Video

When you don’t change things…things don’t change.

for me, 1-2 trades may work but not enough to make a great team ...work on your farm system. judge is from the farm system so is rice so is volpe.

DJ LeMahieu wanted to play four more seasons, but Cashman insisted on six seasons. 2024 is his fourth season after signing his contract extension. DJ will have been paid 4 x $15 M = $60 M with $30 M still owed to him. DJ had wanted 4 x $25 M = $100 M so initially, Cashman saved $10 M. If DJ is unable to play effectively ever again, DFA him just like the Astros did with Jose Abreu with some $33 M still owed to him. Aaron Hicks was also DFAed with $33 M owed to him.

Same stuff as 2022, 2023, Pitching, Hitting have failed the Yankees, miserably ! Especially the Poor Performance Pitching ! Geez !!

FROM THE BEGINNING BOONE SHOWN THAT HE KNOWS NOTHING ABOUT STRATEGIES, IN ADDITION HE WAS MEDIOCRE AS A PLAYER, ONLY BECAUSE OF HIS MEDIOCRE HOME RUN, HIS ONLY MERIT IS THAT HE LICKS CASH'S BOOTS VERY WELL, BECAUSE THERE IS TALENT ON THE TEAM, BUT HE DOES KNOW THEY HAVE TO GET RID OF TORRES' OVERWEIGHT, LEMAHIEU'S MEDIOCRE PERFORMANCE, RIZZO'S OLD AGE, AND THE WORST CLOSER, HOLMES

It’s funny, pro baseball players can’t hit the righty/lefty.

We need a new manager 1:16 George where are you?

Nail on the effing head. The Orioles are stacked with their elite talent, it is time to start matching up.

The Yankees excuses of injury's would piss me off if i was a Yankee fan.. first off every team has injury's you have to develop depth in your system instead of paying two or three guys that end up hurt with ridiculous contracts.. look at Baltimore and take notes you don't have to spend the most money draft well and develop a farm system look for rule 5 guys and under the radar talent.. cashman and boone are the worst GM manager duo in the league

Lemeauh,torres,rizzo,verdugo; were watching last year all over again. Don't trade for more retreads.bring up some young players like they did rice.

So because the Yankees aren’t killing everyone the lineup is non competitive. Right.

YANKEES ARE SO DUMB THEY DONT LIKE CALLING UP YOUNG PROSPECTS IM SURPRISED THEY CALLED UP DOMINGUEZ

The Yankees better do something because the Orioles are getting mighty uppity in their attitude the last two years.

sinking ship

Jahmai Jones isn't that bad he has had some good games with the glove and bat but yeah i get it we do need a spark when G went down we are getting nothing from DH.

Injuries are an excuse to save Brian Cashman. The team stinks.

Not a single productive bat off the bench this entire season, when everyone was healthy, now that Stanton and Rizzo are on the IL, the lineup has only 3 professional hitters on the team, so why would you pitch to team. The Yankees have been trying to make Vertigo into something he is not, He has never been a productive RBI man, he is a 40 RBI per season guy, and having him bat 4th or 5th in the lineup is ridiculous.

Along with Jones bring up Ramirez. Other teams bring up prospects but Yanks seem to run with unreliable major league retreads ie JD Davis.

The NYY don't have a possitive functionality, or conrade, as a unit. And for M. Key's point, Spencer Jones is not gonna safe the team insanity. They must figure out which key players they need, on a trade, to stop the bleeding. Here is what they need: SP, a closer, 2-bats (help generate run after Judge&Soto), and a catcher. Also, Cortes and Rodon must go; TRADE THEM, for god sake!!!

Jeter was surrounded by guys like Posada, Bernie, Tino, O'Neil Brosius. The bench players on those teams were guys like Wade Boggs, Charlie Hayes, and Darrell Strawberry. Judge has been surrounded by guys like Joey Gallo, Luke Voigt, Glyber Torres, Gary Sanchez, Clint Frazier, The bench players are guys nobody has ever heard of. It took the Yankees 8 years into Judges career before they finally got another great player to pair with him.

If it’s who’s greater or higher all time it’s definitely Jeter rn. If it’s just who’s the better player then it’s obviously Judge.

“Just past a diving Jeter!” 😂

Jeter has the better career and it isn't up for legit debate. But then again, Judge has him on pure talent on a baseball field, and that isn't up for legit debate either. Judge is the most talented lifetime Yankee position player since Mantle. And I'm speaking solely of talent, nothing else. Jeter was a talented ballplayer, but he was never considered the best player, or even shortstop in the league. There were always guys who hit better. That's not true with Judge. He literally has no peers right now when it comes to hitting. He's just on a different level from everyone else. Now if the question is best Yankee, no debate, it is Jeter. He's a top 7 Yankee all time at worst. Only ones I definitively put over him are Ruth, Gehrig, DiMaggio and Mantle, with Berra at number 5 for me.

