would rather assist thee in abiding in it. -A. Random Lattin

  • @Finny_finn_finn
    @Finny_finn_finn Před 5 měsíci

    I have worn my hair up for so many years that it feels...and looks odd to me when it's down. I have known people for years that have never seen it down but those who get a rare glimpse are usually shocked by the length and how full it is...I have been wearing it down at night in the privacy of my home...people try to convince me to wear it down when I go to town...and I just can't

  • @user-rb5eh7yo2m
    @user-rb5eh7yo2m Před 5 měsíci

    Wow ur so adorable wtf. Ddid you feel like you got any new idendity crisis when you left? Or do you just feel a freedom and relief?

  • @datbat1
    @datbat1 Před 7 měsíci

    I've been out of the church for more than 20 years, now, but this brings back some lovely memories. Thank you for doing this video. By the way, many people don't realize that all those bobby pins set off the metal detectors at airports. Taking your hair down, going through the detectors, and putting your hair back up is no small feat. They don't always make you do it, but sometimes you get a stubborn TSA agent. Oh, well. That's life.

  • @SolSkinn
    @SolSkinn Před 8 měsíci

    My great grandfather was a big deal mennonite. Meaning, he was ex communicated. It's probably a good thing because I could never fit my hair in one of those! I think it is cute though!

  • @uriahpeep9008
    @uriahpeep9008 Před 10 měsíci

    Monica: I have studied the Holderman Mennonite church (also called Church of God in Christ, Mennonite). You really need to go into MORE detail about the abusive practices of this group. It includes shunning, coercion, intense monitoring of the members as to practice and belief, and so forth. There have been many court cases against this group where rape was committed upon its women and children. This group is on the same level for its horrible abuse as Jehovah's Witness and the Scientology church. This group will kill not only your soul but also your body. Their fiendish practices need to be understood by everyone. This particular group is NOT to be confused with other mainline Mennonite groups. Yes, these groups have their own problems, but NOTHING on the scale of the Holderman group.

  • @germaineewertz6285
    @germaineewertz6285 Před rokem

    thank you.

  • @brandoncornish5295
    @brandoncornish5295 Před rokem

    I definitely understand why you left I left for similar reasons

  • @stonegiant4
    @stonegiant4 Před rokem

    Thanks for the insight.

  • @Daytonabeach2022
    @Daytonabeach2022 Před rokem

    Thank you for sharing your story! I appreciate it :) You are very well spoken!

  • @fionafornarina7625
    @fionafornarina7625 Před rokem

    When you use the bonnet anyway, why putting a hair web underneath? Those hair clips are very sturdy already. I still see your point that for longer and thicker hair, a hair net will add more stability just in case the pins aren't that strong.

  • @sophialee8843
    @sophialee8843 Před rokem

    Im so happy for you. The road to recovered is long after leaving a cult, but you are a very strong brave woman . I'm an ex Jehovah witness It was very painful at the beginning but the best is yet to come .

  • @mo-end-times-info
    @mo-end-times-info Před rokem

    HI Monica - came across your video on YT today - it is three years since the video was posted, wonder how you are now? I was raised in the Roman Catholic religion from infancy and can relate to the oppressive nature of religion and some of the issues it causes - by the grace of God I found the Good News of salvation by grace alone through faith alone in Jesus Christ alone via the word of God and not via religion - eternal life in Jesus - and left the RCC around 2016 - went on a long journey trying to find a group to gather with - did not find one - many different teachings here and there that do not fit the Bible also my own vulnerabilities and shortcomings and issues - now living back in Northern Ireland where I was raised from around five years old. The religious atmosphere is still here but different, more so perhaps - some saved Christians but a lot of religious type beliefs as opposed to free grace - so it is challenging - left friends behind in Scotland - also challenging - just dropping by to share that religion to get saved or the stay saved can be so oppressive ( and can damage mental health, I agree and damage the self that God gave us to be) I also am in self imposed isolation due to the challenges from people's superstitious behaviours and some sort of pattern of speech which seems to be the norm here, but which i cannot quite figure out or match - but there are blessings here in the creation around and other things - missing friends, but cannot go back under the yoke of religion ( re-lig-ion , means to re-bind, I believe) Jesus sets us free, by believing in and trusting Him alone - a relationship, not a religion - hope you are well and flourishing - explored psychology also and some philosophy - probably got some insights, but now feel God's way gives more peace and hope - God Bless you and guide you. Moira, Northern Ireland

  • @charles2521
    @charles2521 Před rokem

    You are very cute, I am glad you are free now. If you want to tell it, I would like to hear your story, how you felt discovering a whole new world.

