Video

The bringing about all the fears was the extinction manifesting.

how about Robert Smirke? i think he deserves a smash just for giving us neat classifications

Okay but John is the best archivist? He ended the world! He fulfilled the purpose of the archivist position! No one else could have done it! Gertrude was a terrible archivist; she didn't even like taking statements!

Hi!!! I’m back after 6 months of firehosing TMA.

GOOD LORD IT'S THE ENTIRETY OF THE LEITNER RANT 😭😭😭

Big stretch here, what if the vampires are extinction monsters ? Just a thought since they could be there to inherent the earth and their ability to quickly burn like discarded paper. But definitely a massive stretch

Fitting to her nature as the Burnt on earth, Agnes Montague's life was an empty, meaningless tragedy that did nothing but squander it's own potential and irreparably harm everyone involved.

HERE'S HOW AGNES MONTAGUE CAN STILL WIN

While I STRONGLY dissagree with some of your takes (most specifically, that I deeply prefer the meta plot episodes to the statements), this is still a really good video. Thanks for making it.

My hot takes? Martin is most certainly not and UwU cinnamon roll. He’s a manipulative prick who puts on the softie act for show. (I still love him tho) Micheal didn’t have enough screen time. His death felt so sudden and so rushed. Jmart DID have adequate build up The guy that worked with Breekon and Hope was a plot hole that could’ve easily been solved by making him one of the anatomy class students In terms of association with knowledge, the eye may have an academic pedigree, but of the fears, it is the least knowledgeable. It just knows things, it doesn’t comprehend them or understand them. The eye and its avatars were easily lead along by the web, and it wasn’t because they didn’t know, it’s because they lacked the foresight to realize what was really happening. The web is the most knowledgeable entity. The slaughter has some of the best and most gripping episodes, and it’s the lonely that is the inferior fear Season five is a drudge to listen to every single time (I’ve listened to the podcast 4 times)

How do you recognize season 5 has so many banger episodes yet its not your favorite?

Yep, I am the one person that would have been disappointed to see more The Extinction, because it didn't exist and this is a hill I will die on. The Extinction was theorised by Dekker and exploited by Peter Lukas as a ploy to convince Martin to use the power of the Panopticon; the whole extinction motif is just a facet of The End, which is why it only got a single domain in the post-change world.

I would like to add that one of the reasons we may not see much out of the Extinction throughout the entire show, and especially the post-change world, is that it may not even be a distinct or emerging entity. One of the points of that storyline was gathering evidence for it even existing; if it is only a facet of The End, as some theorise, rather than an entity in and of itself, then it having only a single domain in the post-change world actually makes sense.

The video game *CHANGED* is a manifestation of The Extinction. Here me out. Adelard Dekker says The Extinction originally started as a part of The End, and in the world of Changed, humanity was [initially] plagued by an undetectable virus. After scientists realized that animals weren't affected, they tried to infuse animal DNA into themselves. This ended up creating a new *manmade* virus: The Latex Beasts. THE ENIRE POINT OF CHANGED IS YOU TRYING AGAINST ALL ODDS TO *KEEP YOUR HUMANITY* INTACT! If that isn't a manifestation of The Extinction idk what is. Also if you want me to go more in depth, I will gladly make a video about it. Just say the word and I will do it so no one else has to.

I know I'm late but it's always a pleasure to see you again. This was a surprise to be sure, but overall I think this is for the best I hope you don't stop making tma content or tmp but also hope to see new and fresh things. All said and done I'm glad to have accompanied you on this journey (even if a little late) and I can't wait to see what the future holds. Have a great day Mr ward or should I say The Final Fantasmagorie. (oh my God it sounds a lot more cooler now!)

9:22 That is what I like to call an Antimeme.

