Jeremy Withers
Jeremy Withers
  • 1
  • 17 084
David Harvey: Limits to Growth, Limits to Gentrification
David Harvey explains why capitalism crashes if it can't find places to keep growing and growing. He explains how financiers' competitive search for profitable investment opportunities is changing the nature of urban development - spiking the cost of living within cities to unstable, unsustainable highs. The roots of the 2008 financial crisis are exposed and an alternative "right to the city" is championed.
zhlédnutí: 17 084

Video

Komentáře

  • @adambrock7692
    @adambrock7692 Před 2 lety

    Crazy their answer to people being so poor and struggling is more cuts . Wonder what's wrong with America

  • @designerama1099
    @designerama1099 Před 3 lety

    I like how she only ever opens her mouth before the edit cuts her off

  • @aethelyfel7573
    @aethelyfel7573 Před 4 lety

    czcams.com/video/w-UUW_Z7UD8/video.html. I stand for the working man, not for the Elite with No Skin in the Game: like a Typical Marxist Professors. The right must usurp these quacks from positions of Power.

  • @richardfinlayson1524
    @richardfinlayson1524 Před 4 lety

    that was a good point;it takes people most of their life to realize that the whole system is a scam.

  • @ravanabrahmarakshas4263

    there is ONLY one solution. violent revolution. KILL billionaires. establish communism by force of GUN. no negotiation woth capitalists. no reform. REVOLUTION. Moses Vegan-Religion.org

  • @nightoftheworld
    @nightoftheworld Před 5 lety

    29:28 "Capitalists love mega-projects, they hate to be bothered with neighborhood activities. So they like the mega-projects, building new stadiums, building new parts of the city. They love projects which have a high rate of return-which means building the kind of city that the rich people want to live in. _So capital actually builds high value housing for a limited market._ In fact a lot of what capital builds is not actually lived in."

  • @nightoftheworld
    @nightoftheworld Před 5 lety

    The juxtaposition of Canadian and American "perceptions of wealth" research was great.. excellent condensation

  • @philgwellington6036
    @philgwellington6036 Před 5 lety

    Who would've thought that a geographer and his message could be so sexy!

  • @jonathanlehman623
    @jonathanlehman623 Před 5 lety

    "That's for the banks to sort out" - Capitalism. smh.

  • @bellorusso
    @bellorusso Před 5 lety

    I'm cynical enough to think that people deserve what is coming to them. I called myself a leftist back in the 1980's when everybody loved capitalism and wanted to kill communists. I was heavily ridiculed and bullied for my views. Fast forward 30 years and it turns out I was right. People can't be reasoned with, they only understand a harsh reality.

    • @RYSEAmato
      @RYSEAmato Před 5 lety

      people can change, it just happens slowly and feels painfully slow once one sees solutions that most don't

  • @AussieSaintJohn
    @AussieSaintJohn Před 5 lety

    I just found this video but noticed that it was posted in Dec 2015 and found it very informative statistically but for the sake of credibility, I'd like to post an updated version of this, can anyone share a link to help me out?

  • @sail2byzantium
    @sail2byzantium Před 5 lety

    Good video and I very much like listening to David Harvey. But I would have preferred the video just be a straight Harvey presentation rather than the montage-y format here. that frequently broke away from Harvey himself.

  • @TheVFXbyArt
    @TheVFXbyArt Před 5 lety

    It makes it look like David Harvey keeps interrupting the young lady next to him. XD

  • @AlexthunderGnum
    @AlexthunderGnum Před 6 lety

    Starting from minute 36 the lady to the right of David makes funny attempts on the microphone. She is pretty persistent in her attempts even though in vain. She never said a word despite so many attempts to "bite" the microphone. I wonder what was that for?

    • @AussieSaintJohn
      @AussieSaintJohn Před 5 lety

      I think you'll find that it was heavily edited and very well done as well...

    • @bellorusso
      @bellorusso Před 5 lety

      She is a translator. The parts where she is speaking to the audience have been edited out.

  • @apope06
    @apope06 Před 6 lety

    THIS IS REQUIRED WATCHING!

  • @marcminoguehastings2939

    girl is Portuguese translator as lecture was in Fortaleza Brazil.

