Video

ჩემი გენიალური თამუნა! უფ, როგორ ვისიამოვნე!

So lovely & so incredibly disciplined.

Out.....fkin.....standing....!!! I am crying, wonderfull!!!!

The GOAT!...

This is genuinely the BEST interpretation of this toccata I’ve ever come across. It’s just mastered to perfection. The level of dynamics, the timing, everything. It’s absolutely incredible. I come back to watch this performance every so often because it’s just addicting, it gets better each time I hear it! I wish she was more well known!

I've gone down into the rabbit hole with this piece, watching others play this

Par contre elle est meilleure dans la très difficile Toccata de PROKOFIEFF , sur le plan technique...mais elle manque de nuances.Tout cela demeure sur le même plan et finit par être barbant.Elle accentue trop l'aspect percussif. Voici ma note : 6 / 20. Lionel VIGNERESSE.

Complètement hors contexte : elle prend un TGV et cela presse !!! Aucune expression pour faire chanter le simple charme de cette pièce sans prétention.Du coup le passage en triolets de doubles croches donne une impression de fausse virtuosité.Sans compter des notes complètement inventées et qui ne sont pas de BEETHOVEN.Elle veut se croire dans une grande sonate en gonflant le texte alors qu'il s'agit d'une poésie pastorale sans nulle prétention. Soyons honnêtes : l'aspect technique de ce rondo est facile , d'un degré très simple.En le jouant ainsi à toute embardée cela donne l'impression que c'est difficile à maîtriser. Je conseille l'interprétation de RICHTER.Lui , grand musicien , pouvait comprendre ce genre de pièce sans prétention , comme dans le rondo en sol majeur du même opus 51. Voici ma note : 1, 5 / 20...et c'est bien payé ! Lionel VIGNERESSE.

estoy atraida jaja

beautiful au nat

I always enjoy marvelling at this performance: Magnifico!!

WOW -

Tan rápido???

One of the best Toccata, perhaps more intense than the Juya Wang one

The best definitely

2:38-2:45 omg that change in texture…

Mamacita

The Chopin nocturnes not dreamy enough/too factual for my taste. The other works could be more subtle and intimate at times. The tone could be gentler and less 'brittle'.

Very factual: could do with rounding off. Only Grade V Associated Board exams!

I have to keep listening to this performance to appreciate all the details that most pianists miss. Although the great show-masters of this piece can achieve playing all the notes and reduce the time element to 80% of the length of this performance, much is lost in the melee of notes and blurring pedal (to disguise wrong notes?) producing an almost cacophonic result!!!

Excellent interpretation in bringing out parts which the listener does not normally hear. Also clear, not muddied by the pedal.

This is hardcore gangsta rap but in classical era

Such an exquisite story reveals itself in this incredible articulation of the keyboard. Wow! Absolutely beautiful, Tamar Beraia. Thank you for sharing this incredibly inspirational recital. :)

I feel guilty for listening to this for free. I am in DENIAL. This is such an awesome performance; I also just listened to your Prokofiev Toccata and I have a new favourite pianist!

Amazing

Respect, Salute & Love From Hindustan india.

Très belle lecture. Magnifique musicienne. Prokofiev a certainement adoré!

clumsy

Fantastic interpretation!

The figure of her playing the piano is not beautiful, but I can feel her heart trying to play it correctly. The music is hard and the sound is not beautiful, but it's a very accurate piano performance.

I had a Pollini recording of this work as a teenager. Very impressive playing.

Технично, выразительно, темпераментно!

Tamar is an excellebt pianist. Hope to hear more of her playing.

VERY nicely done.

E' incredibile scoprire quanti grandi talenti possono esserci oggi nel mondo, ed è per questo che non dobbiamo fissarci sui soliti nomi. Bisognerebbe sempre guardarsi in giro e scoprire (visto che oggi si può), e sorprendersi, come è accaduto a me oggi ascoltando questa incredibile interpretazione della Toccata di Prokofiev. Personalmente non conoscevo la Beraia e me ne rammarico, visto che questa sua performance mi ha letteralmente lasciato a bocca aperta. Malgrado l'infelice audio, posso dire di aver comunque assistito ad una attentissima, precisa, nervosa, intensissima lettura di questa meravigliosa partitura pianistica.

This interpretation is ridiculously good, not only comparable to wordclass pianists such as Martha Agerich, but in my opinion, even better. I've never heard an interpretation of scarbo such as this one. Truly an astounding performance and pianist.

Best version ever heard !

A lot of notes and very little music.

Perfect 👏

Perfect! Very articulated! New worlds..🙏🏽👌🤍

best toccata interpretation on youtube by far

I feel like this is what Prokofiev wanted. You can feel the utterly psychotic nature of this piece in this performance. Yuja wang’s performance is amazing but I think this one has much more flavor.

👏🎹❤👏❤🌷👏🌷👏💖

So good. I was spellbound

Such fire. The Limoges Market movement took my breath away. In that realm, pure passion-wise, this might be my favorite performance that I've heard. In another realm, Ivo Pogorelich's studio recording . . . the second part of the Catacombs (With The Dead In A Dead Language) is a hair-raising meditative masterpiece. You can't even breathe.

So, THAT'S what the hands are doing.

3:33 outstanding ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Qué entendimiento…increible

Greatest performance of this Toccata is Horowitz, with Yuja Wang (encore) a ridiculously close second; Zhang about equal to Wang - a fabulous rendition as well. With time at a premium for most, listening to other interpretations could be considered superfluous (other than to satisfy curiosity). No disrespect whatsoever intended, but this isn't even in the same universe as those.

Great Interpretation and spirit of this wonderful work of Mussorgsky.