- 8
- 92 753
Vanya Bisht
Registrace 9. 10. 2011
Scientist by training, educator by passion.
To support my work, you can buy me a coffee here: ko-fi.com/vanyabisht
To support my work, you can buy me a coffee here: ko-fi.com/vanyabisht
What is Co-Production of Knowledge? How to Practice Community Engagement in Sustainability Science?
This video explains the concept of co-production, which is used in the Sustainability Sciences to describe a research process where scientists actively and explicitly engage with the community in every step of the research process. I explain why in order to address the complex problems of our society, science cannot operate in isolation of the society, and instead, I show how we can use the co-production framework to engage with the communities we seek to 'help' with our scientific research.
0:00 [Intro]
1:56 [Why we need Co-production]
4:16 [What is Co-production]
4:57 [How to practice Co-production]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This video is inspired by numerous publications in the field of Sustainability Sciences that explain the concept of co-production. I have shared a few here:
1. Norström, A. V., Cvitanovic, C., Löf, M. F., West, S., Wyborn, C., Balvanera, P., ... & Österblom, H. (2020). Principles for knowledge co-production in sustainability research. Nature Sustainability, 3(3), 182-190.
Link: sustainabilitycommunity.springernature.com/posts/58093-principles-for-knowledge-co-production-in-sustainability-research
2. Chambers, J. M., Wyborn, C., Ryan, M. E., Reid, R. S., Riechers, M., Serban, A., ... & Pickering, T. (2021). Six modes of co-production for sustainability. Nature sustainability, 1-14.
Link: www.nature.com/articles/s41893-021-00755-x
3. Wyborn, C., Datta, A., Montana, J., Ryan, M., Leith, P., Chaffin, B., ... & Van Kerkhoff, L. (2019). Co-producing sustainability: reordering the governance of science, policy, and practice. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 44, 319-346.
Link: www.annualreviews.org/doi/full/10.1146/annurev-environ-101718-033103
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you like my videos, please subscribe to my channel: czcams.com/channels/21E.html...
To learn more about my research and academic life, please follow me on Twitter: Vanya_Bisht
0:00 [Intro]
1:56 [Why we need Co-production]
4:16 [What is Co-production]
4:57 [How to practice Co-production]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This video is inspired by numerous publications in the field of Sustainability Sciences that explain the concept of co-production. I have shared a few here:
1. Norström, A. V., Cvitanovic, C., Löf, M. F., West, S., Wyborn, C., Balvanera, P., ... & Österblom, H. (2020). Principles for knowledge co-production in sustainability research. Nature Sustainability, 3(3), 182-190.
Link: sustainabilitycommunity.springernature.com/posts/58093-principles-for-knowledge-co-production-in-sustainability-research
2. Chambers, J. M., Wyborn, C., Ryan, M. E., Reid, R. S., Riechers, M., Serban, A., ... & Pickering, T. (2021). Six modes of co-production for sustainability. Nature sustainability, 1-14.
Link: www.nature.com/articles/s41893-021-00755-x
3. Wyborn, C., Datta, A., Montana, J., Ryan, M., Leith, P., Chaffin, B., ... & Van Kerkhoff, L. (2019). Co-producing sustainability: reordering the governance of science, policy, and practice. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 44, 319-346.
Link: www.annualreviews.org/doi/full/10.1146/annurev-environ-101718-033103
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you like my videos, please subscribe to my channel: czcams.com/channels/21E.html...
To learn more about my research and academic life, please follow me on Twitter: Vanya_Bisht
zhlédnutí: 2 840
Video
What is Post-Normal Science? Science Policy Approach for Complex Uncertain & Wicked Policy Problems.
zhlédnutí 5KPřed 3 lety
This video explains the concept of Post-Normal Science, which was developed by Funtowicz and Ravetz in 1993 to approach science policy when dealing with problems when are facts are uncertain, values are in dispute, stakes are high, and decisions urgent. Policymaking often happens in contexts where decisions are needed to be made urgently, and there are several parties that have a stake in the s...
4. Theory of Access Explained: Understanding Equity Justice & Power in Environmental Policy
zhlédnutí 2,8KPřed 3 lety
This video explains 5 social mechanisms that influence our ability to access and benefit from environmental resources. Being aware of these mechanisms of access can help us understand the ways in which differences in relative power and privilege create inequities in how we interact with our environment and derive its benefits. This is a seminal publication in the field of Political Ecology and ...
![3. Uncertainty in Decision Making [Known-Unknown Matrix]: Risk, Information & Trust in Public Policy](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/W4KN_wa-AWY/mqdefault.jpg)
3. Uncertainty in Decision Making [Known-Unknown Matrix]: Risk, Information & Trust in Public Policy
zhlédnutí 3,5KPřed 3 lety
Decision making for environmental problems requires tackling with uncertainty - situations that we had not or could not foresee beforehand or uncertainties that arise because of the inherent complexities of our system. This video describes the sources of uncertainties in our system and some of the ways in which we can identify and address them. I use the known-unknown matrix to describe how we ...