  • @jonathankammer9078
    @jonathankammer9078 Před 6 lety

    Bravo Jeremy! You’re weaving of these videos to drive home and illuminate the lesson is fantastically done! I’d like to know how to create pastiche videos myself. Do you pull from CZcams? Does one require permissions from primary sources?

  • @johnpauldebarro730
    @johnpauldebarro730 Před 6 lety

    EXCELLENT

  • @BooDamnHoo
    @BooDamnHoo Před 7 lety

    The idea behind capitalism, perpetual growth, is itself and insane and IMPOSSIBLE idea to bring into practice. Perpetual growth is impossible and even a sustained attempt to do so must inevitably lead to a crash. The entire basis of modern "capitalist" society must change to one of sustainability and, GASP, STEADY STATE. Seriously, WHY must a company always grow? If you have a good product and customers, and if you keep making enough money to keep a roof overhead and food in your stomach then THAT'S GOOD ENOUGH.

    • @reginaldmorton2162
      @reginaldmorton2162 Před 5 lety

      well said

    • @hollywoodartchick9740
      @hollywoodartchick9740 Před 5 lety

      The answer to that would be that the profit is of less interest to speculators than the value of the stocks and bonds (debt value). Speculators don't care about sustainability. They care about their cocaine habits. And they have a lot of influence over policy. They want to buy low in the morning and sell high a few hours later. That's also why student loan forgiveness in the US has not been forthcoming - the gamblers in the bond market don't want to be the last fool holding the hot potato just before we all admit that these things will NEVER get paid.

    • @noisepuppet
      @noisepuppet Před 5 lety

      Colonel Panic It's not so much that a given company has to grow. The owners might like it to, but companies shrink and grow and merge and acquire and spin off and downsize and go bust constantly. What's necessary in the capitalist mode of production is that the system as a whole must grow, and it must do so at a rate attractive to capital. That is, it must provide a pretty sure prospect of profit. Otherwise, the capitalist has no motive to put his money into production, and value stops moving through the system, which is to say that the economy slows or stops. Unfortunately, this includes traffic in the necessary means of life, things like food and pharmaceuticals. So under the current arrangement, the supply of life's necessities depends on an economic system that always grows. Growth in real terms means growth in production and consumption of real stuff-- commodities. A good proxy for all of that is energy consumption. A growing economy happens to be one in which energy consumption is expanding year on year. That's an important side note. Professor Harvey also uses concrete production in China as an example of the scope and scale of economic growth today. What capital finds to be a healthy rate of growth is neighborhood of 3% annually. This means the economy doubles in size roughly every 25 years. So when anyone talks about sustainable growth at profitable rates, all we have to do is look at the size of the global economy in 2020 and ask ourselves if it is physically possible to double it in size, that is, double its production and consumption of material goods, because that is the proposition-- double it by 2045. Suppose we're cornucopian optimists, and we say sure, let's double it. Now it's 2045, and we need to double it again by 2070, and again by 2095, and again by 2120. So in order to sustain capitalism, we'll require the global capitalist economy a century from now to be 16 times the size it is today. At some point, you run into physical limits. There's only so much coal to burn and concrete and steel to make, and so on. There's only so much pounding the environment will take before industry destroys the conditions necessary for its own existence. To understand exponential growth, you just calculate how long it takes the thing to double and start doing your powers of two, and at some point, anyone sane has to admit that the world is only so big. This is the simple math nobody will face. And that's because putting the traffic in basic life necessities on some basis other than profit motive, decoupling human survival from growth, means taking control of the necessary means of life away from the most powerful group of human beings that has ever existed. That's what it means when we say let's base the economy on something besides growth.

    • @noisepuppet
      @noisepuppet Před 5 lety

      Colonel Panic TLDR: it literally means taking private property away from the owners of it.

  • @nickweech3487
    @nickweech3487 Před 8 lety

    many parts of what we all see everyday in our own lives, can be explained by his comments. Have a look at globalpoliticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2016/04/15/how-capitalism-destroyed-the-family-model-and-gave-rise-to-loneliness-rage-militantism-and-prostitution/