  • @yttube4319
    @yttube4319 Před rokem

    I found this style hard to do. It takes a long time to get used to, but once you reach proficiency then it's easy. I've had many interesting conversations about transitioning to a white cap. There are a number of candidates who decided to not join the Church of God in Christ (Holdeman's) and join say the Amish Mennonites (Beachy) or Fellowship Churches as the white cap and round bun is just easier. I suspect the use of photography and willingness to listen to accapella hymns or bible or preaching recorded was also a factor.

  • @fubringbackdownvotecounts3379

    Even The Beatles sang, "All You Need Is Love". ;)

  • @ladybugauntiep
    @ladybugauntiep Před rokem

    I am proud of you for speaking up and speaking out.. you are very brave. ❤️ Allow yourself to breathe.. just breathe…,

    • @creatingheavenonearth
      @creatingheavenonearth Před rokem

      Thank you ❤ I appreciate it!!!

    • @ladybugauntiep
      @ladybugauntiep Před rokem

      @@creatingheavenonearth You are speaking for more people than you realize… my upbringing was more Plymouth brethren but just as stifling… I love God and want to walk in His ways too, but legalism can paralyze us if we allow it too… it’s taken me years to find freedom in Christ … stay on your path.. ❤️

  • @Vegetarianbull
    @Vegetarianbull Před rokem

    Looks like edwardian era

  • @pth6060
    @pth6060 Před 2 lety

    If you are not happy or comfortable with a certain church group, it's not wrong to leave. What is wrong is when people stop serving God and being a Christian. Just because we have nobody to be accountable to, doesn't mean that we are not accountable.

  • @HernMasterPain
    @HernMasterPain Před 2 lety

    I’m sorry for what you went through. There are more liberal(open to modernity, not necessarily politically liberal) mennonite communities and churches that are pretty normal and supportive of their people. I’m sorry that it can wear you down though, and I hope you feel better.

  • @pth6060
    @pth6060 Před 2 lety

    The Mennonites are some of the most loving, caring, sincere people on the planet. From what I have seen, most people that leave the Mennonites usually adapt to the world very quickly, and by that of course lose their relationship with Jesus Christ.

    • @Spock_Rogers
      @Spock_Rogers Před rokem

      That seems rather passive aggressive.

    • @charles2521
      @charles2521 Před rokem

      I am not an expert on the subject, but I have heard some very creepy stories about Mennonite communities.

    • @christianmama2441
      @christianmama2441 Před rokem

      @@charles2521 As there are very creepy stories in any group of people in every nation. It is human nature, not so much specific to a certain group. Sin is everywhere, religious community or secular.

    • @weylin32
      @weylin32 Před 3 měsíci

      Yeah no you can't see any of what goes on inside when you are outside. You have absolutely no idea what people experience.

  • @pth6060
    @pth6060 Před 2 lety

    I am a Mennonite and I am open-minded as well. I do not feel that the Mennonite church that I'm a part of is a cult in any way, we are free to do whatever we want so long as it doesn't violate Bible principle. I would not want to do anything anyway that would hurt my brothers and sisters in Jesus and hurt my relationship with Jesus Christ. Feeling that I don't have freedom I have found is when I have a problem in my heart, and have lost my relationship with Jesus.

  • @tressajantzen4136
    @tressajantzen4136 Před 2 lety

    I was raised holdeman Mennonite in DeRidder, la and have been out 16 yrs. praise God for showing you the truth. It’s unfair for us or anyone that is raised in a religious cult like this to go through some of the experiences and spiritual abuse.

  • @larrybaker9924
    @larrybaker9924 Před 2 lety

    Do the women shave,trim,or go full bush ?

  • @larrybaker9924
    @larrybaker9924 Před 2 lety

    You are very fetching.