BOTH. Two role models. Let’s see how judge does with the rest of his career. Kinda dumb question.

jeter or judge!!!! not even close!!!!! Judge by a mile

Also to answer Don's question - Jeter's 162 game average for WAR was 4.2 - Judge's is 8.4. Obviously this is including Jeter's later years which Judge hasn't had yet. Jeter's best WAR season was 8.0 - Judge's so far was 10.5, with a chance to have an even higher one this year as he is already at 6.0 on July 1st. In my opinion Judge is a much better player than Jeter, but at the very least one has to acknowledge that it is at least close.

I was born in very early 1994 - by the time I was aware of baseball and the Yankees, the Yankees dynasty of the late 90's was underway as were the hall of fame careers of Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera, as well as A-Rod and other key Yankees of the past 30 years. I missed Mattingly almost entirely and I obviously never saw Reggie, Mantle, or any other all timers like that play. That being said, Aaron Judge is easily the best Yankees player I have ever seen in my lifetime (talking about pure baseball ability, rings and opportunities aside). I absolutely adore Derek Jeter, he is my hero. But Judge is a better fielder, as good of a hitter, and by far without any comparison more powerful. He will certainly eclipse Jeter's home run and RBI totals by the time his career is over, whether he plays nearly as many games as Jeter did or not. He has hit 62 home runs in a single season and is on track for his 3rd 50 home run season. We are talking more home runs in a season than Babe Ruth, Gehrig, Dimaggio, Mantle, Maris, Jackson, or A-Rod ever hit. He is as good as some of the all-time great players in terms of baseball ability. The only question marks, as said in the video, are the postseason successes and longevity. If Judge wins a ring or more he will certainly join the conversation of all-time greatest Yankees. However, even if his career were to end right now I would still consider him the best baseball player the Yankees have had since I was born.

Judge is more of a comp to arod not jeter lets be honest. Were talking about top tier hitters here

Jeter is more clutch so jeter overall. Judge had to prove himself in the playoffs

Judge needs to win a WS before this conversation is even relevant .... Judge is my favorite yankee ever and I'm in a long line to be sure.... he is physically and emotionally elite.... Jeter and Judge are complimentary players ~ they would have been great on the same team.... If the Yanks get Soto Judge's last 7 years in stripes could be his best numbers wise....and of course he has stay on the field. Judge's offensive impact is far more robust than Derek's but character wise they are twins from different parents...

Judge will not hit 3,000 hits, will not win Gold Glove, will not have a 300 career average...nuff said

Derek jeter is better than judge

You numbers people don’t understand baseball

Jeter had crazy longevity Peak for peak it’s Judge.

More talented is judge. 6’9 280 can hit for power contact can play a high level defense in right and a leauge average center field which is good. He is also a lot faster than most people think. Talent doesn’t equate to greatness jeter is greater right now. But if judge wins 1-2 more mvps and a ring or two I can say he’ll be greater he’ll have less hits but probably double the hrs and RBIs

#'s matter more in October

Mk gotta stop using gold gloves as a metric to say if a player is good defensively or not. Im a Cubs fan and i watched Ian Happ literally be one of thee worst LFs in the league last Yr and he won a GG. Dude ranked in the 7th percentile in OAA finishing the Yr with a -7. If those metrics were available to the public back then Baseball fans would've caught on alot quicker to Jeter being a terrible SS especially in his 30's. I mean you already here a ton of people bring it up today

Judge can carry a team offensively, that is something Jeter could never do, but Judge has major flaws in his swing and plate coverage, both of which are readily exposed and taken advantage of by quality pitchers in the post-season. Jeter put the bat on ball, was more of a contact hitter than is Judge, so if there is a close game, Yankees down one run, with a man is scoring position, I would prefer Jeter over Judge to come to the plate in that situation every day. Judge is on pace to hit close to 60 HR, have 130+ rbi's, and strike-out 185-200 times this season. The majority of Judges rbi's come via the home-run, wherein Jeter's while not an big RBI man, produced his with singles and doubles,

Jeter is the most iconic player of my lifetime. He’s the man. No one comes close

Jeter wasn’t even the best offensive shortstop as A Rod and Nomar was always loved more. Jeter post season was out of this world. Too many clutch and iconic moment.

Haven't watched Judge hit in the playoffs huh Don. He's atrocious in the playoffs.

As a winner Jeter but as a player Judge easily.

Massive L for Rosenberg. It was everywhere

The Yankees fucking suck

Go get Trevor Bauer!

As a Red Sox fan, Verdugo is giving the Yankees exactly what they signed. He's an average player overall, in fact he is playing below average at the moment. He's OK in the field, but he has never lived up to expectations at the plate. He's been steadily declining for the past 4 years and the Red Sox saw this. He is a better option than what the Yankees had last year, but to have a .704 OPS when half your games are played at a park taylor made for lefties, is underachieving.

Yankees are done. No recovery is possible as long as all you got is 3 out of 9 hitting and lousy pitching

Cashman has to go every year it's the same 💩

michael really making a big deal out of this, its like the first time hes seen an internet meme