Ive returned well rested. now pt 3. The Crown Beholding does all it can to see all-not caring about commanding. Authority does all He can to command all-observing is but means to an end. The Buried exerts pressure without authority and The Crown with. The Corruption reduces all relationships into a squirming community of love and vermin. The Crown makes all thing into obedient slaves, their action an extension of His will. The Web is kinda seperate from The Crown cause the latter refused any and changes to His being, resulting in the birth of The Web; however because how much overlapping are their fears are, the two are also the same Power, The Director. Its the reason I called it an eldritch instance of Split Personality trope. I planned to post a MAG 200-esque story here about The Director and its halfs, but i didnt made it yet. So, any question or critisism regarding anything i posted, namely the reddit links from the last comment? speakin of reddit www.reddit.com/r/TheMagnusArchives/comments/1054b08/the_entities_remixed/ I have problem with The Childlike Wonder (i call it The Nostalgic), The Night and The Reflection. The former two cause i cant fidure out what fears they represent, and the latter cause of its name "Speculum". This is what i figured: Wonder - your past not being what you think it was, your past is holding something horrible, your past is being perverted, being stuck in the past. night - darkness, dreams reflect - who/what you are, were and will/can be, not knowing who/what you are, were and will/can be, being copied, being replaced by a copy all i guessed by names and allies, but speculum in particular is wierd cause it doesnt fit with the last set. what do you think? Also i made deducyions on the rrst of remixed fear if you wisheto read

Congrats on the rebrand, Ward. Personally I think it should be "The", cause, for me at least, it makes linguistic sense in a [name], [epithet] way. "Malachi Ward, the Final Fantasmagorie" rolls well in speech. And since im here, i might as well say something about my magnus things. First of all, small changes in my fanmade Dread Powers. - The Wild's "Name That Unfolds Like Lotus Blossom" is changed to All Things Past Are Comning Back to make more spooky, and includes fears of the untamed, the uncivilized, and of the modern world being no diffrent than the wilderness outside of it, and potentionally of uncharted territory - The Crown's epithet is "the Father of Slaves" to compliment The Web's "the Mother of Puppets" - The Control is now The Director - Ive divided The Desolation to give it distinction from The Deprived; the former is now the fear of losing you love/desire/are attached to, and the latter is the fear of lacking one's needs and nessecities, be they actual or percieved. - The Repeat is now The Cyclic. - The Fallen is just as "mind-having" as The Web, but "Evil Can Not Comprehend Good" is in full effect, and its "direct" plans happen to fail a lot, but it cant understand how it fails due to its narcisism. Now, in The Extinction and End vidoes i explained my decisions regarding my fanmade Power. I kinda find it lacking now, so i will try explaining it a diffrent way, namely "compare and contrast". The Fallen: - When Beholding targets your flaws and wrongdoings, it judges you for them, and exposes them for all to see. When Tartarus does it, it makes you obsesed with them, making you fear becoming something monstrous and inhumane in a worst possible ways. - The Slaughter fouceses on the violence, both inside and outside of war, and the aftermath of it. The Fallen focuses those who commit it. TBC in comments

Also, I’m reaaaaally glad I’m not the only one e that feels that vampires feel so out of pocket even when they are so freaky just the fact that they are called vampires takes me out

It’s super interesting to me how different things makes us scared and changes the rating, I don’t like the statements that are set too far in the past, that makes them less scary to me, I love the statements about technology like the guy who uploaded himself into a computer and the one that kept a scary website, there are two episodes I will never listen again, killing floor and cruelty free, I just can’t, and since I really don’t care about the overarching plot season 5 was a complete drag to go though

I definately think "A Final Fantasmagorie" sounds better, but "The Final Fantasmagorie" looks better to read.

Congratulations, man! The rebrand is looking stellar.

out of respect , i will not make another fnaf joke .

Eyyyyy thanks for the mention, bro! Truly looking forward to how the changes come about! You’re already doing wonders just from what you shared!