  • @linyea617
    @linyea617 Před 2 lety

    Did it ever occur to you that those feelings or vibes may have only been from your specific church or denomination..... There probably are thirty or more stripes of Mennonite so please don't paint us All with one brush

    • @weylin32
      @weylin32 Před 3 měsíci

      Did you see the part in big letters at the beginning of the video that said Holdeman Mennonites?

  • @anotherslytheringirl6249

    You were a horrific bully to me and I nearly killed myself because of you and your cousins but you seem to have grown

  • @sophiemorrison9820
    @sophiemorrison9820 Před 2 lety

    I have long hair. When i wear it up for the better part of a day and take it down for bed I find my scalp is sore from all the clips and things. I imagine that is the case with you, too. Thanks for sharing.

  • @robinlies9644
    @robinlies9644 Před 2 lety

    Wow! Thank you! I had no idea so much was involved. That's alot of work.

  • @sarahstubblefield7710

    Thanks for your thoughtful contribution

  • @LRJJwealth
    @LRJJwealth Před 2 lety

    Congratulations young lady, I live in a area with Mennonites and Amish and interact with them frequently..their always seems to be a hidden sadness or a change in facial demeanor when leaving to return home.

  • @xxLivinginTheLightxx
    @xxLivinginTheLightxx Před 2 lety

    Oh let's not forget that expression of feelings is absolutely unacceptable. Crying is not accepted. Ugh!!! It seems beautiful in the beginning, but then you realize it's completely broken and abusive!

  • @xxLivinginTheLightxx
    @xxLivinginTheLightxx Před 2 lety

    I can absolutely tell that you were raised holdeman by the way you speak. Thank you for sharing! May I ask, are you from Manitoba? You have the classic Manitoba accent within the "church".

  • @xxLivinginTheLightxx
    @xxLivinginTheLightxx Před 2 lety

    They are abusive!

  • @heikoebbenga3355
    @heikoebbenga3355 Před 2 lety

    Monica there is always a way back into the Mennonite community. We going to a church in south Missouri.

  • @shawbrothersgirl2740
    @shawbrothersgirl2740 Před 2 lety

    Even now I'm struggling with depression and questioning God sometimes *HOWEVER I know he loves me despite what I'm going through* the rejection the failures because I count my blessings and the other good things I got going on in my life like my own business and I'm able to make money and then whenever sickness tries to attack me I bind it and cast it out in the name of Jesus and it usually goes away so I count my blessings *and he loves you too please do not leave God you may leave religion two different things but don't leave God* for what does it profit a man Jesus says to gain the whole world and possibly lose your soul? *Now I did see hell in a vision and it does exist* but you and the viewers may not believe me it's fine but I'm speaking to you directly to your heart and your mind are you really going to take that chance to live the life you want to live I'm not saying that you can't dance and stuff like that because you were deprived of that stuff for years apparently but I'm saying to leave God altogether and just believe in scientists or New age religion or consciousness you going to take that chance with your soul and then when you die possibly go to hell you know you only have one life and there's eternity after that life has ended and it's either eternity in heaven or eternity in hell so are you really willing to take that chance with your life and your soul just for some temporary pleasure until you're around 80 years old? REALLY? I pray God speaks to your heart and gives you understanding and for you to make the right choice but please do not let the devil deceive you but like I said keep pressing and do not believe the false doctrine of consciousness or the false doctrine of New age religion or the false doctrine of doing what you feel because that's how the devil works he works on our feelings for us to do what we want to do Jesus said that the spirit is willing but our flesh is weak so the devil did the same thing to Eve he worked on her feelings she felt good about it and so she did what she wanted to do even though God told her not to eat from that tree And now not only Eve paid for that sin but Adam and all of us women paid for her sins so I'm praying for you that you will make the right choice and do not let the devil deceive you into false doctrine of consciousness and New age religion I haven't been to a church in a long time but I do have an online fellowship that I worship with and I encourage you to join it's on Wednesdays Fridays and Sundays feel free to join in via chat and or by phone and if asked how were you invited just tell them sister precious told you about the ministry and she's also a prophetess and if the spirit leads her would tell you everything you need to know I'm praying for you Apostle Sharon Hamilton m.czcams.com/users/ApostleSharonHamiltoncommunity Services is on Wednesdays Fridays and Sundays via live chat or over the phone from 6:00 a.m. till about 3:00 p.m. EST sometimes finishes early sometimes finishes later you can join in at any time

  • @cbaymult9411
    @cbaymult9411 Před 2 lety

    Bible something is very bad. Jesus and God do not approve of it. It destroys brains. Jesus did not like churches and said go to the mountain to pray in private.