2. Elinor Ostrom's Design Principles Explained: Bottom-Up Strategies for Environmental Governance
zhlédnutí 22KPřed 3 lety
How have some communities been able to successfully govern their environmental resources for centuries? This question was first examined by the political economist, Elinor Ostrom. This video describes the eight Design Principles that she found were common practices among communities that had been successful in governing their commons. This is the second video in the series 'Why Are Environmenta...
1. Free-Rider Problem Explained: Prisoner's Dilemma, Collective Action, and Governing the Commons
zhlédnutí 17KPřed 3 lety
This video describes the Free-Rider Problem, explaining that environmental resources are common-pool resources (the commons) which makes them prone to the Tragedy of the Commons. I use concepts from Economics (the Prisoner's Dilemma Game) and Political Science (Theory of Collective Action and the Design Principles of Elinor Ostrom) to explain how we can avoid the Tragedy by encouraging people t...
Elinor Ostrom and the Theory of Governing the Commons Explained
zhlédnutí 40KPřed 5 lety
How can we solve the Tragedy of the Commons? Elinor Ostrom has an answer! This is an educational video about the commons scholarship pioneered by Elinor Ostrom, which provided a challenging alternative to Hardin's theory of the Tragedy of the Commons. "Commons" is a term used in resource economics to describe types of goods that can be accessed by anyone but their use by one party limits their ...
Can Memes Help Reduce Plastic Consumption?
zhlédnutí 195Před 5 lety
This video was created for a class project on 'Sustainable Development in Action' at the Arizona State University (ASU). The purpose was to come up with practical ideas that can be used to reduce single use plastic consumption in college campuses. It was found that most students prefer to buy single use plastic bottles because they simply because that is the most convenient thing to do. Therefo...
The "Prisoner's dilemma" is mental masturbation. Because only a fool would testify against their partner, as they testified against you, and willingly take a 10 years prison sentence... when the partner's very testimony against you can be redirected as lying to get out of jail... proven by the deal to testify against you.
wowwwwwwww
Thank you for vulgarizating it so well, right on point
This is a great synthesis for the course I teach. I will use it in my next class!
Thank you for this video! 🎉
❤ Nice Explanation
Well explained Vanya.
I really enjoyed this video. Can I get the citication of the contents?
Hello! Great video!! and I subscribed as well!😊 I have a question, you mentioned that privatization is not the only answer based on ostrom, why is this? What were the effects of privatization for ostrom that didnt led to the success of the commons? Thank you..
Otimo video... ajudou mto na pesquisa que estou fazendo aqui... 🤙😁
Obrigado! :)
Hi.. do you have any research article related to the Ostrom’s book Governing the Commons?
Hi, you can check out this paper that discusses the challenges for governing commons: www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/science.1091015?casa_token=qLteUIeoBdAAAAAA%3AIIQ6t5HLeQrDfGHTZZOrBnBcQvBff9cNjyk28n6srs6Zbu4PzRC_nSXmosPpmJXed9NmWYdEbngxMQ And this one for understanding the application of Ostrom's design principles in a real world context: agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/92WR02991?casa_token=NXVdQde2iWMAAAAA:xJbdXSZXLUZIBz-TYSnfKdhvgxXuO0kae2r1HMBg3ob9-x4gnXTTHKyBMp7paLQG8CrjR_rDz8SUcg The first one is open-access. Let me know if you need a pdf of the second one..and I will email it to you.
This such a good video! Love how the topics were organized!
Thank you!
thank you for describing it so clearly .
Imagine thinking human activity could make any meaningful impact against the forces of nature in the grand scheme of things. Sheer fucking hubris.
very helpful 😊
Thank you Vanya you explained this beautifully !!! I would love to know how you made the video!
Thank you for the appreciation Archana, I make these videos myself using the website Powtoons
Thank you for the video! Very helpful.
Amazing series!
Thank you :)
This is surprisingly high quality material. thank you
Thank you for the appreciation
Thanks a lot! I study whole system approach to sustainable design, and work on a book about system change for child care. Ostrom is a main inspiration, and you have nailed her message in your presentation.
Thank you! Applying systems approach to child care sounds interesting! I'm glad you found this video helpful :)
So creative and you presented this complex topic in the simplest manner.👏👏
Thank you for the appreciation Reeti :)
Good content on science policy, I am also a science policy scholar at the centre for studies in science policy, JNU. I would love to collaborate with you, let me know about your interests.
"Among a long list of white dudes" 😂 Great video!
Россия с природными ресурсами никогда не входила в сообщество с "международным правительством", какого ¡@! мировое сообщество ("коллективный запад") вводит санкции в отношении РФ?
Это правда. В любой системе управления те немногие, у кого есть "власть", определяют, как живут остальные в системе. У тех, у кого нет власти, нет другого выбора, кроме как сопротивляться и в конечном итоге демонтировать силовые структуры или несправедливое навязывание.
Very informative..... Thank you❤
Thank you so much!
Thank u so much 🥰💕💕💕
Blessed to have encountered this lecture.
Finally I understand this ! Thank you!!
