Video

Perahia is much less poetic than this student naturally is, hence it's a big loss of time for this student.

SPLENDID

I love the flying staccatos on the upbow followed by staccatos (up-down-up-down) used in the Mozart, 1st mvt. It really adds so much clarity and character

נפלא. באך במיטבו. צ'לו במיטבו.

Good Video!... Will do Wonderfully!🪔... Many Thanks!... 🎁

Well done🎶

2:18 super fail that note out of a pitch 😂

0:26 Scene (Acte II) 3:34 Hungarian Dance (Acte III) 8:57 Scene (Acte IV) 13:49 Waltz (Acte I)

The thing with this master classes, in general, is that they focus too much on the performance as the master would do it. Which, I’m sure many would find great value in that, but to me it’s not that interesting. I think the classes should focus more on correcting the student on technique, where they struggle, clear difficulties and such. As it’s obvious this student has quite a few technical flaws that need to be addressed. It’s easier to find your own voice in music when you have mastered those difficulties. The thing with teaching interpretation at such meticulous level is that it is too difficult and frankly unnecessary, because in the end, no one can play the same, nor should play the same. Argerich, Horowitz, Richter, Gould, Rubinstein, etc. They all play Appasionata sonata and each version is very different, different accents, different rubato, different dynamics. Etc. But what do all of them have in common? Superb technique, they can nail the piece beginning to end with little error and with their own mark of musicality. In, in the end a pianist who is well develop technically will find room to find their own emotion in music. Otherwise, playing with tension, bad posture, unnecessary movements will just hinder the ability to connect with the sounds and thus create a moving performance. Just my 2 cents.

beautiful interpretation

too young to master this piece

This master class is not just a great class for the pianists, but for all the listeners here. It's a class about how to interpret music, where each segment is important, not just the whole piece.

מצוין. 20 דקות של הנגינה עברו תוך שניה.

Psalm 45:8b, lovely and well-done!

I love this song!😄

I am sure of very little in life -- but that is not a violin.

Why is he eating his finger at 21:14!?!?

The student was very receptive to Murray Perahia, I believe he was quite spot on with his comments actually.

Great performance by incredibly talented musicians and amazing conductor Evgeny. Perfect dynamics and amazing timbres of soloists. Bravo!!!

自分の主張を押し付ける指揮者ではないね。鳴ってるの聞きながら、うん・いいね・思った通り鳴ってると共感してる気がする。オケとの共感が素晴らしい。松本さんに向けた笑顔も優しくとってもいいね。

The player is absolutely outstanding although it's quite challenging to have the emotional depth at this age for that kind of piece. Excellent class, great upload, many thanks.

Bravo, Ilan!

Is this on occupied land?

Perahia is correct in putting this piece in historial Polish context.

Enjoyed this. Great ensemble playing! Are these two girls siblibgs?

Totally out of style 😂😂😂😂😂

какая интенсивность звука у Д. Б.!

игру Д Б. всегда отличает Это "Чуть .. чуть " во всех деталях поет рояль под ее пальцами

Д. Б коснулась клавиш и рояль запел

יוצא מין הכלל!!! מצויין!!!

This boy is a good pianist. Good sense of drive, very individual interpretation and some artistic intuition. Hoping the best for him

I saw them last night in Madrid, they were stunning!

What a wonderful orchestra. The young people ought to be very proud of themselves.

Excellent masterclass with Sebok.

😍very beautiful

Wow, a spectacular masterclass! "A murder has happened" - who else had their hair standing on end by then and right to the end? Terrific student and peerless teacher.

Подумал, что надо бы, в чистую субботу, послушать Горностаеву, экспромт Шуберта 90-1. Не слушал года 2 классику вообще (поэтому в рекомендациях ресурс никак не мог его мне подсунуть). Захожу - а он мне подсовывает ровно то (ПОЧТИ то!), о чем я только что подумал. Ютуб научился читать мысли?

Some great artists are not as great as teachers. Obviously, Perahia has many a wonderful things to say, but he's too intrusive, i.e. he talks too much ;-)

美しい演奏でした❤

Listening to Chopin's scherzo is like watching evening news, full of all the troubles in the world and all the great things happening all around. They didn't have TVs back then, so the scherzos can fill those roles.

I would be so stressed with someone standing over me like that with an audience watching, feeling constantly punished

my cat is meowing and pawing at the screen, she loves it so much, lol

Великолепно! Моё особенное восхищение Кириллу за его соло во второй части. А вообще ребята гениальные. Спасибо.

How Wonderful / Wie wunderbar

FREE PALESTINE ❤❤

What a marvelous young talent!

Peculiar to see M.P. fixated on looking at the score.....😢

אשלן דיברת וניגנת מקסים ומרגש! שמחה מאוד שאת מנגנת את יצירותיה של דודתי - יוסימה פלדשוה. תודה ובהצלחה לך!