Video

Thank you Taimur Sir.

This really is not the first time a "former" trotskyist has proven they do not have a firm grasp of trotskysim. I will say this, folks please just read Trotsky for yourself. You will see it is merely basic Leninism. Trotsky's only fundamental addition to pre-1917 Lenin is The Theory of Permanent Revolution. I am not going to address everything I have a disagreement. I will only point out that your assertion about Trotsky's views of the peasantry and workers are fundamentally wrong. You are actually misunderstanding the theory of Permanent revolution and Lenin's original disagreement with the Mensheviks. The theory of Permanent revolution asserts that in backwards colonial nations, only the proletariat can lead a bourgeois democratic revolution through an alliance of the peasantry because the bourgeoisie are tied to international capitalism and the aristocracy and thus have arrived too late to play an independent and thus revolutionary role. This revolution will then transform into a socialist or proletarian one and spill over into advanced capitalist nations (thus making it permanent). It is not a belief the proletariat should seize power alone. Please read what Trotsky actually writes on this subject, you will find he came to this conclusion in 1905 and refined it over the years. Lenin would eventually come to the same conclusion independently and that is what aided in Trotsky rejoining the party.

You dont understand the theory of permanent revolution

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

You are an absolutely fabulous professor! I look forward to following your other lectures! Thank you!🙏🙏🙏

amazing going to read the article now

Peterson makes mistakes, but this guy makes mistakes too. For instance, Marx did indeed define "class" in purely economic terms, so it's reasonable to say that Marx in the Manifesto refers to "economic class struggle".

I’ve always thought that one of the best arguments against late communism is that it’s boring due to less conflict. Which isn’t enough to dissuade me (I’m a socialist) but it’s true, if there were a lot less conflict then life would be a lot less entertaining. If we did fix all our class antagonisms and sang kumbaya, then would we not have a lot less to fight for, a lot less to live for, and a lot less to die for.

within the sociopolitical reality of capitalist societies, people are not forced to work for the State... Communism gives the State far too much power based on the presumption that the Ruler will be ethical ... But nothing can be further from the truth.

ای۔پی۔پی صرف قوم کو لوٹنے کے لیے بنائی گئی جو وہ کامیاب ہو رہے ہیں اور قوم سوئ ہوئ ہے جو جو بل اپنی جیب سے ادا کرتا ہے درد اس کو ہوتا ہے گھر کے جتنے آ فراد ان کو محسوس ہی نہیں ہوتا بچوں کی فرمائش سب حکومت چھین کر لے گئ

I am agree with u some points but it is reality in Pakistan no development project cannot approve without powerful hands which always interested in their own goals of earning commission. They never see its futuristic pros and cons in long run to the citizens of Pakistan. They keep always in mind their own interests. They have to pay back in reward on the day of judgement.

This is the first lecturer I've found who truly understands Marx and Gramsci. For some reason the American professors simply can't understand Gramsci

❤❤❤❤

You rock! Thank you for this.

good video... I think Trotsky was wrong as well ... but I came to reject communism entirely... is more about control than helping the peasantry and can only be achieved by using extreme and oppressive force... Communism treats human beings like units but We are not machines we have souls

Thanks for producing all this content. Very informative

Love you 💕❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

❤❤❤❤

“Conplex thoughts of Marx and Engels”, one word sums it up just fine “theft”.

The most awaited video❤

TLP is as greater threat as TTP

I always wonder why is this page so underrated

Sir I can't find any resources to support that Samuel Huntington was an advisor to Pak government. Could you please clarify?

The ending is very funny 😂 ylthis is just part 1

Apne sirf farmers k rujati hone pe bat ki but trotsky ne jo stalinist Beaurcracy ka btaya tha aur jok hua and usne ik internationalist slogan dya k ik connected world market me socialism in one country survive nai kar skta, apne uspe bat nai ki. I appreciate your work alot and respect u alot but u sounded a bit biased to me in this video. And also the wasn't support of peasantry for revolution in china laos cuba in favour of bourgeois reforms rather than a socialist one?

thank you for this

Sir U have best ways to explain complex topics in lucid way. Stay blessed

Humour level 🎚️ teaching 🎚️ just wow❤❤❤❤

What a fantastic explanation of trotskyism. As a Conservative I have been educating myself in socialism to have a better understanding of why people with in Britain want to devalue and demolish the great work that Britain itself has had on our shores and the world. Britain does not need socialism it needs cohesion. All socialism is doing is dividing nations where we should be embracing each other to better understand difference to create a stronger cohesion and change for our future.

Thank you Dr Taimur, this invaluable.

would you say that the Trotskyist view of the proletariat is more often than not Eurocentric?

Ah yes, 👍 I have waited long for more English content. Thank you comrade.

Tlp zindabad Pakistan and

seems copy pasted facts, hardly made any intellectual/genuine effort. It gets harder to ignore with each video of pakistani professionals that key to becoming a professional in pakistan is to have birth in a rich or affluent household then by virtue of your background there is no stopping for a person with a modicum of will power or concentration power. In other words, intellectual minnows have seemingly become 'intellectual' giants

Peasants are like small business owners, they aspire to be lords of their own domain, you can have a revolution with them against the land owners but then you will eventually have to deal with them unless you suppress them with an iron boot. Far better to align with the intellectual bourgeois and socialise capitalism.

Read report of Govt.of imran khan..froze dollar rate .........why now?? Its been discussed since Hubco.

“Free trade” is the cry of the ✡️.

More Power to you Sir.

Love you sir

That was a beautiful speech professor

Chak de fatte... Congratulations Long live Venezuela

❤❤❤❤

Inspiring speech!!!

Red salute from India

Bird's-eye view of the road in Caracas looks like the brick wall of the Warsaw Ghetto dividing the Iron Gate Square with the Aryan Side on the Left n the Jewish Ghetto on the right.

4:54 Palistine flag, not Afghanistan flag (old or new).....

God bless Sir,Red Salute

I met Trotskyists. They live in the cumulus clouds. They do not understand Third World realities.

8:46 Prima Nocta was not a real thing. It's responsible to triple check statements when creating content which is intended to be accepted by a large audience. Edit; rephrased because my original comment made it seem like I was speaking about Marx and Engels specifically

5 minutes in and you already got Trotskyism and permanent revolution wrong.