Yay 😁😁
What Ostrom said , Gandhi said a century ago.. The GRAM SWARAJ , now when I look back The man was so ahead of his time.. he single handed gave solutions to most of problems today we have..
Ostrom wrote complicated book, not verbally said only. Gandhi cannot write. He is third rate scholar
Gandhi was a creep, and this idea is very old. It does old as human life and older. No one said it was olstrom's original idea. It's just that she fleshed it out and wrote a book about it.
Good info, but how can this be cited for academic work? Who is the author and when was this video published?
Thank you Robert for considering to cite this video. I am the author (script writer, animator, voice) of this video (Vanya Bisht). The video was published on February 5, 2021.
Thanks Vanya. Do you mind including your qualification and occupation? I am a uK based PhD researcher and would like to use some of your resources. Thanks.
@@robertegwea5224 Thanks Robert. You can find my bio in the 'About' page of my channel. I am a PhD candidate at Arizona State University in the US in the field of Human and Social Dimensions of Science and Technology.
why the animation of poor ppl was black when rich ppl were white ?? 0.0 nice explaination tho but lil racist
That's a good observation. Implicit biases of the creator do shape the creation. Thanks for pointing that out. I will be careful in future
Shouldn't it be 0,20 and 20,0 (rather than 5,20 and 20,5) else they have no incentive to testify
The actual numerical value doesn't matter (for a qualitative analysis as presented in this video), the important thing is that the incentives to testify are kept lower than the incentive to stay silent.
@@VanyaBisht Manu is right. The numerical value doesnt matter but the relation does. In the prisioners dilemma its always better to defect no matter what the other player does. This is not the case with your numbers. If in your example the other one cooperates it is equaly good for you to cooperate as it is to defect. Thats a way of looking at the situation but its definetly not a prisioners dilemma. Look it up: in prisioners dillema defecting is a dominant strategy, meaning that its ALWAYS strictly better to defect - no matter what the other one does. Doesnt mean that your modelling is not also a good way of looking at situatons where no coordination is possible but its not a prisioners dillema. Im an economics Student with specialisation in game theory so maybe you should research that again. Otherwise its a good Video! :) Edit: May be a bit nit-picking but also your example with the fishing pond where you write: "most powerful wins" in the defect/defect cell is not a prisioners dilemma if that means that the most powerful is better of than she would be in the cooperate/cooperate case. That is because in prisioners dilemma both are worse of in the defect/defect situation than in coop/coop. Technically spoken defect/defect is not pareto efficient but the only nash equilibrium. But again thats also an interesting modelling approach for such a Situation!
Thanks for the detailed explanation!
@@VanyaBisht you're welcome! Actually I think that your modiefied prisioners dilemma is very interesting so thank you for that :) Yours is more about trust and about what each Player thinks the other one could do. You only defect because of fear that the other one could possibly defect, but initially there is no clear reason why the other one would defect except from fear that you could defect and so on... So you don't trust just because you're not sure if the other one trusts you. Thats a weird Situation...
Hey Vanya! Thanks for creating all of these videos! You explain each subject so well and gave such a great introduction to Elinor Ostrom - I think this is the start to a deep fascination with her work!
Thanks for the appreciation James!
This was really helpful for my proposal. The breakdown was simple. Kudos👍
Thank you George :)
Thank you for the tiime to do this, it is really enjoyable.
wow this video is really well-made. good job
lol i felt that bit of hate at the start of the vid.
Post-Normal Science, thanks, I learn a new term today.
Thx for this very clear explaination!!! Well done!!!
Thank you :)
I will quote you in my PhD!!!!
Beautiful video. Thank you so much. I'm making a video biography abou Lin Ostrom and this is great to understand why she won the Nobel Prize!! U have Instagram? I would love to follow u there
Thank you so much! You have a wonderful CZcams channel yourself. All the best to you :)
This actually helped me a lot. Thank you so much for making this video!
I am glad it helped!
Hi Vinya, this is a great video, thanks for making it!
Thanks Jaiyam :)
Great video!!! Hours of reading economic articles and nothing. 10 minutes video and now everything is clear. Thank you
Thank you so much Sophie :)
Fantastic visuals, informative and efficient! A true economist you are Miss Bisht!
Thank you Spike!
Thank Vanya! Excellent
Excellent video. Developmental science has too often adopted a top down approach. This video helps to explain how science can be made more egalitarian and relevant to society.
Very true!
Congratulations Vanya! You have taken up an important issue for our society and explained it in a very lucid and intelligent manner. Good job. Keep it up.
Thank you for the appreciation :)
Great, this is the main problem of research and policy decisions. No one bothers to assess the actual needs and problems of society whether poor or middle class people. The main objective is to get academic or political gains from tax payer's money.
What an insightful video! Both academics and industry experts can take a cue from this to make much more meaningful societal impact! :)
The concept of co-design is already quite popular and gaining ground in the tech industry with the emphasis on needs based, customer centric tech design.
😍Your videos are always the best. Looking forward to the next one!
Thank you so much! The next one is coming really soon :)