  • @wabawaba2339
    @wabawaba2339 Před 2 lety

    Those people are interbreeding way to much and that is biologically wrong and just flat out wrong in every context religious and secular

  • @krista3108
    @krista3108 Před 2 lety

    girl you look so familiar to me!!! 🤗 i use to be holdeman as well

    • @creatingheavenonearth
      @creatingheavenonearth Před 2 lety

      😊 I'd love to exchange stories if you want to! My email is monicarosewrites@gmail.com

    • @krista3108
      @krista3108 Před 2 lety

      @@creatingheavenonearth sent email

  • @jeansaben9954
    @jeansaben9954 Před 2 lety

    my scalp would itch/but I admire their commitment

  • @tbro2476
    @tbro2476 Před 2 lety

    Hey monica how do I join the holdeman mennonites?

    • @fourscot
      @fourscot Před 2 lety

      You dont want to

    • @uriahpeep9008
      @uriahpeep9008 Před 10 měsíci

      If you are a glutton for abuse (body and soul) then go right ahead. But, be prepared for a horror experience of your life. The lesson is.....LOOK before you leap.

    • @Dylan-zz7bw
      @Dylan-zz7bw Před 4 měsíci

      i would suggest you attend and see what you think of them... don't listen to random people on the internet.... just look up on Google a church near you and attend... god bless you and i wish you the best

  • @fa__ti
    @fa__ti Před 3 lety

    and the rest is not hair? why only cover the collet? the whole head is hair.

  • @josecarvlho356
    @josecarvlho356 Před 3 lety

    Awesome video , do you know which state has more Menonites and are they the same as Mormons or Amish ??? Awesome hair and video .

    • @creatingheavenonearth
      @creatingheavenonearth Před 3 lety

      Thanks! Kansas would have the most Holdeman Mennonites, and yes they're different from Amish and Mormons.

  • @acjohn6995
    @acjohn6995 Před 3 lety

    Even though you left the church, would you ever go back to one for service once in a while? My Holdeman friend is getting married soon, looking forward to it, always good singing and food. I wish I could learn sight-reading better, it's fun to sing those songs. For a female trio song, check out "Love Amazing."

    • @creatingheavenonearth
      @creatingheavenonearth Před 3 lety

      Yeah I have, for my cousins' weddings etc. I miss the singing sometimes and I still use the recipes!!!

    • @acjohn6995
      @acjohn6995 Před 3 lety

      @@creatingheavenonearth If you ever come to Kansas, I'll go with you!

    • @uriahpeep9008
      @uriahpeep9008 Před 10 měsíci

      The Holderman Mennonite church is an abomination because of the crimes its OWN members are allowed to commit among its women and children. This group is dangerous to members, both body and soul. I would not be encouraging anyone to go near this insane group. Read Wikipedia for info on this cult.

  • @ancientlandmark_
    @ancientlandmark_ Před 3 lety

    Beautiful 🕊🌟

  • @noblejonnycali
    @noblejonnycali Před 3 lety

    ✨❤️✨

  • @savvygood
    @savvygood Před 3 lety

    Lovely! I appreciate a nice harmony.

  • @evelyne7071
    @evelyne7071 Před 3 lety

    Are you “shunned”?

    • @creatingheavenonearth
      @creatingheavenonearth Před 3 lety

      Yes and no. Technically shunning for the Holdeman Mennonites, or 'excommunication', means the member sits the ex-member at a separate table to eat when eating together, is not allowed to do business with an ex-member or shake hands, or give the Christian greeting (the holy kiss). Ex-members are also not allowed to attend members meetings or hold any position such as school board member, youth leader, Sunday school teacher, etc in the church. The rules about eating at separate tables and shaking hands get relaxed often. Or they find a way around it by having everybody sit around the living room to eat instead of at a table, etc. But a person can lose business by getting expelled. It's different than the Amish shunning. It can be emotionally extremely difficult.