Looking forward to what you get up to with the new look, though that title gave me a shock when I saw the notification, glad you ain't leaving yet (Also I think you might have the wrong link in the description, I think it links to this video instead of the other one which I will have to watch later)

One could say you escaped the springs of your old name trapping you (This joke is really unfunny but I really wanted to make a fnaf joke)

By changing and reshaping our identities, we try to find ourselves. This happens everyday. I wish you good luck. I always liked your Magnus content and looking forward to what will come up next.👍

I can't wait to see what you come up with in your new journey, buddy 💙💙

Interesting

RE Vampires: I get your confusion, I also thought they they were at least somewhat connected to the Web, BUT we know for sure they are associated with the Hunt. They exemplify the patient and manipulative hunter, they literally hunt for humans in cities, and they also appeared in the Everchase. And yes, the Hunt also hunts itself: that is actually very well established at least several times. I do get tho that vampires are generally overdone in much of fiction. However, you can't tell me that a mostly humanoid creature with a proboscus is not an original concept for a vampire. I think vampires and werewolves both being part of the Hunt makes perfect sense ❤

You could add snakes shedding their skin as a symbol of death and rebirth to the thing with the Extinction and snakes also.

Something that I’ve noticed is that the person that can always see through the Not!Them’s illusion is always someone who either doesn’t know the victim very well or has a neutral/not good relationship with them. Melanie, who didn’t know Sasha very well, was the only person who could see through it. In the case of Graham Folger, Amy Patel was notably kind of off-put by him and the person whose mother got replaced had a rather rocky relationship with their mother. The person whose cousin got replaced had kind of a neutral relationship and didn’t seem to particularly like them. I think it will always be someone who knows the person but maybe isn’t on the best terms with them. Idk if this means anything or if it’s just a small detail but it’s something I’ve noticed.

My favorite Jon/Martin alternate ship name is Teaholding

Opinions on Needles and Ink50Ul?

Coward/j /silly

Hi, I'm back here a second time because after many months, brain decides to think about ethics town again. Great video, ethics town deserves a bigger fandom

There should be another entity: the Hurt. This entity creates fear by finding ways to hurt people then using that pain or even the anticipation of that pain to generate fear. For example look at the Needle Man in the Magnus Protocol. He hugs a person, maiming them horribly, then uses the fear they feel of continued pain and damage to terrorize them.

Okay, it's been 3 months, but still a massive spolier, so you've been warned. It's not Jon, Martin, and Jonah. It's Jon, Martin, and Jurgen.

Oliver and Jon are very parrallel to each other imo. They both go through major discoveries about their power and their abilities abd make relatively profound realisatikns about the workd. The both try to get away/go under a lot of paranoia over what they can see beyond their normal eye sight. Finally, when the change occurs, their names are replaced by titles, the coroner in oliver's case, and the archivist in John's case. They also like each other reasonably and have a gentleman's deal to not kill each other as it doesn't really matter

The newest tma episode has snakes!!!

I feel like Thrown Away's theming around garbage adds a physicality in connection with the corruption that I find curiously understated. After all, when you mass produce, there will inevitably be waste. What is it about a tooth that is different from a doll head or a sheet of paper, aside from coming from a living being? Are our body parts really any different from inanimate objects once removed from our body? It is the peak of objectification to be disposable.

Listening to this after the newer episodes of TMP I love this theory.

Mr. Bonzo's here to play! Mr. Bonzo's here to stay!

hop off episode 10

did Slaughter haters just not watch The Piper

"Take her not me, take her not me..." lost johns cave literally gave me nightmares

hot take: mag 5 is the best episode out of the first 10

Since the first time hearing it I have loved Ex Altiora its the closest thing I can think of to that compulsion to fine more and more. found this video while looking for reference art cheers for great content

ive always thought of the hunt and the slaughter being more similar than the slaughter and the desolation. a part of the hunt is the fear of being hunted and eventually killed by someone or something, a part of the slaughter is about you being killed, not just hunted, while the desolation is about someone else dying in a violent way and also loss. one other thing, Jmart caught me off guard too. it felt like the relationship developed way too fast and it almost felt a little forced, dont get me wrong, I love them together, but It felt like it was a last minute idea that was catering towards the part of the fandom that shipped them.

When i went back to rewatch everything, I was so pleased to make all the connections i had missed the first time around because i didn't believe names or side characters mattered lol